House on Chase Creek
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island Heights NY
8.3
Very Good
From $140
From $140
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Parking

Luxury Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast for Adults Only

Show more
 
West Neck Guesthouse
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island Heights NY
9.1
Excellent
From $214
From $214
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Parking

Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi

Small Bed & Breakfast

Show more
 
Ram's Head Inn
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
7.7
Good
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking

Hotel near Golf Courses

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
The Chequit
Inn in Shelter Island Heights NY
9.0
Excellent
From $427
From $427
Info Categories
Inn with Parking

Small Inn

4-Star Inn

Show more
 
Shelter Island House
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
4.0
Rated
From $225
From $225
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking

Luxury Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
Sunset Beach Hotel
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
From $334
From $334
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking

Hotel near Golf Courses

Hotel with Spa

Show more
 
632 more hotels nearby!
Shelter Island Hidden Waterfront 1.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
The Pridwin Hotel 1.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Hotel in Shelter Island NY
9.0
Excellent
From $262
From $262
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Hotel
Show more
 
Romantic Shelter Island Cottage with 2 Pools & Pond 1.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking
Dog Friendly Vacation Home
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool
Show more
 
Luxurious Shelter Island Hideaway with Pool! 1.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Shelter Island NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool
Show more
 
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast 2.0 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY
8.8
Excellent
From $368
From $368
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Parking
Luxury Bed & Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool
Show more
 
Greenport Home with Harbor View Near Ferry and Beaches 2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking
Dog Friendly Vacation Home
Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi
Show more
 
Walk to all. LIRR;Jitney;ferries;shopping;beach;town 2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking
Show more
 
The Harbor Front Inn 2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Hotel in Greenport NY
8.4
Very Good
From $261
From $261
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking
Hotel for Honeymoon
Family Friendly Hotel
Show more
 
Modern on 9th 2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Vacation Home in Greenport NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Parking
Dog Friendly Vacation Home
Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi
Show more
 
Ruby's Cove 2.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Guest House in Greenport NY
10
Excellent
Info Categories
Guest House with Parking
Luxury Guest House
Romantic Guest House
Show more
 
Greenporter Hotel 2.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Hotel in Greenport NY
7.9
Good
From $128
From $128
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking
Hotel near Golf Courses
Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability
Show more
 
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport 2.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY
9.6
Excellent
From $341
From $341
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Parking
Bed & Breakfast Taking Steps Towards Sustainability
Bed & Breakfast for Adults Only
Show more
 
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows 2.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Hotel in Greenport NY
9.5
Excellent
Info Categories
Hotel with Parking
Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability
Dog Friendly Hotel
Show more
 
ZEY HOTEL 2.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY
8.7
Very Good
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Parking
Family Friendly Bed & Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi
Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in Shelter Island Heights.
Categories:
  •     Parking (638)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (425)
  •     Pool (351)
  •     Outdoor Pool (302)
  •     Dog Friendly (239)
  •     4 Star (116)
  •     3 Star (100)
  •     Family (97)
  •     Small (81)
  •     Accessible (56)
  •     Golf (49)
  •     Luxury (44)
  •     Honeymoon (39)
  •     Heated Pool (38)
  •     Private Pool (32)
  •     Beach (30)
  •     Gym (27)
  •     Business (24)
  •     Indoor Pool (23)
  •     Sustainability Journey (20)
  •     EV charging stations (19)
  •     Tennis (16)
  •     Yoga (16)
  •     Spa (15)
  •     Adult Only (14)
  •     Romantic (13)
  •     Beachfront (13)
  •     5 Star (9)
  •     Vineyard (6)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (4)
  •     Boutique-Style (3)
  •     Dog Play Area (2)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub (1)
  •     Dog Sitting (1)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (1)
  •     Children's Pool (1)
  •     Health & Safety (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ