Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection
Hotel in New York NY
8.8
Excellent
From $366
From $366
4-Star Hotel
As part of the Library Hotel Collection, this hotel offers a unique, book-themed experience with a quiet and comfortable setting. Each floor is dedicated to a different category of knowledge, making it a stimulating and relaxing place to stay.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection is an excellent boutique hotel located in a great location, making it a great place for discerning travelers looking for a lovely stay. Guests highly recommend this hotel and some have expressed plans to book again in the future. The library-themed hotel is charming with excellent facilities and services. While some guests have complained about the pricey nature of the hotel and uncomfortable mattresses, most guests have enjoyed their stay. The hotel's restaurant on the ground floor has received mixed reviews, but the other amenities and services are excellent. However, some guests have missed the amenities and services available before the pandemic cutbacks. Despite some minor complaints, the hotel is overall very good and a recommended destination.
Show more
 
Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection
Hotel in New York NY
9.1
Excellent
From $310
From $310
4-Star Hotel
This hotel provides a cozy and intimate atmosphere, perfect for relaxation. It offers a complimentary breakfast, and the staff is known for providing personalized service, making it a comfortable and high-quality experience.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryNestled in the vibrant heart of Times Square, the Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection emerges as a true gem among New York's bustling hotels. Often described as a charming and unique oasis, it offers a luxurious experience without breaking the bank, making it a great value for money. The hotel’s historic building adds character, blending old-world charm with modern comforts, appealing to those who appreciate both the past and present.

The standout feature of the Casablanca Hotel is undoubtedly its exceptional service. Guests consistently praise the 5-star staff for their professionalism and warmth. From cheerful greetings at the reception to attentive interactions throughout the hotel, the staff make every guest feel right at home and valued. They are known for their eagerness to assist, ensuring that all needs are met promptly and with a smile.

While breakfast offerings might fall short for a 4-star hotel, the all-day availability of the café on the second floor is a much-appreciated amenity, offering a cozy spot to enjoy coffee, snacks, or a simple bite amid a busy day of sightseeing. Additionally, the complimentary wine and cheese evenings add a delightful touch to the overall experience.

The hotel's location presents another significant advantage. It places guests within easy walking distance of iconic New York attractions, including theatres, Bryant Park, and prime shopping spots. Visitors often express their intent to return, citing the Casablanca Hotel as one of their favorite stays in New York. With its unbeatable combination of location, charm, and service, it indeed stands out as a first-class choice for those visiting the city.
Show more
 
Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection
Hotel in New York NY
9.0
Excellent
From $388
From $388
4-Star Hotel
Part of the Library Hotel Collection, Hotel Giraffe provides a blend of elegance and comfort with a focus on hospitality. The hotel features spacious rooms and a rooftop garden, ensuring a memorable and high-quality stay.
Show more
 
Hotel Elysee by Library Hotel Collection
Hotel in New York NY
8.7
Very Good
From $334
From $334
4-Star Hotel
Part of the Library Hotel Collection, Hotel Elysee offers a luxurious and comfortable stay with a focus on personalized service. Its elegant ambiance and prime location make it a top choice.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Elysee by Library Hotel Collection offers an exceptional experience often described as more than deserving of its star rating. Its location is ideal, just a mere five-minute walk from the bustling 5th Avenue, offering both convenience and the charming character of an old-world, European boutique hotel. Guests appreciate the quaint and classy atmosphere, which differs greatly from the impersonality of global chain hotels.

The hotel is noted for its spacious rooms adorned with tasteful decor, as well as the overall elegance and character that make a stay here memorable. The dining experience is also a highlight, with a variety of delightful offerings including cappuccino that guests enjoy. The attentive staff further enhances the experience, contributing to the seamless service and comfort provided throughout the hotel.

While some mention the structure's age and its attraction to an elderly clientele, the overall ambiance is that of warmth and sophistication, often outshining its four-star designation. Hotel Elysee stands as a wonderful boutique option in the city, offering superb value for money in a memorably picturesque setting.
Show more
 
Archer Hotel New York
Hotel in New York NY
8.8
Excellent
From $314
From $314
4-Star Hotel
This hotel features a modern design with a focus on comfort and style. It is known for its handcrafted cocktails and personalized service.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryArcher Hotel New York has received positive feedback from guests, scoring an average of 9.00 out of 10. The hotel's location is perfect with excellent choices of food places just across the street and cocktails at Havana bar. The staff are wonderful, friendly and helpful. The hotel is lovely and clean and the rooms are comfortable despite being small. The decor of the rooms and the overall quality of the hotel are good. Guests love the incredible views of the Empire State Building from the rooftop bar, which is also known for its delicious food. Some guests have pointed out small negatives, such as the slightly loud air conditioning and the occasional tardiness of the cleaners. However, the hotel is still recommended for its security and cleanliness, as well as being a great choice for a mid-town stay.
Show more
 
Bryant Park Hotel
Hotel in New York NY
9.2
Excellent
From $373
From $373
4-Star Hotel
Located next to Bryant Park, this hotel offers luxurious accommodations and excellent service. Its prime location and elegant design make it a top choice for a comfortable and high-quality stay.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryIf you're planning a trip to New York City and looking for a hotel that will blow you away, look no further than the Bryant Park Hotel. Located in a beautifully maintained historic building, this hotel offers exceptional value for its central location. Guests rave about the pleasant and comfortable accommodations with particular emphasis placed on the great location and views of Bryant Park. Despite a few negative comments about outdated design and pricing, the Bryant Park Hotel remains a top choice for travelers looking to explore all the city has to offer. Highly recommended!
Show more
 
Walker Hotel Greenwich Village
Hotel in New York NY
8.2
Very Good
From $366
From $366
4-Star Hotel
Capturing the spirit of Golden Age New York, this hotel is inspired by the Georgian revival towers of 1920s Fifth Avenue. It offers a unique and stylish stay in the heart of Greenwich Village.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Walker Hotel Greenwich Village offers a refined and elegant atmosphere typical of a four-star establishment. Guests have praised its luxurious vibes and fun environment, enhancing the overall stay experience. The facilities provided contribute to the hotel's good value and are consistent with the expectations for its rating. While the hotel is generally well-regarded, some guests felt that the staff's competence did not fully align with the boutique hotel's four-star status. Despite this, the Walker Hotel remains a very nice choice for those seeking a sophisticated stay in Greenwich Village.
Show more
 
Ace Hotel New York
Hotel in New York NY
7.5
Good
From $255
From $255
4-Star Hotel
This hotel offers a trendy and artistic vibe with its minimalist design and vintage-inspired decor. It is a popular spot for creative types and features a lively lobby scene.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryAce Hotel New York is a solid choice for travelers seeking a blend of comfort and affordability. The rooms provide ample space, creating a sense of ease for guests. While some may question its adherence to a four-star standard, the hotel often conveys a four-star ambiance and provides four-star service and amenities, ensuring a satisfying stay for most visitors.

Cleanliness is a notable strength, especially in the bathroom, which is consistently well-maintained. Guests frequently highlight the reasonable pricing and overall good value for money, making it a practical option for those looking for quality without excessive expenditure.

In summary, Ace Hotel New York offers a commendable balance of comfort, service and value, appealing to those who appreciate a straightforward yet pleasant hotel experience.
Show more
 
The Maritime Hotel
Hotel in New York NY
8.6
Very Good
From $300
From $300
4-Star Hotel
With its nautical-themed decor and prime location in Chelsea, The Maritime Hotel offers a unique and stylish experience. The comfortable rooms and attentive service ensure a pleasant stay.
Show more
 
The Renwick
Hotel in New York NY
8.4
Very Good
4-Star Hotel
This hotel provides a unique artistic theme, with rooms designed to reflect the creative spirit of its namesake artists. It offers comfortable accommodations and a distinctive atmosphere.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Renwick stands out as a charming boutique hotel ideally located just steps from Grand Central Station, making it a perfect base for exploring New York City's most iconic attractions. Many guests appreciate the hotel's great value, noting that its price-quality ratio is fair given its prime Manhattan location. The comfortable rooms and excellent service contribute to a pleasant stay, with many guests feeling safe, welcome, and well taken care of.

Housekeeping receives positive remarks for maintaining spotlessly clean rooms, further enhancing the comfort factor. Guests often highlight the breathtaking views of the Empire State Building, especially from higher floors, adding to the hotel's appeal. Despite some criticism about the hotel not quite matching a traditional 4-star standard, many still highly recommend it for its excellent location, attentive staff, and the tranquility offered by its boutique size.

The Renwick is praised for its welcoming staff and chic ambiance, though some guests have noted room for improvements in service and amenities that typically come with a 4-star rating, such as a restaurant and in-room coffee or tea facilities. Additionally, a few guests mention minor inconveniences, such as inconsistent bathroom amenities and the absence of a bar and restaurant.

Overall, The Renwick offers a delightful boutique experience with a prime location, making it a recommended choice for both leisure and business travelers who value a unique, intimate atmosphere over standard chain hotel options.
Show more
 
The Ludlow Hotel
Hotel in New York NY
9.0
Excellent
From $436
From $436
4-Star Hotel
Located in the Lower East Side, The Ludlow offers rooms with spectacular views of the city's skyscrapers and bridges. It provides a unique and stylish experience with free WiFi in each guestroom.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Ludlow Hotel delivers a luxuriously comfortable experience that aligns well with its four-star rating. The service stands out as top-notch, enhancing the overall stay to match the expectations of a four-star hotel. Guests frequently describe the hotel as almost luxury, indicating that while it may not reach full luxury status, it comes very close. The facilities and ambiance provide a luxury feel, albeit the rooms are noted to be somewhat smaller than anticipated. Despite the high prices, these are considered reflective of the four-star standard and the quality offered. Overall, The Ludlow Hotel is praised as a great choice for those seeking excellent service and comfort within this price point.
Show more
 
citizenM New York Times Square
Hotel in New York NY
8.8
Excellent
From $283
From $283
4-Star Hotel
This hotel provides a modern and tech-savvy experience with its stylish rooms and innovative amenities. It is located in the heart of Times Square and offers a rooftop bar with panoramic views.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryCitizenM New York Times Square offers a modern and sleek concept that garners largely positive feedback for its clean and comfortable rooms and pleasant staff. The hotel's excellent location, just steps from the subway, adds to its appeal, making it a fantastic value for the price. The amenities and facilities are generally rated as four-star quality, bringing a high cost-performance ratio that makes it a great choice for travelers.

The hotel does, however, present a few shortcomings. Some guests felt that the service and amenities, while commendable, were somewhat basic for a four-star rating. The rooms, although modern and comfortable, were noted to be smaller than expected for a property of this caliber. Breakfast offerings also received critiques for not meeting the four-star standard, leaving some guests wanting more.

Despite these areas for improvement, the overall sentiment is that CitizenM provides a good balance between cost and quality, delivering a four-star experience with modern, clean amenities and a prime location. The creative touches, such as adjustable modern lights and artistic design, contribute to the hotel's unique charm, making it a solid option for those visiting New York City.
Show more
 
Hotel Beacon
Hotel in New York NY
8.8
Excellent
From $282
From $282
4-Star Hotel
Hotel Beacon is known for its spacious rooms, many of which include kitchenettes, making it a comfortable option for longer stays. Its Upper West Side location offers a quieter atmosphere with easy access to Central Park.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Beacon is upheld for its quality, offering a service-oriented experience with quick responses from staff. Visitors appreciate the good facilities and clean, well-appointed rooms, boosting its reputation for a central location close to bus stops and subway stations. The suites are noted for their ample storage space, dining table and practical kitchen, perfect for a home-like stay.

Although some guests mention that the hallways and room decor could use updating and don't fully meet four-star expectations, the staff’s exceptional service and friendliness make up for it. Many reviews highlight the hotel as good value for a New York City four-star with stellar amenities that ensure a comfortable and welcoming stay. The hotel feels luxurious and beautifully renovated, akin to a European hotel, though not consistently reaching the contemporary chic expected by some.

Overall, Hotel Beacon is recommended for its clean, safe environment, comfortable size rooms and excellent location in the Upper West Side. It is praised as a very good hotel with good price points and amenities, making it a lovely overall experience for many, who express intentions to stay again.
Show more
 
The Standard, High Line New York
Hotel in New York NY
7.9
Good
From $387
From $387
4-Star Hotel
The Standard is a hip property in the Meatpacking District. It is home to The Standard Biergarten, the triple threat rooftop terrace (Le Bain dance club, cocktail bar and pool), as well as some of the best views in the city.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Standard, High Line New York boasts a strong four-star rating and offers a luxurious feel with its aesthetically pleasing design and clean rooms. The hotel has garnered positive feedback for maintaining a four-star ambiance and providing an overall very good experience. However, some reviews suggest that the hotel needs some maintenance and re-vamping to meet the expected standards, especially when compared to other four-star hotels. Despite this, the hotel remains expensive but without significant complaints, suggesting that the overall experience and facilities justify the cost. The ambiance and cleanliness of the hotel align well with a four-star rating, though it may fall short of European standards. Overall, The Standard, High Line New York is a noteworthy option for those seeking a visually appealing and clean accommodation.
Show more
 
Park South Hotel, part of JdV by Hyatt
Hotel in New York NY
8.6
Very Good
From $316
From $316
4-Star Hotel
This hotel is in a great location and has a rich history, oozing from every corner thanks to a mezzanine library stocked with Gotham-centric tomes as well as exclusive black-and-white prints from the New York Historical Society.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryPark South Hotel, part of JdV by Hyatt, offers an exceptional hotel experience that leaves a lasting impression on its guests. Nestled in a great location, the hotel provides easy access to the vibrant city of New York, making it a convenient choice for travelers. Guests frequently praise the hotel for its clean rooms and comfortable beds, contributing to a restful stay. The staff consistently receives accolades for their friendly and helpful demeanor, ensuring that each guest feels welcome and well-cared for. A notable feature of the hotel is its rooftop bar, which offers a delightful ambiance and is highly recommended by visitors. Those who have stayed at Park South Hotel express a strong desire to return, whether for pleasure or another visit, underscoring the hotel's well-deserved reputation. It's no wonder that the hotel holds an impressive rating on Expedia, reflecting its commitment to quality and guest satisfaction.
Show more
 
Hotel 48LEX New York
Hotel in New York NY
7.6
Good
From $286
From $286
4-Star Hotel
This hotel offers spacious suites with kitchenettes and separate living areas, perfect for extended stays. It features a convenient location in Midtown East and personalized service.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLocated in a bustling area in Manhattan, Hotel 48LEX New York is praised for its central location, making it an excellent base for exploring the city. Guests often highlight the friendly and accommodating staff, adding a touch of warmth and welcoming atmosphere to their stay. For a city hotel, the property is relatively spacious, offering an upscale boutique experience. The hotel's second-floor lounge, featuring a happy hour, is noted as a pleasant perk that guests appreciate. The Lexington Brass provides added value with its prix fixe menu, offering a substantial dining experience for hotel guests.

Despite these positives, several areas for improvement are evident in guest feedback, particularly regarding the four-star rating. Some visitors feel the service and facilities fall short of expectations for such a rating, with housekeeping issues and breakfast service notably mentioned. Although the housekeeping issues were addressed during stays, there remains a sense that the overall service does not fully meet four-star standards. This perception of value for money seems to be a mixed experience among guests. Overall, while Hotel 48LEX New York offers good value in a prime location, certain aspects such as service execution and breakfast need attention to fully align with four-star expectations.
Show more
 
Lombardy Hotel
Aparthotel in New York NY
8.5
Very Good
From $320
From $320
4-Star AparthotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLombardy Hotel offers a mix of experiences for its guests. The accommodations are noted for being clean and spacious, which provide a comfortable stay. The service largely meets four-star expectations, ensuring a satisfactory experience for visitors. Additionally, the hotel's prime location is a notable advantage for travelers.

However, there are significant drawbacks. Many guests observed that the hotel and its rooms appear considerably older than depicted online, showing signs of age and not living up to the four-star standard. Some found the high price point for their stay, particularly at $500 a night, to be unjustifiable given the perceived quality. This disparity has led some to suggest the hotel aligns more closely with a two-star rating. Despite the generally good service, the overall perceived value and outdated appearance of the hotel rooms remain points of contention among guests.
Show more
 
Hotel Belleclaire Central Park
Hotel in New York NY
8.3
Very Good
From $281
From $281
4-Star Hotel
This hotel provides a comfortable and convenient stay on the Upper West Side, near Central Park. It features well-appointed rooms and a friendly atmosphere.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Belleclaire Central Park, located on the beautiful Upper West Side, feels quite high-end, boasting classic architecture and a charming ambiance. The property's proximity to the subway and its classic décor create a comfortable and convenient stay for guests, while its renowned adjacent French bakery sweetens the experience with generous breakfast vouchers.

Guests repeatedly note the chic and renovated interiors, efficient and helpful staff, quiet air conditioning and well-maintained cleanliness of the bathrooms. These touches contribute to its solid four-star rating and offer good value for money. Many reviewers deem the hotel very good with appropriate value for the price paid with no complaints about the four-star rating.

However, there are mentions of minor areas needing improvement to fully match its four-star status. Some feel it is closer to a three-star experience due to issues like the poor breakfast quality and specific service limitations. The ongoing renovations also affect guest experience, reducing the overall four-star charm temporarily.

Despite these inconsistencies, the hotel remains a lovely historic spot with a refined atmosphere, combining excellent location, commendable services and satisfactory accommodations into an overall solid four-star experience for visitors.
Show more
 
Soho Grand Hotel
Hotel in New York NY
8.4
Very Good
From $406
From $406
4-Star Hotel
This luxury boutique hotel in Manhattan offers stylish and spacious rooms that reflect the creative energy of the neighborhood. With high-style gathering places like the Grand Bar & Salon and Soho Diner, it provides a vibrant and comfortable experience.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Soho Grand Hotel strikes a balance between style and functionality, living up to its four-star designation. Many guests found the hotel's stylish design and decor impressive, creating a visually appealing environment. The location is often highlighted as perfect, making it convenient for visitors to explore the surrounding areas. The hotel offers the comforts expected from a four-star establishment, ensuring a generally satisfying stay for its guests.

However, feedback on service highlighted some inconsistency and slower response times, suggesting room for improvement in customer service. Additionally, while the hotel satisfies in various aspects, some guests felt that for its four-star rating, soundproofing and pricing could be improved to better meet personal expectations. Despite these minor setbacks, the overall experience at the Soho Grand Hotel remains aligned with its four-star category, providing an excellent stay for many.
Show more
 
The Empire Hotel New York
Hotel in New York NY
6.7
Rated
From $226
From $226
4-Star Hotel
Located on the Upper West Side near Lincoln Center and Central Park, this iconic hotel mirrors the elegance and modernity of its surroundings. The stylish Art Deco rooms and vibrant rooftop bar provide an authentic Manhattan experience.
Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in New York.
Categories:
  •     4 Star (246)
  •     Luxury (207)
  •     Accessible (186)
  •     Gym (186)
  •     Business (180)
  •     Honeymoon (167)
  •     Dog Friendly (164)
  •     Nightlife (157)
  •     Parking (151)
  •     Romantic (144)
  •     Family (141)
  •     Sustainability Journey (89)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (45)
  •     Skyscraper (29)
  •     Small (27)
  •     EV charging stations (17)
  •     Historic (13)
  •     Cheap (12)
  •     Pool (11)
  •     Boutique-Style (10)
  •     Outdoor Pool (8)
  •     Dogs Stay Free (5)
  •     Yoga (4)
  •     Heated Pool (4)
  •     Spa (3)
  •     Adult Only (3)
  •     Golf (3)
  •     Health & Safety (2)
  •     Indoor Pool (2)
  •     Panoramic View Pool (1)
  •     Rooftop Pool (1)
  •     Haunted (1)
  •     Tennis (1)
  •     Unusual (1)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ