Thistle Hotel
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsThistle Hotel, located in Edinburgh's West End, receives widespread admiration for its prime position. Guests value its proximity to major attractions like Dean's Village, Princes Street, and Edinburgh Castle, all accessible by foot, as well as the convenience of nearby Haymarket station for broader exploration. The hotel's historic charm, coupled with the balance it strikes between city buzz and tranquil surroundings, provides an ideal base for both tourists and event attendees. Visitors frequently commend the hotel's friendly and attentive staff, whose warmth and dedication enhance the guest experience significantly.
The hotel's breakfast offerings, particularly the continental selection, receive generally positive feedback, with many praising the diversity and quality of items. The option of a cooked breakfast, available for an additional charge, is also recommended by several visitors. Staff at breakfast service are noted for their excellence in accommodating guest needs, including providing "Breakfast To-Go" for early departures. A few guests mention room for improvement due to limited variety or occasional shortages in offerings, but overall, the breakfast experience is seen as satisfactory.
Rooms at Thistle Hotel, characterized by spaciousness and traditional charms, receive praise for comfort and cleanliness. Guests appreciate the large beds and ample storage, as well as the cozy, historic decor. However, while many rooms are well-maintained, some guests note the need for refurbishment, particularly in fixtures and bathrooms. Despite this, the majority report a comfortable and satisfying stay.
The hotel's historic aspect is a significant draw, offering a unique experience within a Georgian townhouse over 300 years old. While the charming Victorian decor appeals to many, some guests encounter cleanliness issues, such as dusty corners or outdated facilities. Despite these occasional setbacks, the dedicated staff strive to maintain a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere.
Thistle Hotel also provides a joyful family-friendly atmosphere, with spacious room options catering well to families. The bedding receives positive remarks, with many finding the beds extremely comfortable, although some guests have noted inconsistencies in mattress quality.
Wi-Fi connectivity at the hotel is mixed, with some guests enjoying reliable service and others experiencing disruptions. Additionally, parking poses challenges typical of urban settings, with limited on-site availability, prompting guests to seek alternative solutions.
Overall, Thistle Hotel offers a charming stay with attentive service and historic allure, appealing particularly to those seeking value for money in a convenient location. While there are areas for improvement, the positive aspects, notably the staff's hospitality and the hotel's location, make it a commendable choice for travelers.
Categories
The hotel's breakfast offerings, particularly the continental selection, receive generally positive feedback, with many praising the diversity and quality of items. The option of a cooked breakfast, available for an additional charge, is also recommended by several visitors. Staff at breakfast service are noted for their excellence in accommodating guest needs, including providing "Breakfast To-Go" for early departures. A few guests mention room for improvement due to limited variety or occasional shortages in offerings, but overall, the breakfast experience is seen as satisfactory.
Rooms at Thistle Hotel, characterized by spaciousness and traditional charms, receive praise for comfort and cleanliness. Guests appreciate the large beds and ample storage, as well as the cozy, historic decor. However, while many rooms are well-maintained, some guests note the need for refurbishment, particularly in fixtures and bathrooms. Despite this, the majority report a comfortable and satisfying stay.
The hotel's historic aspect is a significant draw, offering a unique experience within a Georgian townhouse over 300 years old. While the charming Victorian decor appeals to many, some guests encounter cleanliness issues, such as dusty corners or outdated facilities. Despite these occasional setbacks, the dedicated staff strive to maintain a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere.
Thistle Hotel also provides a joyful family-friendly atmosphere, with spacious room options catering well to families. The bedding receives positive remarks, with many finding the beds extremely comfortable, although some guests have noted inconsistencies in mattress quality.
Wi-Fi connectivity at the hotel is mixed, with some guests enjoying reliable service and others experiencing disruptions. Additionally, parking poses challenges typical of urban settings, with limited on-site availability, prompting guests to seek alternative solutions.
Overall, Thistle Hotel offers a charming stay with attentive service and historic allure, appealing particularly to those seeking value for money in a convenient location. While there are areas for improvement, the positive aspects, notably the staff's hospitality and the hotel's location, make it a commendable choice for travelers.
Historic Hotel
Located on Manor Place in Edinburgh's New Town, this hotel is in a building that is part of the Georgian and Victorian development of the area. The architecture aligns with the historical character of the New Town.
Hotel for Honeymoon
Family Friendly Hotel
Hotel near Nightlife Spots
Hotel with Free Wi-Fi
Business Hotel
Hotel with Parking
Small Hotel
3-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
Thistle Hotel in Edinburgh is frequently praised for its remarkable location, situated conveniently near both the hustle and bustle of the city center and tranquil spots for those seeking quietude. Nestled in the West End, the hotel offers easy access to major attractions like Dean's Village, Princes Street, and Edinburgh Castle, all within walking distance. It's perfectly positioned near Haymarket station, making transport links easily accessible for exploring the broader area.
Guests appreciate the mixture of historic charm and proximity to the city's lively center, emphasizing the hotel's role as an ideal base for both sightseeing and attending events, such as local sports matches. Surrounded by a peaceful neighborhood, it strikes a balance between being centrally located and ensuring a serene stay, perfect for those who appreciate quiet accommodations close to the action.
The hotel itself is located in a lovely area, with its historic building adding to the ambience. In addition to its prime location, reviewers repeatedly commend the friendly staff, highlighting their helpfulness and attentiveness, which enhances the overall guest experience. For visitors eager to explore Edinburgh's landmarks, restaurants, and shopping areas on foot, Thistle Hotel offers an excellent starting point balanced with comfort and convenience.
At Thistle Hotel, guests generally find the breakfast offerings to be satisfactory, with a mixture of positive and mixed feedback. Many visitors appreciate the continental breakfast for its variety and adequacy, noting that it includes diverse options such as bread, toppings, yogurt, fruit, and pastries. The continental breakfast often wins praise for its quality and availability, with some guests enjoying it so much that they choose to partake multiple times during their stay.
For those seeking a bit more, an option for a cooked breakfast is available upon request, often for an additional charge. Guests who opted for this were pleased, with some describing it as a "must" and "excellent." Particularly noteworthy was the hot breakfast with items like porridge, which received positive remarks.
Staff at the breakfast service are frequently applauded for their friendly and attentive approach. They appear willing to go above and beyond, providing personal service, and accommodating requests with a smile. This commitment includes preparing a "Breakfast To-Go" for early departures, showcasing their readiness to cater to guests' needs.
However, there are a few areas where the breakfast could improve. Some guests found the continental breakfast to be somewhat basic or limited, with occasional reports of items running out without prompt replenishment. Additionally, the absence of fresh rolls and the reliance on pre-packaged goods were mentioned by a few guests as a minor downside. Despite these points, the overall impression is that Thistle Hotel provides a breakfast experience that, while not extravagant, is adequate, well-prepared, and enhanced by excellent service.
Thistle Hotel offers a diverse range of rooms that cater to varying needs and preferences, wrapped in a traditional charm and warm atmosphere. Guests frequently commend the spaciousness and comfort found in many of the hotel's accommodations. Rooms often include large beds, plentiful storage, and modern amenities, making them ideal for families or larger groups.
Cleanliness and coziness are consistent highlights, with many guests appreciating the ample space and overall arrangement of their accommodations. The large, high-ceilinged rooms provide a welcoming atmosphere, while the charming, historical decor adds to the hotel's distinctive appeal. The comfortable beds ensure a restful sleep, leaving guests satisfied with their stay.
Despite the allure of the hotel's charm, there are instances where rooms could benefit from some modern upgrades or refurbishment, particularly in their fixtures and bathrooms. Some guests note that certain accommodations feel outdated and show signs of wear, such as mold and dampness. While a majority of rooms maintain satisfactory cleanliness standards, there are occasional lapses in room service and maintenance.
Overall, Thistle Hotel is well-situated for exploring the city's attractions, and its dedicated staff contribute to an enjoyable guest experience. For those seeking spacious, comfortable, and clean accommodations with a touch of historic charm, Thistle Hotel is a commendable choice, though prospective guests should be mindful of potential minor inconveniences concerning room maintenance and aesthetics.
Thistle Hotel offers a largely positive experience when it comes to bedding comfort, featuring a variety of options that most guests find satisfactory. With comments highlighting extremely comfortable beds, generous-sized options, and even super comfy mattresses, it's clear that many guests appreciate the restful night's sleep provided. The use of large beds, including king and twin-sized beds, shows a commitment to accommodating diverse needs. Positive remarks about the cleanliness and cosy atmosphere of the rooms further enhance the overall experience.
Some guests have noted quirks, such as double beds being made from two singles pushed together or issues with certain beds, including sagging and mattresses that need replacing. Rare complaints about discomfort suggest that while most visitors enjoy the comfort of the beds, experiences can vary. Despite some negative remarks about a few beds being hard or lumpy, the warmth of the blankets and supportive pillows often redeem the bedding experience. Overall, Thistle Hotel tends to provide comfortable accommodation, enabling guests to relax and enjoy their stay.
Thistle Hotel presents a mixed tapestry of experiences, particularly in the domain of cleanliness. Amidst its Victorian charm and outdated furnishings, many guests found solace in clean and tidy rooms that offer comfort and coziness. Various accounts recount spotless and spacious accommodations, with rooms regularly spruced up and maintained by diligent staff. Some appreciated the newly updated bathroom fixtures, contributing to a functional and clean environment. The staff's friendliness and helpfulness, paired with a convenient location near Princess Street, add value to the stay for several visitors.
However, the hotel struggles with significant cleanliness issues. Many guests reported dirt and neglect, with dusty corners, unclean carpets, and moldy showers tarnishing the overall experience. The aged decor and facilities often result in bathrooms feeling unhygienic, with broken or loose fixtures, unvacuumed carpets, and general dilapidation. Problems such as leftover trash, dirty cup stains, and unpleasant odors underline the urgent need for renovation and regular maintenance. In essence, while Thistle Hotel embodies a quaint and charming experience for some, the pervasive cleanliness challenges and outdated facilities call for substantial improvements to guarantee a consistently pleasant stay.
The staff at Thistle Hotel consistently leaves a memorable impression on guests with their remarkable friendliness and helpfulness. From the moment visitors arrive, they are met with a warm welcome, setting the tone for a pleasant stay. The team is often praised for going above and beyond to ensure comfort and satisfaction, offering assistance whenever needed and providing useful recommendations. Names like Andrew, Sam, and Mathew frequently surface in reviews, especially noted for their dedication and accommodating nature. Despite occasional challenges like understaffing, the staff manages to deliver exceptional service, showcasing their commitment to guest care and hospitality. Their genuine kindness and ability to address any queries or needs enhance the overall experience, making Thistle Hotel a choice destination for travelers seeking attentive service with a personal touch.
The Wi-Fi experience at Thistle Hotel seems to be a mixed bag, with some guests noting good connectivity while others experienced issues. Positive remarks highlight the availability of free Wi-Fi, adding to the convenience of staying at the hotel. However, several guests encountered problems, such as slow speeds and frequent disconnections. In certain rooms, the Wi-Fi reportedly did not work at all, impacting guests who required stable internet access. Despite the potential for a strong signal, dissatisfaction arises due to the unreliable and often weak connection that intermittently cuts out. Overall, the Wi-Fi service appears to be a hit or miss, suggesting that guests might need to manage expectations regarding internet connectivity during their stay.
Navigating parking at the Thistle Hotel proves to be a bit challenging, reflecting the urban constraints typical in many city center locations. While parking is touted as available, the reality is that spaces are extremely limited, often reduced to just one onsite spot. Travelers often find themselves needing to secure offsite parking, sometimes at considerable distances, or relying on paid parking facilities nearby. This can entail significant extra costs, sometimes as high as £25 per day and often requiring upfront payments with few flexible options.
Some guests have found success using alternative solutions like the JustPark app, which offers helpful recommendations and allows for pre-planned parking arrangements within a manageable walking distance from the hotel. Free parking options also exist, but availability can be sporadic and are typically situated a walk away from the premises. However, advance planning is crucial, as operational road works or limited spaces can disrupt previously organized parking plans. Despite these hurdles, those who come prepared with parking strategies find that intermediate solutions, though lacking convenience, can mitigate the typical city-centric parking frustrations.
Thistle Hotel creates a welcoming and inclusive environment that is particularly accommodating for families. Guests often highlight the good-sized rooms, with options like triple rooms that are ideal for a family stay. The hotel manages to maintain a cozy, family-run charm that resonates well with both families and older couples seeking a pleasant atmosphere. Its family-friendly vibe makes it a solid choice for families of various sizes, ensuring a comfortable stay for everyone. Whether visiting with a family of four or three, the spacious rooms cater well to their needs, reinforcing the hotel's reputation as a parent and child-friendly destination.
Thistle Hotel offers a charming stay characterized by attentive and friendly service, making it an appealing option for budget-conscious travelers. Despite its simple appearance, guests frequently find that the hotel provides good value for money, often being cheaper than several other accommodations in the vicinity. While the three-star rating might be subject to disagreement, many guests still appreciate the overall experience, describing the hotel as lovely and traditional, with all the necessary amenities. A highlight of the service is the pleasant and informative communication regarding arrival procedures, providing a warm and welcoming introduction. While some guests have expressed a desire for more functional bathroom facilities, the consensus appears to favor the hotel's affordability and satisfying quality relative to its cost.
The Thistle Hotel is a destination rich in history and charm, situated within a magnificent building that's over 300 years old. This charming hotel is housed in a historic Georgian townhouse, offering guests a unique experience steeped in the grandeur of old Edinburgh. It beautifully maintains its heritage features, encapsulating the essence of a classic old Scottish structure. Despite being a little dated, the hotel's character and classic design enhance its appeal, providing a glimpse into the past with its typical Victorian charm. Visitors can enjoy the spacious rooms and explore the quiet, picturesque West End, making it an ideal base for outings in the city. Positioned in a lovely part of town, the Thistle Hotel is a haven for those who appreciate historic and old-fashioned British architecture.
Location Show Map
Location
Guests appreciate the mixture of historic charm and proximity to the city's lively center, emphasizing the hotel's role as an ideal base for both sightseeing and attending events, such as local sports matches. Surrounded by a peaceful neighborhood, it strikes a balance between being centrally located and ensuring a serene stay, perfect for those who appreciate quiet accommodations close to the action.
The hotel itself is located in a lovely area, with its historic building adding to the ambience. In addition to its prime location, reviewers repeatedly commend the friendly staff, highlighting their helpfulness and attentiveness, which enhances the overall guest experience. For visitors eager to explore Edinburgh's landmarks, restaurants, and shopping areas on foot, Thistle Hotel offers an excellent starting point balanced with comfort and convenience.
Breakfast
For those seeking a bit more, an option for a cooked breakfast is available upon request, often for an additional charge. Guests who opted for this were pleased, with some describing it as a "must" and "excellent." Particularly noteworthy was the hot breakfast with items like porridge, which received positive remarks.
Staff at the breakfast service are frequently applauded for their friendly and attentive approach. They appear willing to go above and beyond, providing personal service, and accommodating requests with a smile. This commitment includes preparing a "Breakfast To-Go" for early departures, showcasing their readiness to cater to guests' needs.
However, there are a few areas where the breakfast could improve. Some guests found the continental breakfast to be somewhat basic or limited, with occasional reports of items running out without prompt replenishment. Additionally, the absence of fresh rolls and the reliance on pre-packaged goods were mentioned by a few guests as a minor downside. Despite these points, the overall impression is that Thistle Hotel provides a breakfast experience that, while not extravagant, is adequate, well-prepared, and enhanced by excellent service.
Rooms
Cleanliness and coziness are consistent highlights, with many guests appreciating the ample space and overall arrangement of their accommodations. The large, high-ceilinged rooms provide a welcoming atmosphere, while the charming, historical decor adds to the hotel's distinctive appeal. The comfortable beds ensure a restful sleep, leaving guests satisfied with their stay.
Despite the allure of the hotel's charm, there are instances where rooms could benefit from some modern upgrades or refurbishment, particularly in their fixtures and bathrooms. Some guests note that certain accommodations feel outdated and show signs of wear, such as mold and dampness. While a majority of rooms maintain satisfactory cleanliness standards, there are occasional lapses in room service and maintenance.
Overall, Thistle Hotel is well-situated for exploring the city's attractions, and its dedicated staff contribute to an enjoyable guest experience. For those seeking spacious, comfortable, and clean accommodations with a touch of historic charm, Thistle Hotel is a commendable choice, though prospective guests should be mindful of potential minor inconveniences concerning room maintenance and aesthetics.
Beds
Some guests have noted quirks, such as double beds being made from two singles pushed together or issues with certain beds, including sagging and mattresses that need replacing. Rare complaints about discomfort suggest that while most visitors enjoy the comfort of the beds, experiences can vary. Despite some negative remarks about a few beds being hard or lumpy, the warmth of the blankets and supportive pillows often redeem the bedding experience. Overall, Thistle Hotel tends to provide comfortable accommodation, enabling guests to relax and enjoy their stay.
Cleanliness
However, the hotel struggles with significant cleanliness issues. Many guests reported dirt and neglect, with dusty corners, unclean carpets, and moldy showers tarnishing the overall experience. The aged decor and facilities often result in bathrooms feeling unhygienic, with broken or loose fixtures, unvacuumed carpets, and general dilapidation. Problems such as leftover trash, dirty cup stains, and unpleasant odors underline the urgent need for renovation and regular maintenance. In essence, while Thistle Hotel embodies a quaint and charming experience for some, the pervasive cleanliness challenges and outdated facilities call for substantial improvements to guarantee a consistently pleasant stay.
Staff
Wi-Fi
Parking
Some guests have found success using alternative solutions like the JustPark app, which offers helpful recommendations and allows for pre-planned parking arrangements within a manageable walking distance from the hotel. Free parking options also exist, but availability can be sporadic and are typically situated a walk away from the premises. However, advance planning is crucial, as operational road works or limited spaces can disrupt previously organized parking plans. Despite these hurdles, those who come prepared with parking strategies find that intermediate solutions, though lacking convenience, can mitigate the typical city-centric parking frustrations.
Family
3 Star
Historic
No, Thistle Hotel doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at Thistle Hotel.
No, Thistle Hotel doesn't allow dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at Thistle Hotel.
No, Thistle Hotel doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
