The Buck Inn, Malham
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsThe Buck Inn in Malham boasts an exceptional location in the picturesque village, making it a prime choice for hikers and nature enthusiasts. Guests appreciate its proximity to iconic sites like Malham Cove and Janet's Foss, as well as its historic charm and modern comforts. The Inn's central position allows visitors to leave their car parked, as numerous walking paths and local attractions are within easy reach. Coupled with friendly staff and a robust full English breakfast, it stands out as an ideal base for exploring the Yorkshire Dales.
Breakfast at The Buck Inn is generally well-received with many guests praising its tasty, well-cooked offerings and excellent quality. The full English breakfast receives particular accolades, though some guests noted a lack of variety and issues with portion size and timing. Despite these criticisms, the use of local ingredients and availability of gluten-free options were positive highlights.
Dinner experiences at the inn are largely positive as well with guests frequently mentioning the excellent quality and variety of the menu. The evening meals receive high marks for being delicious, well-cooked and served hot, though a few guests pointed out limited menu options and occasional slow service. The inviting bar area with its welcoming atmosphere and open fire, enhances the overall dining experience.
Guest reviews of the rooms present a mixed but generally favorable picture. Many visitors commend the cleanliness, comfort and beautiful views of the surrounding countryside. However, some rooms show signs of age, such as dated décor, mould issues and small bathrooms. Despite these drawbacks, the amenities like in-room tea and coffee and the decent value for money were appreciated. Cleanliness is consistently lauded, though certain communal areas require better upkeep.
The exceptional staff at The Buck Inn garner widespread praise for their friendliness, helpfulness and dedication. Visitors frequently highlight the warm and accommodating atmosphere created by the team, despite occasional understaffing. Named staff members such as Seth, Sophie, Sebastian and Danny receive individual commendations for their outstanding service.
Free WiFi at the Inn has mixed feedback with some guests experiencing weak or intermittent signals, particularly in bedrooms. Connectivity issues, possibly due to the building's age, impact the overall experience for those who rely on a reliable internet connection.
The beds receive general acclaim for their comfort and cleanliness, contributing to a restful night’s sleep for many guests. However, some complaints about double beds made from two single mattresses and occasional issues with bed quality were noted.
As a three-star establishment, The Buck Inn offers good value for money with its rustic charm and historical ambiance. While the building could benefit from updates in décor and interior, the cozy atmosphere and basic amenities meet the expectations set by its rating.
The inn is also highly dog-friendly, making it an excellent choice for pet owners. Dogs are welcomed throughout the premises and the inclusive atmosphere adds to the charm. Although some guests mentioned an odor in dining areas due to wet dogs, the overall pet-friendly environment is a significant draw for families and canine lovers.
In summary, The Buck Inn, Malham is celebrated for its excellent location, friendly staff, generally positive dining experiences and dog-friendly policies. Despite areas needing improvement, it offers a memorable stay with a blend of historical charm and modern amenities.
Categories
Breakfast at The Buck Inn is generally well-received with many guests praising its tasty, well-cooked offerings and excellent quality. The full English breakfast receives particular accolades, though some guests noted a lack of variety and issues with portion size and timing. Despite these criticisms, the use of local ingredients and availability of gluten-free options were positive highlights.
Dinner experiences at the inn are largely positive as well with guests frequently mentioning the excellent quality and variety of the menu. The evening meals receive high marks for being delicious, well-cooked and served hot, though a few guests pointed out limited menu options and occasional slow service. The inviting bar area with its welcoming atmosphere and open fire, enhances the overall dining experience.
Guest reviews of the rooms present a mixed but generally favorable picture. Many visitors commend the cleanliness, comfort and beautiful views of the surrounding countryside. However, some rooms show signs of age, such as dated décor, mould issues and small bathrooms. Despite these drawbacks, the amenities like in-room tea and coffee and the decent value for money were appreciated. Cleanliness is consistently lauded, though certain communal areas require better upkeep.
The exceptional staff at The Buck Inn garner widespread praise for their friendliness, helpfulness and dedication. Visitors frequently highlight the warm and accommodating atmosphere created by the team, despite occasional understaffing. Named staff members such as Seth, Sophie, Sebastian and Danny receive individual commendations for their outstanding service.
Free WiFi at the Inn has mixed feedback with some guests experiencing weak or intermittent signals, particularly in bedrooms. Connectivity issues, possibly due to the building's age, impact the overall experience for those who rely on a reliable internet connection.
The beds receive general acclaim for their comfort and cleanliness, contributing to a restful night’s sleep for many guests. However, some complaints about double beds made from two single mattresses and occasional issues with bed quality were noted.
As a three-star establishment, The Buck Inn offers good value for money with its rustic charm and historical ambiance. While the building could benefit from updates in décor and interior, the cozy atmosphere and basic amenities meet the expectations set by its rating.
The inn is also highly dog-friendly, making it an excellent choice for pet owners. Dogs are welcomed throughout the premises and the inclusive atmosphere adds to the charm. Although some guests mentioned an odor in dining areas due to wet dogs, the overall pet-friendly environment is a significant draw for families and canine lovers.
In summary, The Buck Inn, Malham is celebrated for its excellent location, friendly staff, generally positive dining experiences and dog-friendly policies. Despite areas needing improvement, it offers a memorable stay with a blend of historical charm and modern amenities.
Dog Friendly Inn
Small Inn
3-Star Inn
Guest Reviews
Nestled in the picturesque village of Malham, The Buck Inn boasts a prime location that draws in hikers and nature enthusiasts from all around. Guests consistently praise the Inn's convenience for exploring the breathtaking surroundings, including notable sites like Malham Cove, Janet's Foss and Gordale Scar. The historic pub ambiance adds character, perfectly blending old-world charm with modern comforts. Situated in the heart of Malham, visitors appreciate the central position which offers numerous walking paths right on the doorstep. Free onsite parking is a notable perk in this popular and often crowded village.
The setting of The Buck Inn is often highlighted as idyllic, serving as an excellent base for those eager to venture into the Yorkshire Dales. Despite its remote appeal, the location is distinguished not only for its natural beauty but also for being strategically positioned for easy access to local attractions and essential services. The village of Malham itself is unspoilt, offering stunning landscapes that complement the Inn's inviting and cozy atmosphere.
Coupled with friendly staff and a robust full English breakfast, the Inn's location ensures that guests have a seamless and enjoyable experience, whether they're stepping out for a leisurely stroll or embarking on a more rugged hiking adventure. Visitors often mention that once their car is parked, there's really no need to drive again, as everything worth seeing is within walking distance. This combination of strategic placement, historical charm and superb natural beauty makes The Buck Inn an ideal choice for a memorable stay in Malham.
Guests at The Buck Inn, Malham, had varied experiences with the hotel's breakfasts. Many praised the breakfast with phrases like "tasty breakfast," "amazing breakfast," and "breakfast was great," highlighting the delicious, well-cooked offerings. There were repeated mentions of the breakfast being of excellent quality with options such as a full English breakfast being perfectly cooked and filling, making it exceptional value. Several reviews also noted the friendly and efficient service with staff working hard to ensure guests were satisfied, despite sometimes being short-staffed.
However, some guests pointed out areas needing improvement. Specific criticisms included a lack of variety and limited choices with some describing the breakfast as basic or minimal. Issues such as late breakfast timings, small portions and slow service were also highlighted. Complaints about cold or overcooked items and occasional cleanliness issues with breakfast tables also appeared.
Despite the mixed feedback, the presence of local ingredients and gluten-free options were positive highlights for guests. The overall consensus suggests that while many found breakfast enjoyable and plentiful, others felt it could benefit from a broader selection and more prompt service.
The Buck Inn in Malham has garnered praise for its dining experience with many guests appreciating the excellent and well-prepared food. Reviewers frequently highlight the good quality and variety of the menu, often describing the meals as delicious, well-cooked and served piping hot. The inn's evening meals are especially well-regarded with several noting the great value and generous portions. Highlights include the tasty dinner offerings and standout pub food, alongside positive remarks on the service and the welcoming atmosphere of the bar area, enhanced by an open fire.
Despite the general positivity, some guests mentioned a few drawbacks. Reports of limited menu options and occasional slow service were noted, along with instances of mixed quality and small portions. Additionally, some found certain meals to be average or slightly overcooked.
Overall, The Buck Inn provides a predominantly commendable dining experience with its exceptional evening meals, good selection of dishes and a comfortable, inviting setting that enhances the overall enjoyment of the food.
The guest reviews for The Buck Inn in Malham paint a mixed but generally positive picture of the hotel's rooms. Many guests appreciated the cleanliness and comfort of the rooms, highlighting clean bedding, soft towels and comfy beds. Some rooms were described as spacious with good storage and others enjoyed unique decoration and beautiful views of the surrounding countryside.
However, the decor and fittings showed signs of age in several rooms with mentions of dated interiors, peeling paint and mould issues. The bathrooms were often noted as small and in need of updating and some had trouble with shower temperature regulation. Guests also noted instances of poor housekeeping and issues like blocked drains, unclean carpets and missing amenities. The single glazing and lack of consistent heating left some rooms chilly, despite the provision of supplemental heaters.
Despite these criticisms, many found their rooms met their needs for a short stay, were value for money and appreciated the amenities like in-room tea and coffee. The overall experience seems to hinge on the specific room assigned, as some guests found their accommodations exceeded expectations with spaciousness and lovely decor, while others felt improvements were necessary.
The Buck Inn in Malham generally receives praise for its beds with many guests highlighting the comfort and cleanliness of their sleeping arrangements. Phrases like "comfy beds," "comfortable sleep," and "super comfortable" appear frequently, suggesting that many guests found their beds to be a restful retreat. The hotel also garners positive remarks for its clean bedding and spaciousness with some guests specifically noting the quality of mattresses and pillows.
However, not all feedback is glowing. A recurring criticism involves double beds being made from two single mattresses pushed together, which didn't provide a comfortable experience for some. Complaints about lumpy, hard or noisy mattresses also emerged, indicating occasional inconsistency in bed quality. Additionally, a few guests found the beds to be too small or in need of updating.
Despite these occasional issues, the consensus leans towards a positive experience with comfortable and clean beds contributing to a good night's sleep for many travelers. Overall, The Buck Inn appears to offer a generally satisfying sleeping arrangement, although improvements in certain areas could enhance guest comfort further.
The Buck Inn in Malham boasts an overall reputation for cleanliness as highlighted by several guest reviews. Many visitors found their rooms and en-suites to be very clean and tidy with some even describing their rooms as spotless. The warm, clean rooms with fluffy towels and comfortable beds contributed to a pleasant stay for many guests. The Inn’s traditional and cosy atmosphere paired with its convenient location near walking paths also added to its appeal.
However, there are areas needing attention. Some guests pointed out dated décor and neglected bathrooms with specific mentions of mould and tired appearances. Certain communal areas like the bar and dining rooms, as well as some rooms, have been described as insufficiently clean with issues such as sticky tables, dirty carpets and cobwebs.
In summary, while The Buck Inn generally maintains a standard of clean and comfortable accommodation, there are inconsistencies that need addressing, particularly in the upkeep of shared spaces and older bathroom facilities. The hotel's prime location and charming pub atmosphere remain significant positives.
The Buck Inn, Malham has garnered numerous positive reviews for its exceptional staff. The overwhelming consensus highlights the friendliness, helpfulness and dedication of the team. Guests frequently describe the staff as welcoming, cheerful and always willing to go the extra mile to ensure a pleasant stay. Many visitors appreciated the attentive service and noted that staff members were not only polite and courteous but also genuinely engaged with guests, creating a warm and accommodating atmosphere.
While there were a few mentions of occasional understaffing, this did not significantly detract from the overall positive experience. Several specific staff members, including those named Seth, Sophie, Sebastian and Danny, received individual praise for their exceptional service and ability to make guests feel cared for.
Despite some isolated instances of slow service or less favorable interactions, the consensus remains that the staff at The Buck Inn are a major highlight of the establishment, contributing greatly to a hospitable and enjoyable stay.
Guests at The Buck Inn in Malham have expressed varied experiences regarding the hotel's WiFi. While some reported no issues or complaints, others found the signal weak, intermittent or non-existent, particularly in the bedrooms. Several reviews mentioned that the poor reception quality and slow internet could be attributed to the building's age. A few guests appreciated the WiFi despite its flaws, but overall, the general consensus suggests that the hotel's internet service leaves much to be desired. Efforts to rectify the connectivity issues appear to be lacking, impacting the overall experience for those who value a reliable internet connection during their stay.
The Buck Inn, Malham offers a unique lodging experience within its charming, rustic pub setting. This very old building, filled with history and an authentic country atmosphere, exudes an old and quaint charm that appeals to those seeking a traditional inn experience. Guests can enjoy the lovely open fire and the Boltmaker beer, which is highly praised.
The cost of staying at The Buck Inn represents good value for money with accommodation described as clean, tidy and generally adequate for a three-star rating. Despite some minor issues relating to the dated decor and tired-looking interior, including peeling paint and old carpets, the basic amenities are sufficient for the price, adding to the overall adequate experience.
While the property could benefit from some refurbishment and a freshen-up in areas such as the bar and guest room windows, the building's cozy atmosphere and rustic appeal remain a significant draw. The service provided by James and his staff receives high marks with guests appreciating their fantastic care and hospitality. The Buck Inn stands as a charming, value-for-money option for visitors looking to immerse themselves in an authentic country pub experience.
The Buck Inn in Malham has garnered a reputation as a highly dog-friendly establishment, warmly welcoming canine companions throughout its premises. Located in an idyllic setting, it's an excellent destination for dog owners, evident from the numerous positive remarks about the pet-friendly policies. Dogs are not only allowed but are made to feel welcome in the rooms, restaurant, bar and general areas, making it easy for guests to enjoy their stay without worrying about their furry friends.
The hotel features dog-friendly rooms and even some larger accommodations to comfortably host multiple dogs and their owners. The presence of a dog menu and options to accommodate both children and pets further enhances the experience for families and canine lovers alike. Visitors particularly appreciated the inclusive atmosphere where dogs could join their owners in most activities.
Nonetheless, the dog-friendly ambiance does come with a few caveats. Some guests mentioned an odour in the dining room and bar, attributing it to wet dogs, which could be a mild inconvenience for those sensitive to such smells. Moreover, dogs are not allowed in specific areas like certain rooms, respecting guests who might have allergies or a preference for a pet-free environment.
Overall, The Buck Inn's dedication to being a dog-friendly venue is highly commendable, ensuring a pleasant and accommodating stay for both humans and their canine companions. It stands out as a top choice for dog owners seeking a comfortable and inclusive getaway.
Location Show Map
Location
The setting of The Buck Inn is often highlighted as idyllic, serving as an excellent base for those eager to venture into the Yorkshire Dales. Despite its remote appeal, the location is distinguished not only for its natural beauty but also for being strategically positioned for easy access to local attractions and essential services. The village of Malham itself is unspoilt, offering stunning landscapes that complement the Inn's inviting and cozy atmosphere.
Coupled with friendly staff and a robust full English breakfast, the Inn's location ensures that guests have a seamless and enjoyable experience, whether they're stepping out for a leisurely stroll or embarking on a more rugged hiking adventure. Visitors often mention that once their car is parked, there's really no need to drive again, as everything worth seeing is within walking distance. This combination of strategic placement, historical charm and superb natural beauty makes The Buck Inn an ideal choice for a memorable stay in Malham.
Breakfast
However, some guests pointed out areas needing improvement. Specific criticisms included a lack of variety and limited choices with some describing the breakfast as basic or minimal. Issues such as late breakfast timings, small portions and slow service were also highlighted. Complaints about cold or overcooked items and occasional cleanliness issues with breakfast tables also appeared.
Despite the mixed feedback, the presence of local ingredients and gluten-free options were positive highlights for guests. The overall consensus suggests that while many found breakfast enjoyable and plentiful, others felt it could benefit from a broader selection and more prompt service.
Dinner
Despite the general positivity, some guests mentioned a few drawbacks. Reports of limited menu options and occasional slow service were noted, along with instances of mixed quality and small portions. Additionally, some found certain meals to be average or slightly overcooked.
Overall, The Buck Inn provides a predominantly commendable dining experience with its exceptional evening meals, good selection of dishes and a comfortable, inviting setting that enhances the overall enjoyment of the food.
Rooms
However, the decor and fittings showed signs of age in several rooms with mentions of dated interiors, peeling paint and mould issues. The bathrooms were often noted as small and in need of updating and some had trouble with shower temperature regulation. Guests also noted instances of poor housekeeping and issues like blocked drains, unclean carpets and missing amenities. The single glazing and lack of consistent heating left some rooms chilly, despite the provision of supplemental heaters.
Despite these criticisms, many found their rooms met their needs for a short stay, were value for money and appreciated the amenities like in-room tea and coffee. The overall experience seems to hinge on the specific room assigned, as some guests found their accommodations exceeded expectations with spaciousness and lovely decor, while others felt improvements were necessary.
Beds
However, not all feedback is glowing. A recurring criticism involves double beds being made from two single mattresses pushed together, which didn't provide a comfortable experience for some. Complaints about lumpy, hard or noisy mattresses also emerged, indicating occasional inconsistency in bed quality. Additionally, a few guests found the beds to be too small or in need of updating.
Despite these occasional issues, the consensus leans towards a positive experience with comfortable and clean beds contributing to a good night's sleep for many travelers. Overall, The Buck Inn appears to offer a generally satisfying sleeping arrangement, although improvements in certain areas could enhance guest comfort further.
Cleanliness
However, there are areas needing attention. Some guests pointed out dated décor and neglected bathrooms with specific mentions of mould and tired appearances. Certain communal areas like the bar and dining rooms, as well as some rooms, have been described as insufficiently clean with issues such as sticky tables, dirty carpets and cobwebs.
In summary, while The Buck Inn generally maintains a standard of clean and comfortable accommodation, there are inconsistencies that need addressing, particularly in the upkeep of shared spaces and older bathroom facilities. The hotel's prime location and charming pub atmosphere remain significant positives.
Staff
While there were a few mentions of occasional understaffing, this did not significantly detract from the overall positive experience. Several specific staff members, including those named Seth, Sophie, Sebastian and Danny, received individual praise for their exceptional service and ability to make guests feel cared for.
Despite some isolated instances of slow service or less favorable interactions, the consensus remains that the staff at The Buck Inn are a major highlight of the establishment, contributing greatly to a hospitable and enjoyable stay.
Wi-Fi
3 Star
The cost of staying at The Buck Inn represents good value for money with accommodation described as clean, tidy and generally adequate for a three-star rating. Despite some minor issues relating to the dated decor and tired-looking interior, including peeling paint and old carpets, the basic amenities are sufficient for the price, adding to the overall adequate experience.
While the property could benefit from some refurbishment and a freshen-up in areas such as the bar and guest room windows, the building's cozy atmosphere and rustic appeal remain a significant draw. The service provided by James and his staff receives high marks with guests appreciating their fantastic care and hospitality. The Buck Inn stands as a charming, value-for-money option for visitors looking to immerse themselves in an authentic country pub experience.
Dog Friendly
The hotel features dog-friendly rooms and even some larger accommodations to comfortably host multiple dogs and their owners. The presence of a dog menu and options to accommodate both children and pets further enhances the experience for families and canine lovers alike. Visitors particularly appreciated the inclusive atmosphere where dogs could join their owners in most activities.
Nonetheless, the dog-friendly ambiance does come with a few caveats. Some guests mentioned an odour in the dining room and bar, attributing it to wet dogs, which could be a mild inconvenience for those sensitive to such smells. Moreover, dogs are not allowed in specific areas like certain rooms, respecting guests who might have allergies or a preference for a pet-free environment.
Overall, The Buck Inn's dedication to being a dog-friendly venue is highly commendable, ensuring a pleasant and accommodating stay for both humans and their canine companions. It stands out as a top choice for dog owners seeking a comfortable and inclusive getaway.
No, The Buck Inn, Malham doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at The Buck Inn, Malham.
Yes, The Buck Inn, Malham welcomes dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at The Buck Inn, Malham.
No, The Buck Inn, Malham doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
