4-Star Hotels in New York NY

Margaritaville Resort Times Square

Hotel in New York NY

8.7

Very Good

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool Outdoor Pool

Luxury Hotel

Hotel Indigo Lower East Side New York

Hotel in New York NY

7.4

Good

From $241

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Hotel Indigo Lower East Side New York, offers a clean and comfortable stay with friendly staff and a vibrant atmosphere. Located in a great area, the hotel is a superb value for money. Although some guests found the amenities to be lacking, overall, the hotel is exceptional with lovely rooms and a great restaurant nearby. However, it may not be worth the high price for some guests who found the substitute of a $20 minibar credit for breakfast to be a rip off. Despite some minor issues, for most guests, this hotel is a very good choice that they would be happy to come back to.
Show more

Empire Hotel

Hotel in New York NY

6.8

Rated

From $225

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool

Luxury Hotel

Dream Downtown, by Hyatt

Hotel in New York NY

7.4

Good

From $258

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryDream Downtown, by Hyatt is an awesome, very nice party design hotel located in a great location. The hotel has a modern design with nice views and comfy beds. Although some guests found it a little overpriced for what they got, their overall stay was satisfactory. The hotel can sometimes be a bit noisy due to its popular nightlife scene, but it provides a hip spot for those seeking a fun atmosphere. It’s important to note that standard rooms for four people have small beds, so double check the size before booking. Despite having a pretentious vibe, it's a comfortable and nicely located design hotel with good facilities and services.
Show more

Hyatt Centric Times Square New York

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $301

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Hyatt Centric Times Square New York hotel is highly recommended for its exceptional location right in the heart of Times Square. Guests can easily access top entertainment venues making it a great base for sightseeing. The large rooms are comfortable and clean, providing a good value for the price. While some guests found the hotel to be slightly overpriced, the majority enjoyed their stay and the convenience of the central location. The hotel is perfect for families and Christmas Shopping Getaways. However, some guests had negative experiences with the front desk and felt that fees were too high. Overall, the hotel is highly recommended for those looking for a comfortable stay in the heart of the action.
Show more

Hyatt Centric Wall Street New York

Hotel in New York NY

8.3

Very Good

From $245

Info

Enjoy inspiring local experiences – from its neighborhood-centric lounge to its loft-style rooms and eco-friendly spa at the iconic Wall Street hotel.

Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Millennium Downtown New York

Hotel in New York NY

7.4

Good

From $224

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Millennium Downtown New York received mostly positive reviews from guests. Many guests were impressed with the beautiful views from the hotel with some even staying on the 42nd floor. The location of the hotel was also praised with easy access to nearby attractions and friendly staff. While some guests found the decor and facilities outdated, the hotel was still comfortable and clean. However, there were some disappointing experiences reported by a few guests. Overall, the Millennium Downtown New York is a great option for those looking for a hotel with stunning views and friendly staff.
Show more

San Carlos Hotel New York

Hotel in New York NY

8.8

Excellent

From $292

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categorySan Carlos Hotel in New York consistently lives up to its four-star rating, offering guests a delightful and memorable experience. Visitors frequently highlight the hotel's exceptionally spacious and comfortable rooms, which embody a luxurious and modern appeal. The hotel's prime, central location further enhances its allure, making it convenient for both leisure and business travelers.

Positive reviews emphasize the hotel's excellent value for money, noting that it provides good price-quality ratio in this segment. The cleanliness of the rooms, as well as the well-designed and modern bathrooms, often surpass expectations, contributing to an overall positive impression. Guests also appreciate the superb hospitality and the commendable quality of service even during challenging times, such as during the pandemic.

Though a few guests mentioned that some aspects like water pressure in the showers and cleanliness could be improved, these concerns are minor and do not overshadow the overwhelmingly positive feedback. In general, San Carlos Hotel is praised for its affordability relative to other NYC hotels in its category, its beautiful design and its ability to exceed expectations.

The hotel's amenities, despite being slightly pricier, are deemed worth the cost, further cementing its status as a highly recommended stay. Overall, San Carlos Hotel offers a superb four-star hotel experience with its central location, friendly staff and high standards of cleanliness and comfort leaving guests highly satisfied.
Show more

InterContinental New York Times Square, an IHG Hotel

Hotel in New York NY

8.0

Very Good

From $304

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe InterContinental New York Times Square hotel has many positive features according to guest reviews. The suites are comfortable and have all the facilities needed for a pleasant stay. However, some guests expressed dissatisfaction with the breakfast, which they felt did not offer enough variety or fresh ingredients. Additionally, some customers felt disappointed with the level of service, especially in regards to bookings made through external websites. Despite this, most visitors felt that this hotel offered good value for money and was located in a prime location for exploring the city.
Show more

Gild Hall, A Thompson Hotel, by Hyatt

Hotel in New York NY

8.6

Very Good

From $241

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLooking for an elegant hotel with spacious rooms and friendly and accommodating staff? Look no further than Gild Hall, A Thompson Hotel, by Hyatt. Guests rave about the modern rooms with comfortable, big beds and the warm, old English charm of the hotel's decor. Staff members like Robert and Angel go above and beyond to make each guest's stay exceptional with great recommendations for local restaurants and attractions. The hotel's breakfast plan is also a hit, featuring fresh and delicious options like avocado toast. And don't worry about your car - parking is safe and courteous, though it'll cost you $65. With all these positives, it's no surprise guests rave about Gild Hall - a truly great hotel in a prime and quiet location.
Show more

Club Wyndham Midtown 45

Hotel in New York NY

8.2

Very Good

From $234

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Bryant Park Hotel

Hotel in New York NY

8.8

Excellent

From $342

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryIf you're planning a trip to New York City and looking for a hotel that will blow you away, look no further than the Bryant Park Hotel. Located in a beautifully maintained historic building, this hotel offers exceptional value for its central location. Guests rave about the pleasant and comfortable accommodations with particular emphasis placed on the great location and views of Bryant Park. Despite a few negative comments about outdated design and pricing, the Bryant Park Hotel remains a top choice for travelers looking to explore all the city has to offer. Highly recommended!
Show more

Sofitel New York

Hotel in New York NY

7.7

Good

From $320

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Business Hotel

Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection

Hotel in New York NY

8.9

Excellent

From $316

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection is an excellent boutique hotel located in a great location, making it a great place for discerning travelers looking for a lovely stay. Guests highly recommend this hotel and some have expressed plans to book again in the future. The library-themed hotel is charming with excellent facilities and services. While some guests have complained about the pricey nature of the hotel and uncomfortable mattresses, most guests have enjoyed their stay. The hotel's restaurant on the ground floor has received mixed reviews, but the other amenities and services are excellent. However, some guests have missed the amenities and services available before the pandemic cutbacks. Despite some minor complaints, the hotel is overall very good and a recommended destination.
Show more

Hotel Beacon

Hotel in New York NY

8.7

Very Good

From $305

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Beacon is upheld for its quality, offering a service-oriented experience with quick responses from staff. Visitors appreciate the good facilities and clean, well-appointed rooms, boosting its reputation for a central location close to bus stops and subway stations. The suites are noted for their ample storage space, dining table and practical kitchen, perfect for a home-like stay.

Although some guests mention that the hallways and room decor could use updating and don't fully meet four-star expectations, the staff’s exceptional service and friendliness make up for it. Many reviews highlight the hotel as good value for a New York City four-star with stellar amenities that ensure a comfortable and welcoming stay. The hotel feels luxurious and beautifully renovated, akin to a European hotel, though not consistently reaching the contemporary chic expected by some.

Overall, Hotel Beacon is recommended for its clean, safe environment, comfortable size rooms and excellent location in the Upper West Side. It is praised as a very good hotel with good price points and amenities, making it a lovely overall experience for many, who express intentions to stay again.
Show more

The James New York - NoMad

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $223

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe James New York - NoMad presents itself as a modern and classy establishment with a lobby lounge that guests find pleasant. The hotel's location is frequently highlighted as a great asset, making it convenient for travelers. However, opinions diverge regarding its four-star rating. Some guests feel that the accommodations and services align well with what one would expect from a four-star hotel, while others believe it falls short, suggesting that it might be more accurately rated as a three-star property.

Certain elements of the luxury aspect seem slightly outdated and there are mentions of a small lack of equipment which some guests feel should be standard for a hotel of its caliber. Issues such as smelly radiators and an overly strong bleach smell in the rooms have also been pointed out, detracting from the overall experience. Additionally, the coffee service has been noted as an area in need of improvement, especially given the price point of $400 per night.

In summary, while The James New York - NoMad offers good accommodations in a prime location, some aspects could benefit from updates and enhancements to fully meet the expectations of a four-star rating.
Show more

INNSiDE by Meliá New York Nomad

Hotel in New York NY

8.5

Very Good

From $248

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

The Manhattan Club

Hotel in New York NY

8.1

Very Good

From $296

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Concorde Hotel New York

Hotel in New York NY

8.7

Very Good

From $281

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryConcorde Hotel New York has received widespread praise for being reasonably priced and offering great value, especially for a four-star establishment in NYC. Guests have consistently described the hotel as exceptional and very good, frequently noting that it exceeds expectations for a four-star rating. The atmosphere captures the essence of a four-star experience, satisfying most visitors.

Accommodations are consistently highlighted for their cleanliness and style with many guests applauding the newly renovated rooms. The hotel is described as always clean with spotless facilities and attentive, courteous staff. The rooms, despite some being slightly outdated, are well-maintained and offer amazing views from higher floors.

Though there are mentions that the hotel may not meet four-star standards in every aspect, like synthetic pillowcases and some outdated rooms, most guests find the overall standard to be very good. Additional on-site amenities, such as the coffee service on the third floor, further contribute to a positive stay.

Ultimately, Concorde Hotel New York is deemed excellent value for the price, providing clean, quiet accommodations and very good service, making it a worthwhile choice for visitors to the city.
Show more

Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel by Marriott

Hotel in New York NY

8.4

Very Good

From $328

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryRenaissance New York Times Square Hotel by Marriott generally receives mixed opinions regarding its four-star rating. While many guests agree that the hotel is clean and offers comfortable beds, there are differing views on whether the establishment truly meets four-star standards. Several reviews highlight that the hotel provides good value for money considering its prime location and amenities.

Some guests feel the ambiance and decor fit well within a four-star experience, while others believe the aesthetic and service levels fall short of the expected quality. There are multiple mentions of the hotel being comparable to a three to three-and-a-half-star facility, lacking the luxury typically associated with a higher ranking. Comments about the hotel's "factory" feel and middle-class appeal also suggest room for improvement.

Despite some criticisms, many visitors vouch for a pleasant four-star experience, noting the hotel's efforts in maintaining its rating. The value proposition remains strong for many, even if some aspects, such as the breakfast and overall service, may not fully align with four-star expectations.
Show more

*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.

SHOWING 1-20 OUT OF 200+ HOTELS IN AND AROUND NEW YORK

View all hotels in New York.