The Caledonian Hotel
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsThe Caledonian Hotel consistently garners favorable reviews for its exceptional central location, making it an attractive destination for travelers. Positioned within short walking distances to the beach, seafront and town center, guests appreciate the accessibility to shops, the bus station and main city sites. The friendly staff and clean rooms contribute to the hotel's appeal, making it suitable for various purposes, from leisure stays to stopovers.
Breakfast at The Caledonian Hotel is highly praised with guests highlighting the variety and quality of the food. The cooked breakfast, in particular, receives specific compliments and the service at breakfast is noted to be attentive and excellent. Though there are minor suggestions for improvement, such as a more extensive continental selection, the overall sentiment towards breakfast is overwhelmingly positive with guests finding it worth the additional cost.
The hotel's dinner offerings also receive high marks. The restaurant is frequently highlighted as serving excellent food with some meals, such as the macaroni, being particularly amazing. The varied menu provides good value for money and the friendly and efficient service enhances the dining experience. Despite occasional lapses in service and minimal meal options, the overall experience at the restaurant and bar is delightful.
Guest reviews on the rooms at The Caledonian Hotel are mixed but lean towards positive. Many guests praise the spaciousness, cleanliness and comfort of the rooms. Some rooms have been recently refurbished, showcasing modern designs. However, there are mentions of dated and tired-looking rooms that could benefit from updates and renovations. Despite these issues, the consensus is that the rooms are comfortable and functional.
Cleanliness at The Caledonian Hotel receives predominantly positive feedback. Guests frequently mention the rooms and public areas as very clean and well-maintained. Although some areas could use updating and more thorough cleaning, the overall experience is positive with guests appreciating the clean bedding and towels.
The staff at The Caledonian Hotel are celebrated for their warm and attentive nature. Guests frequently highlight the friendly, helpful and professional staff members, who go above and beyond to enhance the guest experience. The team’s cheerful disposition and exceptional service play a significant role in ensuring a pleasant and enjoyable stay.
The WiFi service at the hotel receives mixed reviews. Some guests found the WiFi satisfactory and quick, while others encountered issues such as patchy connectivity or difficulty connecting. Reviews on the reliability of the internet are varied, indicating room for improvement.
The beds at The Caledonian Hotel are often praised for their comfort with many guests highlighting the cleanliness and quality of the bed linen. While most reviews describe the beds as comfortable, a few mentions indicate firmness or discomfort. Overall, the beds contribute to a restful night's sleep for the majority of guests.
As a mid-range hotel, The Caledonian Hotel provides good value for money with free parking and very good food. It is seen as a solid budget-friendly option that meets expectations for the price. Although the accommodation is sometimes described as tired and dated, the overall experience is satisfactory with some guests suggesting it surpasses the quality of typical three-star hotels.
Breakfast at The Caledonian Hotel is highly praised with guests highlighting the variety and quality of the food. The cooked breakfast, in particular, receives specific compliments and the service at breakfast is noted to be attentive and excellent. Though there are minor suggestions for improvement, such as a more extensive continental selection, the overall sentiment towards breakfast is overwhelmingly positive with guests finding it worth the additional cost.
The hotel's dinner offerings also receive high marks. The restaurant is frequently highlighted as serving excellent food with some meals, such as the macaroni, being particularly amazing. The varied menu provides good value for money and the friendly and efficient service enhances the dining experience. Despite occasional lapses in service and minimal meal options, the overall experience at the restaurant and bar is delightful.
Guest reviews on the rooms at The Caledonian Hotel are mixed but lean towards positive. Many guests praise the spaciousness, cleanliness and comfort of the rooms. Some rooms have been recently refurbished, showcasing modern designs. However, there are mentions of dated and tired-looking rooms that could benefit from updates and renovations. Despite these issues, the consensus is that the rooms are comfortable and functional.
Cleanliness at The Caledonian Hotel receives predominantly positive feedback. Guests frequently mention the rooms and public areas as very clean and well-maintained. Although some areas could use updating and more thorough cleaning, the overall experience is positive with guests appreciating the clean bedding and towels.
The staff at The Caledonian Hotel are celebrated for their warm and attentive nature. Guests frequently highlight the friendly, helpful and professional staff members, who go above and beyond to enhance the guest experience. The team’s cheerful disposition and exceptional service play a significant role in ensuring a pleasant and enjoyable stay.
The WiFi service at the hotel receives mixed reviews. Some guests found the WiFi satisfactory and quick, while others encountered issues such as patchy connectivity or difficulty connecting. Reviews on the reliability of the internet are varied, indicating room for improvement.
The beds at The Caledonian Hotel are often praised for their comfort with many guests highlighting the cleanliness and quality of the bed linen. While most reviews describe the beds as comfortable, a few mentions indicate firmness or discomfort. Overall, the beds contribute to a restful night's sleep for the majority of guests.
As a mid-range hotel, The Caledonian Hotel provides good value for money with free parking and very good food. It is seen as a solid budget-friendly option that meets expectations for the price. Although the accommodation is sometimes described as tired and dated, the overall experience is satisfactory with some guests suggesting it surpasses the quality of typical three-star hotels.
Cheap Hotel
3-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
The Caledonian Hotel consistently receives praise for its exceptional location, making it an attractive choice for travelers. Positioned centrally, it's within a short walking distance to the beach, the seafront and the town center, offering guests the convenience of easily exploring these areas. The hotel's proximity to shops, the bus station and main city sites provide additional conveniences for visitors. Guests also appreciate the friendly staff and the clean rooms, noting the hotel’s suitability for various purposes, from leisure stays to stopovers between St Andrews and Edinburgh. The central positioning of the hotel makes it ideal for exploring the Fife coast and discovering the East coast with convenient car parking nearby. The hotel's lovely ground floor ambience contrasts slightly with some dated rooms, yet its location and easy access to amenities make it a favored choice among guests.
Guests at The Caledonian Hotel have consistently praised the breakfast offerings, highlighting the variety and quality of the food. Many reviewers described the breakfast as lovely, delicious and excellent with specific compliments directed towards the cooked breakfast and the comprehensive selection available. Service at breakfast also received high marks with some guests specifically thanking staff members for their attentive care.
While there were mentions of areas for improvement, such as the desire for a more extensive continental selection or the inclusion of local produce, the overall sentiment was positive. Guests found the breakfast to be worth the additional cost, citing ample portions and great value for money. The breakfast options ranged from hearty full English breakfasts to vegan-friendly choices, catering to a wide array of preferences.
In summary, breakfast at The Caledonian Hotel stands out for its quality, variety and excellent service, making it a highlight of many guests' stays.
The dining experience at The Caledonian Hotel has generally been highly praised by its guests. The restaurant downstairs is frequently highlighted as serving some of the best food, making it an excellent spot for both breakfast and dinner. Guests have described the food as lovely, first class and superb with some meals standing out as particularly amazing, such as the macaroni. The varied menu at the restaurant provides good value for money and the friendly and efficient service adds to the positive dining experience.
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, a few guests noted inconsistencies in food quality and some mentioned occasional lapses in service, such as forgotten items during meals. The attached pub offers a good sports bar environment with commendable pub food, while the bar and dining area are labeled excellent overall. A handful of guests found the meal options somewhat minimal and a couple of reviews mentioned that the dinner atmosphere can be surprisingly quiet at times.
Overall, The Caledonian Hotel's restaurant and bar provide a delightful mix of delicious food and great value, making it a recommended choice for those staying at the hotel.
The rooms at The Caledonian Hotel offer a range of experiences for guests, blending modern comforts with some areas in need of improvement. Many guests praised the spaciousness and cleanliness of the rooms, highlighting features like comfortable beds, spotless environments and good-sized accommodations. Some rooms have been recently refurbished, showcasing modern and appealing designs. Facilities like breakfast included in some room packages and clean bathrooms were also appreciated.
However, the hotel does have its share of dated and tired-looking rooms. Several guests commented on the need for updates and renovations, mentioning issues such as peeling paint, frayed carpets, mould in bathrooms and broken items within the rooms. The decor in certain areas appears old-fashioned and in need of a fresh coat of paint. Noise and lighting issues in some rooms were also noted, along with inadequate heating and ventilation in a few instances.
Despite these concerns, the overall consensus is that the rooms are comfortable and functional. For those seeking a convenient location and basic accommodations with the essentials, The Caledonian Hotel provides an acceptable stay, though a revamp would enhance the overall guest experience significantly.
The Caledonian Hotel receives high praise for its beds, frequently described as very comfortable and even super comfy. Guests often highlight the beds as being clean with lovely bed linen, contributing to a restful night's sleep. Many found the beds to be of good size, ranging from comfy and fluffy to spacious and long with a few noting king-size options. Most reviewers appreciated the overall comfort and cleanliness, although some noted that the beds were a bit firm or a bit small and a minority mentioned that the beds were either too hard or extremely uncomfortable. Despite a few criticisms, the general consensus is that the beds at The Caledonian Hotel offer a comfortable and pleasant sleeping experience, ensuring guests are well-rested during their stay.
The Caledonian Hotel receives predominantly positive reviews regarding its cleanliness. Guests appreciate the "first class" cleanliness standards, highlighting the rooms as "very clean," "spotlessly clean," and "super clean." Many found the accommodations to be both clean and comfortable with multiple mentions of large, modern and spacious rooms that have been meticulously maintained.
However, it's noted that some rooms appear a bit dated and could benefit from updating and a more thorough cleaning. Despite this, bedding and towels consistently receive high marks for cleanliness. The public areas, dining rooms and main entrances are praised for being well-maintained, adding to the overall positive experience. Some guests noted issues such as sticky surfaces and unpleasant smells in certain hallways, but these seem to be exceptions rather than the norm.
The hotel itself is described as clean and functional, though some details like room decor and hallway upkeep could use more attention. Despite a few minor critiques, guests frequently mention the friendly staff and the excellent value for money, making The Caledonian Hotel a recommended stay for cleanliness-conscious travelers.
The Caledonian Hotel is celebrated for its warm and attentive staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere for guests. Reviewers frequently highlight the exceptionally friendly and helpful nature of the team with special mentions for individuals such as Lauren, Shannon and Claire, who go above and beyond to enhance the guest experience. The staff's professionalism and courtesy consistently impress, providing efficient and informative service.
Despite occasional mentions of understaffing and a few less favorable interactions, the overall consensus emphasizes the friendliness, politeness and willingness of the staff to assist with any needs. Their cheerful disposition and exceptional service often leave a lasting impression, making guests feel valued and well-cared-for throughout their stay. With excellent staff coverage from check-in to dining, it’s clear that the team at The Caledonian Hotel plays a significant role in ensuring a pleasant and enjoyable stay for all visitors.
The WiFi at The Caledonian Hotel receives mixed feedback from guests. Many guests found the WiFi to be satisfactory with some mentioning that it worked fine and was quick. However, there were also instances where the internet was described as patchy, slow or too complicated to connect. Some guests reported issues with the WiFi not connecting at all or described it as poor and unreliable. A few reviews specifically noted that there was no internet available in rooms. Overall, while the WiFi meets the needs of some guests, others have encountered challenges with connectivity and reliability.
The Caledonian Hotel offers plenty of free parking and consistently receives compliments for its very good food and always helpful staff. For those seeking a budget-friendly option, it provides good value for money and is an acceptable choice for the price paid. It is regarded as a solid mid-range option with some guests even suggesting it surpasses the quality of typical three-star hotels.
However, the hotel has several areas in need of improvement. The accommodation is often described as tired and dated with rooms requiring a significant update and modernization. While the exterior might not be the most visually appealing, it possesses qualities that could rival higher-star establishments. Despite its shortcomings, many find the overall experience satisfactory and adequate for the cost.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
While there were mentions of areas for improvement, such as the desire for a more extensive continental selection or the inclusion of local produce, the overall sentiment was positive. Guests found the breakfast to be worth the additional cost, citing ample portions and great value for money. The breakfast options ranged from hearty full English breakfasts to vegan-friendly choices, catering to a wide array of preferences.
In summary, breakfast at The Caledonian Hotel stands out for its quality, variety and excellent service, making it a highlight of many guests' stays.
Dinner
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, a few guests noted inconsistencies in food quality and some mentioned occasional lapses in service, such as forgotten items during meals. The attached pub offers a good sports bar environment with commendable pub food, while the bar and dining area are labeled excellent overall. A handful of guests found the meal options somewhat minimal and a couple of reviews mentioned that the dinner atmosphere can be surprisingly quiet at times.
Overall, The Caledonian Hotel's restaurant and bar provide a delightful mix of delicious food and great value, making it a recommended choice for those staying at the hotel.
Rooms
However, the hotel does have its share of dated and tired-looking rooms. Several guests commented on the need for updates and renovations, mentioning issues such as peeling paint, frayed carpets, mould in bathrooms and broken items within the rooms. The decor in certain areas appears old-fashioned and in need of a fresh coat of paint. Noise and lighting issues in some rooms were also noted, along with inadequate heating and ventilation in a few instances.
Despite these concerns, the overall consensus is that the rooms are comfortable and functional. For those seeking a convenient location and basic accommodations with the essentials, The Caledonian Hotel provides an acceptable stay, though a revamp would enhance the overall guest experience significantly.
Beds
Cleanliness
However, it's noted that some rooms appear a bit dated and could benefit from updating and a more thorough cleaning. Despite this, bedding and towels consistently receive high marks for cleanliness. The public areas, dining rooms and main entrances are praised for being well-maintained, adding to the overall positive experience. Some guests noted issues such as sticky surfaces and unpleasant smells in certain hallways, but these seem to be exceptions rather than the norm.
The hotel itself is described as clean and functional, though some details like room decor and hallway upkeep could use more attention. Despite a few minor critiques, guests frequently mention the friendly staff and the excellent value for money, making The Caledonian Hotel a recommended stay for cleanliness-conscious travelers.
Staff
Despite occasional mentions of understaffing and a few less favorable interactions, the overall consensus emphasizes the friendliness, politeness and willingness of the staff to assist with any needs. Their cheerful disposition and exceptional service often leave a lasting impression, making guests feel valued and well-cared-for throughout their stay. With excellent staff coverage from check-in to dining, it’s clear that the team at The Caledonian Hotel plays a significant role in ensuring a pleasant and enjoyable stay for all visitors.
Wi-Fi
3 Star
However, the hotel has several areas in need of improvement. The accommodation is often described as tired and dated with rooms requiring a significant update and modernization. While the exterior might not be the most visually appealing, it possesses qualities that could rival higher-star establishments. Despite its shortcomings, many find the overall experience satisfactory and adequate for the cost.
No, The Caledonian Hotel doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at The Caledonian Hotel.
No, The Caledonian Hotel doesn't allow dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at The Caledonian Hotel.
No, The Caledonian Hotel doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
