HI New York City Hostel in Manhattan earns glowing reviews for its prime location, conveniently close to Central Park, multiple subway stations and key landmarks like Times Square and Riverside Park. The Upper West Side neighborhood adds to its charm, offering a range of dining, shopping and recreational options within a safe and vibrant atmosphere. Its accessibility to public transportation further strengthens its appeal for tourists seeking an efficient base for exploring New York City.
The hostel doesn't include complimentary breakfast but compensates with an on-site café that serves a varied and affordable menu, including popular options like chicken chipotle and Mexican deli sandwiches. Although there are some minor complaints about the lack of diverse food options and occasional issues with food quality, the well-equipped kitchen and nearby grocery stores provide ample alternatives. The dining options, including a pleasant garden and patio area, generally receive positive feedback for their convenience and quality.
Accommodation at HI New York City Hostel is described as clean and spacious with particular praise for the diligent maintenance of both private and communal spaces. Guests find the beds comfortable and the presence of spacious lockers adds a sense of security. However, occasional issues with ventilation, temperature control and minor cleanliness lapses are noted. Despite this, the overall value is deemed fair given the strategic location and amenities.
The hostel excels in cleanliness with constant upkeep of bathrooms, showers and common areas consistently highlighted in guest reviews. The staff's friendliness and helpfulness significantly contribute to the hostel’s appeal, despite occasional reports of unprofessionalism and inefficiency. Most guests find the staff to be accommodating and hospitable.
The free Wi-Fi is generally reliable and fast, although some areas, particularly the 4th floor and dorm rooms, experience connectivity issues. Nevertheless, it meets the basic needs of most guests.
The social atmosphere at HI New York City Hostel is another strong point, characterized by numerous planned evening activities such as karaoke nights, stand-up comedy shows and pub crawls. These events create a collegiate environment that encourages interaction and the formation of new friendships. The nearby dive bars offer additional nightlife options, complementing the hostel’s social activities.
Overall, HI New York City Hostel stands out for its excellent location, cleanliness, comfortable accommodations and engaging social programs. While there are some areas for improvement, such as air conditioning noise and occasional lapses in staff responsiveness, the hostel remains a highly recommended, budget-friendly option for travelers looking to explore New York City.
Night Hotel Broadway is praised primarily for its exceptional location on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, providing effortless access to Times Square and other popular destinations via the 96th Street subway station. Guests appreciate the convenience of nearby amenities such as Central Park, numerous dining options, cafes and retail shops, all contributing to a vibrant yet relatively tranquil atmosphere.
The spacious and comfortable rooms receive mixed reviews regarding their condition. While many guests appreciated the size, good views and cleanliness maintained through daily housekeeping, there were recurring complaints about outdated furnishings, dirty carpets and faulty fixtures. Some guests reported issues like cigarette and musty odors, cockroach sightings and inadequate renovation, indicating a need for substantial improvements.
Cleanliness overall also received varied feedback. Several guests noted the regular changing of bed sheets and towels and the cleanliness of bathrooms and common areas. However, problems such as stained carpets, unpleasant smells and lack of thorough cleaning in hallways and elevators were frequently mentioned. Improvement in maintenance and more rigorous cleaning protocols are necessary to meet guest expectations fully.
The staff at Night Hotel Broadway garnered generally positive reviews. Many guests found the staff friendly, helpful and professional with a few standout individuals like CeCe and Justin being specifically praised for their exceptional service. Despite a few instances of rude or indifferent interactions, the staff's overall performance significantly contributed to a pleasant guest experience.
Issues were noted with the hotel's Wi-Fi service with many guests finding it unreliable and slow, especially in the rooms. Positive feedback was minimal and mostly mentioned good connectivity close to the modem. This suggests that substantial improvements in internet service are needed.
Parking at Night Hotel Broadway received mixed reviews. While some appreciated the attached garage and reserved spots, many found the parking to be expensive and limited. The provided vouchers often did not cover the cost and the garage's location was sometimes inconvenient for guests.
For families, the hotel offers large beds and spacious rooms adequate for family stays with amenities like bathtubs useful for small children. Despite these positives, safety concerns and instances of smoking on adjacent floors were noted, indicating areas needing attention to better accommodate families.
Regarding bed comfort, feedback was mixed with many finding the beds comfortable and clean and others pointing out issues with outdated and sagging mattresses. The general sentiment was that while some beds met standard expectations, others needed better maintenance and updates.
Night Hotel Broadway is described as a basic three-star hotel ideal for budget-conscious travelers, offering reasonable value for money thanks to its strategic location and friendly service. While its facilities and amenities did not exceed basic three-star expectations, the hotel excels in offering accessibility, particularly given its proximity to transportation options. Recommendations for improvements focus on upgrading room conditions and amenities, enhancing cleanliness throughout the property and improving internet service. Overall, Night Hotel Broadway presents itself as a practical choice for visitors seeking affordability and convenience during their NYC stay.
Categories
Accessible
Cheap
Honeymoon
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-2 out of 2 hotels in and around Suffern