Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Cheap, 3-Star Hotels in Butler

10 HOTELS IN AND AROUND BUTLERRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
10 hotels nearby!
Hotel Moca NYC main photo
Hotel Moca NYC
23.7 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
5.1
Rated
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Hotel Moca NYC receives a mixed array of reviews, with several positive aspects highlighted by guests. The hotel's location is a significant advantage, praised for its convenience and easy access to public transportation, including nearby subway stations and bus stops. This strategic position offers guests the ability to quickly reach various parts of Manhattan, making it an ideal base for exploring New York City. Furthermore, its proximity to notable attractions like Yankee Stadium adds to its appeal, offering good value for money, particularly for those looking to prioritize accessibility.

The hotel’s accommodations offer a varied experience. Many guests enjoy the comfortable beds, frequently recommending the hotel for its restful sleep quality. The rooms, however, receive mixed feedback. While some appreciate the cleanliness and amenities provided, others point out areas needing improvement, such as occasional maintenance issues and unclean spaces. Despite these concerns, the rooms with nice views are a pleasing feature for some visitors.

Staff interactions at Hotel Moca NYC elicit diverse responses. Certain guests compliment the staff for their helpfulness and professionalism, with some employees demonstrating a commitment to enhancing guest experiences. Yet, others highlight inconsistency in service quality, noting issues with unprofessionalism and a lack of readiness to assist, which poses a challenge in delivering a uniformly positive hospitality experience.

Cleanliness remains a crucial area requiring attention. The hotel has received numerous negative remarks regarding its hygiene standards, with reports of dirty rooms, unpleasant odors, and maintenance shortcomings. These issues detract from guest comfort and indicate a need for enhanced cleaning procedures.

Despite these varied experiences, Hotel Moca NYC stands out for its location and sleep comfort, suitable for travelers focused on these aspects. However, potential guests should remain aware of the consistent feedback concerning room condition and service quality when booking their stay.
Categories
Cheap
3 Star
Small
Night Hotel Broadway main photo
Night Hotel Broadway
23.9 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.1
Good
From $164
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Night Hotel Broadway is praised primarily for its exceptional location on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, providing effortless access to Times Square and other popular destinations via the 96th Street subway station. Guests appreciate the convenience of nearby amenities such as Central Park, numerous dining options, cafes and retail shops, all contributing to a vibrant yet relatively tranquil atmosphere.

The spacious and comfortable rooms receive mixed reviews regarding their condition. While many guests appreciated the size, good views and cleanliness maintained through daily housekeeping, there were recurring complaints about outdated furnishings, dirty carpets and faulty fixtures. Some guests reported issues like cigarette and musty odors, cockroach sightings and inadequate renovation, indicating a need for substantial improvements.

Cleanliness overall also received varied feedback. Several guests noted the regular changing of bed sheets and towels and the cleanliness of bathrooms and common areas. However, problems such as stained carpets, unpleasant smells and lack of thorough cleaning in hallways and elevators were frequently mentioned. Improvement in maintenance and more rigorous cleaning protocols are necessary to meet guest expectations fully.

The staff at
Night Hotel Broadway garnered generally positive reviews. Many guests found the staff friendly, helpful and professional with a few standout individuals like CeCe and Justin being specifically praised for their exceptional service. Despite a few instances of rude or indifferent interactions, the staff's overall performance significantly contributed to a pleasant guest experience.

Issues were noted with the hotel's Wi-Fi service with many guests finding it unreliable and slow, especially in the rooms. Positive feedback was minimal and mostly mentioned good connectivity close to the modem. This suggests that substantial improvements in internet service are needed.

Parking at
Night Hotel Broadway received mixed reviews. While some appreciated the attached garage and reserved spots, many found the parking to be expensive and limited. The provided vouchers often did not cover the cost and the garage's location was sometimes inconvenient for guests.

For families, the hotel offers large beds and spacious rooms adequate for family stays with amenities like bathtubs useful for small children. Despite these positives, safety concerns and instances of smoking on adjacent floors were noted, indicating areas needing attention to better accommodate families.

Regarding bed comfort, feedback was mixed with many finding the beds comfortable and clean and others pointing out issues with outdated and sagging mattresses. The general sentiment was that while some beds met standard expectations, others needed better maintenance and updates.

Night Hotel Broadway is described as a basic three-star hotel ideal for budget-conscious travelers, offering reasonable value for money thanks to its strategic location and friendly service. While its facilities and amenities did not exceed basic three-star expectations, the hotel excels in offering accessibility, particularly given its proximity to transportation options. Recommendations for improvements focus on upgrading room conditions and amenities, enhancing cleanliness throughout the property and improving internet service. Overall, Night Hotel Broadway presents itself as a practical choice for visitors seeking affordability and convenience during their NYC stay.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Honeymoon
HI New York City Hostel main photo
HI New York City Hostel
23.9 mi from Butler
Hostel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $55
$
Info
Summary of reviews
HI New York City Hostel in Manhattan earns glowing reviews for its prime location, conveniently close to Central Park, multiple subway stations and key landmarks like Times Square and Riverside Park. The Upper West Side neighborhood adds to its charm, offering a range of dining, shopping and recreational options within a safe and vibrant atmosphere. Its accessibility to public transportation further strengthens its appeal for tourists seeking an efficient base for exploring New York City.

The hostel doesn't include complimentary breakfast but compensates with an on-site café that serves a varied and affordable menu, including popular options like chicken chipotle and Mexican deli sandwiches. Although there are some minor complaints about the lack of diverse food options and occasional issues with food quality, the well-equipped kitchen and nearby grocery stores provide ample alternatives. The dining options, including a pleasant garden and patio area, generally receive positive feedback for their convenience and quality.

Accommodation at
HI New York City Hostel is described as clean and spacious with particular praise for the diligent maintenance of both private and communal spaces. Guests find the beds comfortable and the presence of spacious lockers adds a sense of security. However, occasional issues with ventilation, temperature control and minor cleanliness lapses are noted. Despite this, the overall value is deemed fair given the strategic location and amenities.

The hostel excels in cleanliness with constant upkeep of bathrooms, showers and common areas consistently highlighted in guest reviews. The staff's friendliness and helpfulness significantly contribute to the hostel’s appeal, despite occasional reports of unprofessionalism and inefficiency. Most guests find the staff to be accommodating and hospitable.

The free Wi-Fi is generally reliable and fast, although some areas, particularly the 4th floor and dorm rooms, experience connectivity issues. Nevertheless, it meets the basic needs of most guests.

The social atmosphere at
HI New York City Hostel is another strong point, characterized by numerous planned evening activities such as karaoke nights, stand-up comedy shows and pub crawls. These events create a collegiate environment that encourages interaction and the formation of new friendships. The nearby dive bars offer additional nightlife options, complementing the hostel’s social activities.

Overall,
HI New York City Hostel stands out for its excellent location, cleanliness, comfortable accommodations and engaging social programs. While there are some areas for improvement, such as air conditioning noise and occasional lapses in staff responsiveness, the hostel remains a highly recommended, budget-friendly option for travelers looking to explore New York City.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Nightlife
La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park main photo
La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park
24.4 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
6.0
Rated
From $193
$
Info
Summary of reviews
La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park offers a commendable stay for travelers seeking a convenient and accessible location in Manhattan. Nestled in the heart of the Upper West Side, the hotel's proximity to Central Park and nearby subway stations makes it an ideal starting point for exploring the city's attractions, museums, and cultural landmarks. Guests particularly appreciate the peaceful and safe neighborhood, complemented by a variety of dining options.

Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and attentive staff, with many guests praising specific team members for their exceptional service, particularly during breakfast. The breakfast itself, included in the room rate, is positively regarded for its variety and value, despite some limitations in options for special diets. The small breakfast area is offset by the warmth and courtesy of the staff, enhancing the overall morning experience.

While the rooms are notably small, they are generally maintained clean and equipped with basic amenities such as flat-screen TVs and comfortable beds. However, the dated decor and occasional maintenance issues detract from the comfort. These compact accommodations are suited for guests who plan to spend more time exploring the city.

Cleanliness across the hotel is a mixed bag, with some areas requiring refurbishment and upkeep. Despite this, the staff's diligence in addressing these shortfalls is appreciated by many. The WiFi service, although free, is reported to have inconsistencies depending on the room's location.

The hotel presents a family-friendly environment in terms of location, though room size and safety concerns may limit its appeal to certain family groups. The comfortable beds receive praise for ensuring a restful night's sleep, contributing positively to the overall experience.

Overall, La Quinta by Wyndham New York City Central Park is a reasonable choice for travelers prioritizing location and value. While it is a three-star hotel with some areas needing improvement, its excellent position and welcoming staff make it a practical and budget-friendly option for a short city break in New York City.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Family
The Central Park North main photo
The Central Park North
24.4 mi from Butler
Guest House in New York NYUS flag
7.9
Good
From $129
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Central Park North is celebrated for its strategic location and exceptional staff service, providing significant value for a stay in New York City. Nestled at the north edge of Central Park, its proximity to iconic landmarks and nearby subway lines makes it a prime location for exploring the city. Despite the occasionally colorful urban setting of Harlem, guests generally find the environment safe and authentic, with easy access to local dining and shopping options.

Guest reviews highlight the hotel's well-maintained cleanliness, setting high standards across rooms and shared spaces. The rooms, albeit occasionally noted for limited space, are praised for their decor and functionality, with features like kitchenettes greatly benefiting longer stays. While some guests face minor inconveniences with temperature control, the room's comfort and coziness are frequently lauded.

The hotel staff is another standout feature, consistently praised for their friendliness and willingness to assist, contributing significantly to the welcoming atmosphere. Staff members, including the hotel manager, are commended for their attentiveness and problem-solving skills, enhancing the overall guest experience.

Contrary to the generally positive feedback, there are a few notes on the variability of bed comfort and room temperature control issues, but these do not overshadow the core offerings. Ultimately, The Central Park North provides a genuine New York experience with clean accommodations, exemplary service, and an unbeatable location, making it a compelling choice for travelers.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Small
West Side YMCA main photo
West Side YMCA
24.5 mi from Butler
Hostel in New York NYUS flag
6.7
Rated
From $112
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The West Side YMCA is a highly valued budget accommodation in the heart of Manhattan, catering to travelers seeking to explore New York City without breaking the bank. Renowned for its unbeatable location, the YMCA is just steps away from Central Park and within walking distance of major attractions such as Broadway, Lincoln Center and Times Square. The surrounding neighborhood is vibrant yet safe, filled with cafes, shops and entertainment venues. The convenience of nearby public transportation, especially the Columbus Circle Subway Station, makes it an ideal base for exploring the city's cultural and touristic hotspots.

Guests highlight the exceptional value for money provided by this location, which offers access to Midtown Manhattan at a fraction of the typical cost. The hostel's amenities, though basic, are regarded by many as adequate considering the central location. While the rooms are generally described as simple and sometimes outdated, the air conditioning and essential amenities like towels, soap and mini-fridges are appreciated. The beds receive mixed reviews with some guests finding them comfortable while others note issues with mattress quality and bedding.

A significant perk of staying at the
West Side YMCA is the access to comprehensive fitness facilities. The enormous, well-equipped gym includes a full-size basketball court, spinning machines, course rooms, weight rooms, an indoor track, a sauna, a steam room and an amazing pool. These facilities are praised for their maintenance and variety, adding notable value to the guest experience. The pool area is particularly well-liked, offering a clean and pleasant environment for swimming with additional amenities such as changing rooms, lockers and a sauna.

Cleanliness in shared spaces and common areas, as well as the diligence of the cleaning staff, is frequently commended. However, the cleanliness of individual rooms receives mixed feedback with some guests reporting issues such as dirt, dust and occasional pests. Shared bathrooms generally fare better, being cleaned daily and well-maintained, though more thorough and frequent cleaning is suggested.

The staff's performance also receives mixed reviews with many guests praising their friendliness, knowledge and helpfulness, especially the cleaning staff. Nonetheless, there are reports of inconsistent customer service with some guests finding the front desk and reception staff rude or unhelpful.

Free Wi-Fi is another area with notable variation in guest experiences. While some laud the Wi-Fi's speed and reliability, others find it sporadic and difficult to access, particularly in their rooms.

Overall, the
West Side YMCA stands out as a highly accessible, central and value-oriented choice for budget-conscious travelers who prioritize location. With its extensive fitness facilities, convenient location and overall safety, it presents a compelling option despite some trade-offs in room quality and service consistency.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Nightlife
Pod Times Square main photo
Pod Times Square
24.6 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $178
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Pod Times Square enjoys a stellar reputation for its prime location, placing guests within an ideal hub for exploring New York City. Its proximity to Times Square, numerous subway stations, bus terminals and major attractions like Broadway theaters and Central Park is frequently praised. Guests appreciate the vibrant neighborhood filled with nearby restaurants and stores, emphasizing the hotel’s convenience and safety.

The rooms, while compact, are well-designed to maximize space, making them suitable for short stays or solo travelers. They are often commended for their cleanliness, modern amenities, cozy beds and powerful showers. Despite their small size and limited storage, the rooms are considered practical and efficient. The cleanliness extends to the communal areas with guests often noting the hotel’s superior standards compared to other economy options.

The staff at
Pod Times Square receive high marks for their friendliness and helpfulness. Guests highlight the exceptional customer service, noting the staff’s polite and professional demeanor across all interactions, from the front desk to the concierge.

The hotel's restaurant and bar, offering lovely rooftop views, provide a pleasant dining experience albeit with some noted limitations in variety and service hours. Breakfast service, however, is an area needing improvement with calls for complimentary options and better organization. Nearby delis and cafés, including recommendations like 'Juniors,' offer alternative breakfast options.

Pod Times Square is also noted for being family-friendly with practical bunk bed arrangements that make the compact rooms more accommodating. Families find the hotel suitable for weekend trips and shorter stays, appreciating the central location for easy city exploration.

The hotel’s complimentary Wi-Fi generally receives positive feedback for its reliability and speed, further enhancing the guest experience.

In summary,
Pod Times Square is recognized for its excellent location, high cleanliness standards, friendly staff and functional room designs. While not meeting traditional luxury standards, it offers a stylish and modern ambiance at a reasonable price, making it a solid choice for travelers seeking practicality and central access to New York City's attractions.
Categories
Cheap
3 Star
Dog Friendly
JGSTAY - Times Square main photo
JGSTAY - Times Square
24.7 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.5
Good
From $214
$
Info
Summary of reviews
JGSTAY - Times Square, a Travelodge by Wyndham, receives notable praise for its unrivaled central location in Manhattan, positioning guests within easy reach of iconic landmarks such as Times Square, Broadway theaters and an array of dining options. This prime spot offers excellent connectivity via public transport, making it an ideal base for exploring New York City.

The rooms, though consistently small, are appreciated for their functionality and comfort. Recent renovations have ensured that they are well-decorated and practical with necessary amenities such as clean towels, good water pressure in the bathrooms and mini refrigerators. Despite the limited space and occasional issues like insufficient soundproofing and lack of natural light, the room rates are considered reasonable, especially given the hotel's central location.

Cleanliness at the hotel is a mixed bag. Upon arrival, many guests find their rooms to be clean and modern. However, the consistency of housekeeping services during stays has been a point of contention with some guests reporting that their rooms were not cleaned unless specifically requested. This inconsistency sometimes results in issues such as dirty sheets, dust buildup and other cleanliness lapses, though the hotel has the potential to offer a comfortable stay with more reliable housekeeping.

Staff service at
JGSTAY - Times Square is generally well-regarded for friendliness and helpfulness with many guests praising the receptionists and other personnel for their courteous and accommodating demeanor. Multilingual staff members, particularly those speaking Spanish, add to the welcoming environment. However, some reviews indicate variability in service quality with a few guests experiencing unresponsiveness or lapses in communication from certain staff members.

The hotel provides complimentary WiFi, which is functional, fast and reliable for many guests. Nonetheless, the WiFi experience can be inconsistent with some rooms or areas of the hotel experiencing connectivity issues. When operational, the WiFi meets acceptable speed standards, allowing guests to stream content and stay connected.

Lastly, the beds at the hotel receive positive feedback for comfort with many guests describing them as clean, cozy and spacious. While a small number of guests noted the beds to be hard or the bedding less clean, the majority report a pleasant sleep experience.

In summary,
JGSTAY - Times Square offers remarkable value for its unbeatable location and functional amenities, complemented by generally friendly staff and comfortable accommodations. However, focusing on consistent housekeeping and WiFi reliability could significantly enhance the overall guest experience.
Categories
Cheap
3 Star
Luxury
The Mayfair Hotel Times Square, an Ascend Collection main photo
The Mayfair Hotel Times Square, an Ascend Collection
24.7 mi from Butler
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $206
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Mayfair Hotel, part of the Ascend Hotel Collection, receives high marks from guests for its prime location in New York City's Theatre District. Situated near Times Square, Central Park and various subway stations, it offers unparalleled convenience for exploring major tourist attractions and Broadway shows while providing a tranquil environment.

The hotel does not offer a traditional breakfast but provides complimentary coffee, tea and sometimes hot chocolate in the lobby, which many guests appreciate. Many reviewers noted the availability of nearby alternatives for breakfast and the 24-hour supply of hot drinks as added conveniences.

Rooms at the Mayfair Hotel are notably compact but recently refurbished, making them modern and clean. The limited space is well-organized to maximize functionality, making it an ideal choice for short-term stays. Guests appreciate amenities like mini-fridges and ironing boards, as well as comfortable beds and a peaceful atmosphere. The cleanliness of the hotel receives consistent praise with daily housekeeping ensuring rooms are immaculate and well-maintained.

The staff at the Mayfair Hotel stand out for their exceptional service. Described as professional, responsive and friendly, they consistently enhance the guest experience. Receptionists, particularly, receive commendations for their warmth and efficiency, making guests feel welcome and well cared for.

Free WiFi is generally reliable, although some occasional disruptions have been reported. Overall, guests find the internet service adequate for their needs.

Comfortable beds contribute to positive reviews, albeit with some mentions of the beds being too small for two people or needing replacement due to softness or sagging. Despite these occasional issues, the overall comfort level of the beds is well-regarded.

The Mayfair Hotel offers great value for its cost, especially given its central location and quality service. While the room sizes and occasional lack of certain amenities like breakfast or larger beds are points of improvement, the hotel's cleanliness, friendly staff and overall comfort make it a solid choice for visitors looking to explore New York City.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Sustainability Journey
The Park Ave North main photo
The Park Ave North
24.8 mi from Butler
Guest House in New York NYUS flag
7.8
Good
From $133
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Park Ave North in Harlem is widely praised for its strategic location, excellent amenities, cleanliness and supportive staff, offering a positive and practical experience for travelers exploring New York City. Highly favored for its convenient proximity to the 125th Street subway station, this hotel facilitates easy access to the city's extensive public transportation network and major transit routes, easing travel to downtown New York. While the neighborhood perspectives vary with some feeling less safe at night, the hotel itself provides a welcoming and secure environment.

Guests commend the rooms for their cleanliness and functionality. Though on the smaller side, they are tidy and equipped with essential amenities like minibars, microwaves, coffee makers and refrigerators. The family suites offer ample space and the presence of comfortable beds and good air conditioning further ensures a pleasant stay. However, some rooms could benefit from better soundproofing to mitigate noise from the street. Still, the overall comfort and convenience balance out these minor setbacks.

The hotel stands out for its exceptional cleanliness with daily housekeeping maintaining immaculate conditions and providing fresh towels regularly. The friendly and accommodating staff receive continual praise for their warm hospitality, efficient communication and helpfulness, enhancing the guest experience significantly. The team, including commendations for members like Elisa, Jasmine, Mimi, Arlin and Michelle, is integral to the hotel's reputation for excellent service.

Beds at
The Park Ave North receive mostly positive reviews with many guests finding the mattresses extremely comfortable, contributing to the reputably good night's sleep. A few guests noted some inconsistencies, such as sagging mattresses or softer pillows, but these concerns are minimal compared to the overall satisfaction with the comfort provided.

Adhering to a three-star standard,
The Park Ave North is recognized for delivering solid value for money, especially for short stays. Its compact but well-maintained rooms, combined with a friendly atmosphere, present a good cost-benefit ratio within the typically high-priced lodging market of New York City. While potential guests should be prepared for some noise and smaller-than-expected room sizes, the hotel remains a highly recommended option for those prioritizing budget-friendly accommodation in New York City’s bustling environment.
Categories
3 Star
Cheap
Small
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-10 out of 10 hotels in and around Butler
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities