Allison House 16

Edinburgh 55.93204800, -3.17269900 , 16 Mayfield Gardens (Show on Map)
7.7
Good


Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Check In
Check Out
1 room2 guests 1 room, 2 guests
Info
Summary of reviewsAllison House 16 enjoys a favorable position in a charming, tranquil residential area in Edinburgh, offering a delightful balance between peaceful surroundings and easy access to the city center. Guests appreciate the hotel's proximity to multiple bus routes and the convenience of reaching downtown within a 10-minute bus ride or a 25-30 minute scenic walk. The neighborhood’s tranquility and proximity to bars, restaurants and shops add to its appeal.

Feedback on the breakfast service at Allison House 16 is mixed. Many reviewers were disappointed by the lack of breakfast, feeling misled by the advertising. However, positive comments highlight the availability of nearby cafes and the in-room coffee options, which help mitigate the absence of an on-site breakfast service.

The hotel’s accommodations, situated in a charming Victorian building, are praised for their cleanliness and comfort. Rooms are described as cozy and well-equipped with daily housekeeping maintaining high standards. Guests appreciate features like comfortable beds, large windows and stunning views from some rooms. Despite minor issues like tiny bathrooms, occasional noise and some maintenance needs, the overall sentiment remains positive with the hotel striking a fine balance between historical charm and modern convenience.

Cleanliness stands out as a significant positive aspect with rooms frequently noted for being immaculate. Daily housekeeping ensures a tidy environment with particular attention to the bathrooms. Despite some isolated issues like stains, minor maintenance concerns and occasional odors, the overall impression is one of a clean and pleasant stay.

The staff at Allison House 16 receive high marks for their friendliness and helpfulness. The self-service check-in and check-out receive overall positive feedback, making the process straightforward for guests. Though the lack of on-site staff can be inconvenient for some, interactions with staff, when present, are generally positive with an emphasis on professional and hospitable service.

Wi-Fi at the hotel is largely reliable with easy connection instructions, though some guests experience inconsistent connectivity, particularly on the upper floors. The hotel’s efforts to provide good internet service are appreciated, though a personal hotspot is advised for those needing a strong connection.

Beds at Allison House 16 are commonly praised for their comfort, contributing to restful nights for most guests. While some find the beds too small or suffer from specific issues like hardness or sagging, the consensus leans towards a satisfying rest experience.

Overall, Allison House 16 offers a comfortable, clean and well-located stay in Edinburgh. While there are mixed feelings about its four-star rating and the absence of breakfast, guests generally find good value in its peaceful setting, friendly staff and convenient access to the city center.
Show more
Categories
Cheap Guest House

Small Guest House

4-Star Guest House

Room Types
Standard Double Room this room includes a double bed.

Comfort Triple Room Providing free toiletries, this triple room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. This triple room features a wardrobe, an electric kettle, flat-screen TV, as well as chocolate for guests. The unit offers 2 beds.

Small Double Room Featuring free toiletries, this double room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. This double room has a wardrobe, an electric kettle, flat-screen TV, as well as chocolate for guests. The unit has 1 bed.

Single Room with Private External Bathroom Providing free toiletries, this single room includes a private bathroom with a shower and a hairdryer. This single room features a wardrobe, an electric kettle, flat-screen TV, as well as chocolate for guests. The unit offers 1 bed.

Guest Reviews
7.7
Good
Location
Allison House 16 boasts a favorable location, making it a convenient option for visitors to Edinburgh. Situated in a quiet residential area, the hotel is not positioned directly in the bustling city center but is well-connected by public transportation. There is a bus stop just a short walk away, providing frequent and quick rides to key attractions like the Royal Mile and Edinburgh's Old Town. Many guests appreciated the peaceful environment, which still allows easy access to downtown within a 15-30 minute walk.

The residential area exudes charm and offers a tranquil atmosphere, which stands out amidst Edinburgh's typically busy streets. Visitors also noted the convenience of having various bus routes nearby, simplifying travel to and from the city center. The location is close enough to walk to several bars, restaurants and shops, adding to its attractiveness for those looking to explore locally and venture into central Edinburgh without hassle.

Another highlight frequently mentioned was the proximity to public transport with many buses stopping almost right at the hotel's door. This convenient access makes it easy to reach the heart of the city in just around 10 minutes by bus. For those who prefer to walk, the scenic stroll to central landmarks takes roughly 25-30 minutes, providing a pleasant route for exploring the city on foot.

Overall, the clean and comfortable accommodations, combined with the excellent and convenient location, make Allison House 16 a compelling choice for travelers. Whether staying for a couple of days or more, guests found it easy to enjoy both the quiet local surroundings and the vibrant city center.

Breakfast
Allison House 16 receives mixed feedback from guests regarding breakfast options. Many reviews highlight the absence of a breakfast service, despite the hotel being advertised as a 'Bed and Breakfast'. Guests repeatedly mentioned no breakfast being provided with some expressing disappointment at the lack of this amenity. There is no option for breakfast on-site, not even as an add-on and some felt misled by advertisements promising a breakfast that was not available.

However, the positive comments note the availability of nearby cafes where guests can enjoy breakfast or brunch, such as a cafe around the corner by the church. Guests also appreciated the availability of coffee in their rooms. Despite the lack of breakfast, some guests found the value for money acceptable overall. The general sentiment is that adding a breakfast option would significantly enhance the guest experience at Allison House 16.

Rooms
Allison House 16, nestled in a charming Victorian building, offers a mix of cozy and spacious accommodations. Many guests have commented on the immaculate cleanliness of the rooms with daily housekeeping ensuring that all spaces are tidy and well-maintained. The rooms are often described as cozy, comfortable and well-equipped with essentials such as kettles, tea and coffee. Beds across the board are consistently recognized for their comfort, adding to a pleasant stay.

Several rooms offer picturesque views, either of the garden or the city, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere. The property's location is convenient with access to multiple bus routes that make exploring Edinburgh a breeze and it’s within walking distance of the city center.

While many rooms boast spaciousness and modern amenities, some guests have found certain rooms to be on the smaller side, which could be a squeeze for two persons. Tiny bathrooms and occasional noise from other guests have been noted. However, the overall sentiment remains positive given the cleanliness, comfort and value for money.

A few quirks do exist, such as the occasional noise from plumbing systems and heaters and some fixtures showing wear and tear. Despite these minor issues, guests appreciate the Victorian charm, ease of self check-in and check-out and the peaceful, residential location. The large windows and well-heated rooms in winter ensure a cozy retreat after a day of exploring Edinburgh.

Allison House 16 strikes a fine balance between historical charm and modern convenience, offering a variety of room types to suit different preferences while maintaining an appealing standard of cleanliness and comfort.

Beds
Allison House 16 has garnered a diverse range of feedback about its beds with a strong emphasis on comfort. The majority of guests have praised the bedding, describing the beds as super-comfortable, very comfortable and incredibly comfy. The clean and spacious bedding has also left a positive impression on many visitors, highlighting the effort put into maintaining high standards of cleanliness and comfort.

However, while many found the beds to be a haven of comfort, a few guests faced issues with the size and support of the beds. Some found the double beds too small or narrow for two people with occasional reports of the mattresses being too hard, too soft or even moldy and sagging. Despite these concerns, the overall sentiment leans towards a comfortable and quiet experience with many guests enjoying restful nights on the well-received beds.

Cleanliness
Allison House 16 receives significant praise for its cleanliness with multiple guests highlighting that their rooms were very clean and comfortable. The rooms are regularly cleaned every day, ensuring that guests return to a tidy space each evening. The bathrooms, both inside and outside the rooms, are also frequently noted for being spotless. Visitors appreciated the fresh and well-maintained environment, mentioning that the rooms are bright, well-decorated and equipped with modern amenities. The housekeeping staff are noted for their attention to detail, making beds daily and maintaining a high standard of sanitation.

Despite these positive aspects, some reviews did point out areas needing improvement. There were occasional mentions of residual stains and minor maintenance issues such as cracked paint and mold in showers. A few guests encountered cleanliness issues in common areas and certain rooms and some noted unpleasant odors in various parts of the property.

Overall, Allison House 16 manages to offer a clean and pleasant stay for the majority of its guests with particularly strong performance in room cleanliness and daily maintenance. The hotel also benefits from easy access to public transportation, making it convenient for exploring the city.

Staff
Allison House 16 receives high praise for the friendliness and helpfulness of its staff with many guests highlighting the amiable and accommodating nature of both the management and the cleaning crew. The majority of the reviews emphasize positive interactions with staff members, describing them as pleasant, professional and hospitable. Managers and cleaning staff alike are frequently noted for their responsiveness, whether it’s assisting with luggage or addressing service requests such as fetching an iron or replacing remote control batteries.

Guests appreciate the efficiency of self check-in and check-out processes with many noting how easy and straightforward these were. The absence of a traditional reception desk allows for a more independent stay and most found this self-service approach to be quite effective.

However, the reliance on remote or sporadic staff presence is notable with some guests finding the lack of onsite staff inconvenient. Instances where staff were unavailable or where communication barriers existed—particularly with cleaning staff speaking limited English—were mentioned. Additionally, several reviews point out the early and sometimes disruptive activity of the cleaning crew.

Despite these challenges, when there is contact with staff, the interactions are generally positive, marked by timely email responses and occasional face-to-face assistance, such as with baggage management. Guests who did interact with the staff found them to be approachable and knowledgeable, albeit with a few reports of unprofessional behavior via intercom communications.

Overall, the self-service model at Allison House 16 receives a mixed response. While many guests enjoy the autonomy and simplicity it provides, others miss the personalized touch and consistent availability of traditional hotel staff.

Wi-Fi
Allison House 16 provides a generally positive experience regarding Wi-Fi connectivity with many guests reporting good, reliable and even great internet service during their stay. Clear instructions and informative boards in the rooms contribute to the ease of connecting to the Wi-Fi. However, the quality of the Wi-Fi can be inconsistent, especially in certain areas and on the upper floors. Some guests experienced weak signals, intermittent connectivity or no signal at all. It appears that while some rooms boast dependable internet, others, particularly those on higher floors, may face issues such as constant disconnections and low signal strength. For those heavily reliant on a strong internet connection, bringing a personal hotspot is advisable.

4 Star
Allison House 16 offers a well-run, comfortable and cozy stay that feels homely to its guests. The rooms are modernly furnished, tidy and spotless, providing an efficient and simple accommodation experience. Guests appreciate the beautiful area surrounding the property. Despite the positives, there are mixed feelings about the hotel's four-star rating. Some guests feel that the standard does not fit a four-star classification, especially considering the price. While the rooms are tidy and the bathroom fixtures are adequate, enhancements like a larger TV could elevate the experience. The overall value for money is noted, but there are expectations for better quality facilities in alignment with the advertised rating.


No, Allison House 16 doesn't have any pool.

No, a spa isn't available at Allison House 16.

No, Allison House 16 doesn't allow dogs.

No, parking facilities aren't available at Allison House 16.

No, Allison House 16 doesn't have a gym.

Location Show Map
More Options
  • Hotel in Edinburgh

  • 8.5 Very Good

  • From $292

  • Hotel in Edinburgh

  • 8.5 Very Good

  • From $219

  • Hotel in Edinburgh

  • 8.3 Very Good

  • From $134

  • Hotel in Edinburgh

  • 9.2 Excellent

  • From $250



6,973,814

Hotels

60

Categories

49,804

Regions

208,995

Cities


×
×
Checkin
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ