The property was built in 1895 by William Nelson. In the next year, a retired Navy Officer named George Langdale Sunderland took residence. He worked with William Nelson and his brothers as head stock buyer and was then promoted to manager. The property remained under the Nelson family until WWII.
Summary of reviews related to the 'Historic' category
Mangapapa Hotel is a delightful historic hotel that is full of old world charm. Guests love the beautiful architecture and the fact that it is steeped in history. Many say that it is a lovely grand hotel set in the country with mature trees that give it a beautiful and elegant feel. This classy historic nostalgic hotel has great service and beautiful grounds, making for a lovely stay. Guests enjoy the classic original condition of the main house and the fact that it provides a unique opportunity to experience grand old estate living. Overall, visitors love the beautiful old house and the stay they have at Mangapapa Hotel, making for a lovely time spent in a historic estate.
The building was designed by D.B. Frame and constructed in 1919 for the Ancient Order of Foresters District Building. Thanks to its robust foundations and Spanish-inspired architecture, it withstood the 1931 earthquake. It has been deemed as a Category II Historic Place.