The Pridwin Hotel
Hotel in Shelter Island NY
9.0
Excellent
From $436
From $436
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym
Hotel near Golf Courses
Show more
 
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island NY
9.9
Excellent
From $365
From $365
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool
Bed & Breakfast with Gym
Bed & Breakfast for Yoga

Show more
 
21 more hotels nearby!
Dering Harbor Inn 1.1 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
From $8
From $8
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
The Harbor Front Inn 2.6 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
8.4
Very Good
From $235
From $235
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
Greenporter Hotel 2.7 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
8.2
Very Good
From $195
From $195
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
Hotel Moraine 3.6 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Greenport NY
9.6
Excellent
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
Baron's Cove 5.1 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Sag Harbor NY
8.4
Very Good
From $421
From $421
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
EHP Resort & Marina 8.8 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in East Hampton NY
8.5
Very Good
From $405
From $405
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Private Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
East Hampton House Resort 11.2 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in East Hampton NY
8.6
Very Good
From $345
From $345
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
Canoe Place Inn & Cottages 15.4 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Hampton Bays NY
8.9
Excellent
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
Water's Edge Resort & Spa 15.5 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Westbrook CT
8.6
Very Good
From $240
From $240
Info Categories
Resort with Outdoor Pool

Resort with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Gym

Beachfront Resort

Show more
 
Waters Edge Resort and Spa TimeShare 15.5 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Westbrook CT
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
The Hermitage at Napeague 16.0 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Amagansett NY
9.0
Excellent
From $225
From $225
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
Driftwood Resort on the Ocean 16.7 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
8.5
Very Good
From $219
From $219
Info Categories
Resort with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Gym

Beachfront Resort

Show more
 
Bayview Resort 17.8 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Hampton Bays NY
7.9
Good
From $207
From $207
Info Categories
Resort with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Gym

Resort near Golf Courses

Show more
 
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 18.3 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
8.0
Very Good
From $661
From $661
Info Categories
Resort with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Gym

Resort with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
Hyatt Place Long Island East End 19.7 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Riverhead NY
8.7
Very Good
From $178
From $178
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Family Friendly Hotel

Show more
 
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk 19.8 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.6
Very Good
From $207
From $207
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Gym

Hotel with Rooms With Fireplace

Show more
 
Montauk Manor 20.2 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.7
Very Good
From $170
From $170
Info Categories
Hotel with Outdoor Pool

Hotel with Gym

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Hotel

Show more
 
The Surf Club Resort 20.8 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
8.0
Very Good
From $452
From $452
Info Categories
Resort with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Gym

Resort near Golf Courses

Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
Categories:
  •     Gym (23)
  •     Outdoor Pool (23)
  •     Pool (23)
  •     Heated Pool (10)
  •     Indoor Pool (6)
  •     Private Pool (1)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (1)
  •     Family (20)
  •     Parking (16)
  •     Honeymoon (14)
  •     Accessible (13)
  •     Golf (12)
  •     Tennis (12)
  •     Business (12)
  •     Dog Friendly (9)
  •     Yoga (8)
  •     Spa (7)
  •     3 Star (7)
  •     Beach (6)
  •     EV charging stations (6)
  •     Romantic (5)
  •     Sustainability Journey (5)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (5)
  •     Small (5)
  •     Beachfront (4)
  •     4 Star (3)
  •     Luxury (3)
  •     5 Star (2)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (2)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Boutique-Style (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
3
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ