West Highland Hotel
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsThe West Highland Hotel is celebrated for its strategic and picturesque location, offering stunning panoramic views of the bay, sea and the Isle of Skye. Situated a short walk away from the train station, ferry terminal and central Mallaig, its prime position is ideal for travelers looking to explore the area. The hotel’s elevated site ensures breathtaking views from many rooms and public areas, adding to its charm. Guests appreciate the convenient proximity to shops, bars, restaurants and local attractions. The friendly staff, cozy and clean rooms and lovely atmosphere contribute to a highly rated overall experience.
The breakfast at the West Highland Hotel receives mixed reviews. Many guests praised the variety and presentation of the buffet breakfast, particularly the continental offerings such as fresh fruits, yogurts, cereals and smoked salmon, enjoyed in a room with spectacular views. On the downside, issues like occasionally cold or unappealing cooked food and the perceived high cost of £16 per person were noted by some guests.
Dinner at the hotel received many positive remarks for its excellent food, particularly seafood platters and steaks and the attentive service. Nevertheless, the restaurant's availability was an issue due to closures from staff shortages or seasonal operations. Some guests found the limited dinner menu disappointing, although nearby alternatives were appreciated.
Regarding the rooms, guests had mixed impressions. Positive reviews highlighted the clean, comfortable and well-appointed rooms with fantastic sea views. Some rooms featured modern, newly refurbished decor and spacious suites. However, criticisms were directed at the small size of some rooms, outdated furnishings, uneven floors and poor insulation. Inadequate soundproofing and missing basic amenities like hair dryers were also mentioned.
Cleanliness at the West Highland Hotel is generally commended with many guests noting spotless rooms and well-maintained public areas. Positive feedback emphasized the clean and welcoming environment, though there were occasional reports of stale linens and lapses in room servicing.
The hotel’s staff stands out for their friendliness and efficiency. Reviews consistently praised the welcoming and helpful nature of the team with special mentions of the front desk staff and managers. Although a few isolated comments mentioned busyness affecting service, overall, the staff significantly contributed to a positive guest experience.
Opinions on the hotel’s free wifi were mixed with some guests finding it fast and others encountering difficulties. Improvements in the reliability and speed of the wifi service would be beneficial.
Parking at the hotel is generally praised for its convenience and ample free spaces both behind and in front of the building. However, some guests noted that the car park could feel cramped and poorly marked.
Family-friendliness at the West Highland Hotel garnered mixed reviews. While the family rooms were praised for size and cleanliness, the hotel could benefit from more comprehensive family-oriented facilities. Staff support for specific needs was highlighted positively.
Guest opinions on the beds were varied with many finding them comfortable but some noting issues with bed size and firmness. There were also concerns about sagging mattresses and the need for bedding replacements.
As a three-star establishment, the hotel offers a classic, cozy ambiance with standard accommodations and services, albeit some parts require renovation. The decor is noted as tired and the amenities outdated, indicating a need for updates to meet modern expectations.
Lastly, the hotel is highly regarded for being dog-friendly with guests appreciating the welcoming attitude towards their pets and the convenient walking opportunities nearby.
In summary, the West Highland Hotel offers a picturesque and convenient location with friendly staff, good cleanliness and decent amenities. However, it could benefit from improvements in breakfast offerings, room updates, wifi reliability and family-friendliness to enhance the overall guest experience.
Categories
The breakfast at the West Highland Hotel receives mixed reviews. Many guests praised the variety and presentation of the buffet breakfast, particularly the continental offerings such as fresh fruits, yogurts, cereals and smoked salmon, enjoyed in a room with spectacular views. On the downside, issues like occasionally cold or unappealing cooked food and the perceived high cost of £16 per person were noted by some guests.
Dinner at the hotel received many positive remarks for its excellent food, particularly seafood platters and steaks and the attentive service. Nevertheless, the restaurant's availability was an issue due to closures from staff shortages or seasonal operations. Some guests found the limited dinner menu disappointing, although nearby alternatives were appreciated.
Regarding the rooms, guests had mixed impressions. Positive reviews highlighted the clean, comfortable and well-appointed rooms with fantastic sea views. Some rooms featured modern, newly refurbished decor and spacious suites. However, criticisms were directed at the small size of some rooms, outdated furnishings, uneven floors and poor insulation. Inadequate soundproofing and missing basic amenities like hair dryers were also mentioned.
Cleanliness at the West Highland Hotel is generally commended with many guests noting spotless rooms and well-maintained public areas. Positive feedback emphasized the clean and welcoming environment, though there were occasional reports of stale linens and lapses in room servicing.
The hotel’s staff stands out for their friendliness and efficiency. Reviews consistently praised the welcoming and helpful nature of the team with special mentions of the front desk staff and managers. Although a few isolated comments mentioned busyness affecting service, overall, the staff significantly contributed to a positive guest experience.
Opinions on the hotel’s free wifi were mixed with some guests finding it fast and others encountering difficulties. Improvements in the reliability and speed of the wifi service would be beneficial.
Parking at the hotel is generally praised for its convenience and ample free spaces both behind and in front of the building. However, some guests noted that the car park could feel cramped and poorly marked.
Family-friendliness at the West Highland Hotel garnered mixed reviews. While the family rooms were praised for size and cleanliness, the hotel could benefit from more comprehensive family-oriented facilities. Staff support for specific needs was highlighted positively.
Guest opinions on the beds were varied with many finding them comfortable but some noting issues with bed size and firmness. There were also concerns about sagging mattresses and the need for bedding replacements.
As a three-star establishment, the hotel offers a classic, cozy ambiance with standard accommodations and services, albeit some parts require renovation. The decor is noted as tired and the amenities outdated, indicating a need for updates to meet modern expectations.
Lastly, the hotel is highly regarded for being dog-friendly with guests appreciating the welcoming attitude towards their pets and the convenient walking opportunities nearby.
In summary, the West Highland Hotel offers a picturesque and convenient location with friendly staff, good cleanliness and decent amenities. However, it could benefit from improvements in breakfast offerings, room updates, wifi reliability and family-friendliness to enhance the overall guest experience.
Hotel with Parking
This hotel offers parking facilities for guests. It is located in a scenic area of the Highlands and has good access to local sights.
EV charging stations
Hotel with EV Charging Stations
The West Highland Hotel provides EV charging facilities for its guests. Specific details regarding the number or type of chargers were not available in public search results.
Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability
Hotel for Honeymoon
Family Friendly Hotel
Dog Friendly Hotel
3-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
The West Highland Hotel boasts an enviable location that consistently impresses its visitors. Nestled high in the town, it offers stunning panoramic views of the bay, the sea and the Isle of Skye. Its prime position is highly praised for being a short walk from the train station, ferry terminal and central Mallaig, making it incredibly convenient for travelers. Guests appreciate the beautiful setting, perfect for a stopover before boarding the ferry to explore Skye or the small isles.
The hotel's elevated site ensures breathtaking views from many rooms and public areas, adding to the overall charm of the place. The proximity to shops, bars, restaurants and local attractions makes it an excellent base for both short and extended stays. Reviewing visitors were particularly fond of the friendly staff, cozy and clean rooms and the lovely atmosphere, which complements the spectacular views offered by the hotel's location on the hill above the village.
In short, the West Highland Hotel is celebrated for its strategic and picturesque location, making it an ideal choice for travelers looking to explore Mallaig and its surrounding areas.
The breakfast experience at the West Highland Hotel presents a mixed narrative. On the positive side, many guests appreciated the varied selection in the buffet breakfast, highlighting its pleasant presentation and the availability of sweet and savory options. Guests frequently described the breakfast as very good, good or even outstanding. Specific praise was directed towards the continental breakfast, often noted for its generous, fresh and high-quality offerings, including items such as fruits, yogurts, cereals, croissants, cold ham, cheese and smoked salmon. The breakfast room's spectacular views and the cozy atmosphere of the hotel itself also garnered favorable mentions.
However, some recurring criticisms suggest that breakfast can be hit-or-miss. Multiple reviews pointed out that the cooked breakfast sometimes arrived cold, dried out or lacked appeal. The pricing was another common critique with several guests feeling that the breakfast was not worth the extra charge of £16 per person, particularly given the quality and variety offered. Issues such as limited selection, poor quality of specific items (like sausage and bacon) and occasional lapses in service efficiency were noted as areas needing improvement.
Overall, while many found the breakfast to be delicious and well-varied, there is a contingent of guests who experienced disappointment, primarily in terms of value for money and the quality of cooked items.
The dinner experience at the West Highland Hotel has garnered a mix of reviews with many guests highlighting positive aspects. Visitors frequently commented on the excellent food and delicious dishes with several praising the restaurant's evening meals, which included standout seafood platters and superb steaks. The restaurant team was noted to be attentive, contributing to enjoyable dining experiences.
However, the availability of the restaurant proved to be an issue for many guests, as there were numerous occasions when it was closed due to staff shortages, refurbishments or being out of season. The limited dinner menu was also mentioned multiple times, likely a result of these staff limitations. When the restaurant was open, some guests found the menu disappointing or limited and a few remarked on the basic or greasy nature of some dishes.
For those unable to dine at the hotel's restaurant, alternatives were available nearby, though the lack of an on-site evening meal was sometimes inconvenient. Despite these issues, when guests could dine in, the meals were often deemed high-quality with particular acclaim for the seafood and the pleasant ambiance.
Overall, while the quality of food and service at the West Highland Hotel's restaurant is generally good, potential guests should be aware of possible closures and limited menu options which might require planning ahead for alternative dining arrangements.
The guest reviews paint a mixed picture of the rooms at the West Highland Hotel. On the positive side, many guests appreciated the rooms, describing them as clean, tidy and comfortable with fantastic sea views. Some rooms were noted for being modern, well-appointed and newly refurbished, adding to the overall comfort. Guests also enjoyed spacious suites, charming decor and cozy atmospheres with some rooms even offering private balconies and beautiful mountain or harbor views.
However, the reviews also highlight several consistent issues. Many rooms were mentioned as being small with some described as tiny and cramped. There was frequent mention of outdated furnishings and facilities, uneven floors and poorly finished bathrooms. Some guests experienced problems with room temperature, poor insulation and non-functional windows. Soundproofing was often inadequate, leading to disturbed sleep. Basic amenities like hair dryers were sometimes missing and guests found the rooms weren't always serviced daily. Overall, while some found their stay pleasant due to the room views and comfort, others felt that the hotel needed significant updates and better maintenance to improve the guest experience.
Guests at the West Highland Hotel had mixed feelings about the beds. Many found the beds to be comfortable with praises for the very comfortable beds, extremely comfortable bedding and some even describing them as one of the most comfortable beds they've ever slept in. The pillows also earned positive feedback for being loved and described as the best hotel pillows for a long time.
However, a number of guests noted issues with the size and comfort of the beds. Some beds were described as small, narrow or too firm with a few guests mentioning specific discomforts such as sagging mattresses or beds that felt like trampolines. There were also comments about the bedding needing replacement and some pillows being too large or firm.
Ultimately, while many appreciated the comfort offered, the hotel's bed quality seemed to be inconsistent, highlighting a need for improvements in both bed size and mattress quality to ensure a universally satisfying guest experience.
Nestled amid the scenic landscapes, the West Highland Hotel stands out for its commendable cleanliness, providing travelers a comforting and inviting atmosphere. Various reviews highlight the hotel's spotless rooms and well-maintained public areas, creating a warm and welcoming environment. Guests frequently mention the cleanliness of the rooms and bathrooms with some describing them as extremely clean, modern and spacious.
Despite a few comments on threadbare carpets and outdated elements, the overall sentiment points towards satisfaction with the hygiene and upkeep. The dining areas and public spaces also meet high cleanliness standards, contributing to a pleasant overall experience. Couples particularly appreciate the cozy and comfortable accommodations, while the refurbished rooms offer modern amenities and comfort.
However, there are isolated reports of cleanliness issues, such as stale bed linens and occasional room servicing lapses. Despite these minor drawbacks, the hotel's dedication to maintaining a clean and comfortable stay appears to be well-recognized by guests. The general consensus indicates that West Highland Hotel ensures a clean, hospitable environment, making it a reliable choice for those seeking tranquility and comfort in their travels.
The West Highland Hotel shines brightly when it comes to its staff, as reflected in numerous guest reviews. Across the board, the staff are described as amazing, friendly and extremely helpful. Many guests noted the warm welcome they received upon arrival, while also highlighting the efficiency and attentiveness of the team throughout their stay.
The hotel’s front desk staff, including specific mentions of the morning receptionist and manager Fiona, consistently made a positive impression. They were noted for their friendliness, helpfulness and accommodating nature, often going out of their way to ensure guests' comfort, including upgrading rooms when necessary.
Guests also commended the cleaning, reception and lounge staff for their exceptional service. The personalized attention and genuine care towards guests were repeatedly acknowledged, creating a welcoming atmosphere that made guests feel truly valued.
There were a few isolated comments about some staff being too busy or not as welcoming. However, these were far outweighed by the glowing praise for the majority of the team.
Overall, the West Highland Hotel’s staff are recognized for their friendliness, efficiency and unwavering commitment to excellent service, contributing significantly to the hotel’s positive guest experience.
The guest reviews of the West Highland Hotel reveal mixed experiences with the hotel's wifi service. While guests appreciate the availability of free wifi, opinions on its reliability and speed vary significantly. Some found the wifi to be fast, while others encountered difficulties connecting or experienced slow and unreliable internet. A few guests noted the absence of wifi altogether. The presence of a sign urging guests to figure out the wifi on their own suggests that connectivity issues may be common. Overall, the wifi service at the West Highland Hotel could benefit from improvements to ensure a more consistent and reliable experience for its guests.
The West Highland Hotel offers a variety of convenient parking options for its guests, ensuring a stress-free experience. The majority of reviews highlight the ample, free parking space available both directly behind the hotel and in additional spots out front. Guests frequently mention that parking is easy and that there are plenty of spaces to choose from with a good-sized car park that provides direct access to the hotel. The parking facilities are considered sufficient and very handy with many appreciating the on-site parking as well. While some noted that the car park can be cramped and poorly marked and finding a reserved parking bay might be a challenge, the overall feedback on parking remains positive. Free parking is a significant perk, contributing to the convenience and accessibility of the hotel.
The West Highland Hotel appears to be a mixed bag when it comes to family-friendly offerings. It is noted to be family friendly and good for families with kids loving the experience. The family room is praised for being a good size and clean, which suggests comfortable accommodations for those traveling with children.
However, there are mentions of limited amenities and a lack of family-friendly options, indicating that while the basic needs may be met, the hotel could improve in providing more comprehensive family-oriented facilities and services. Additionally, there are inconsistencies reported, such as a booked family room not being available upon arrival.
The support from staff in other areas stands out positively, including accommodating specific needs such as mobility problems, showcasing a willingness to assist guests effectively. Although some family amenities are lacking, the hotel staff's helpfulness and the room conditions offer a balanced experience for family travelers.
West Highland Hotel offers a classic, cozy ambiance despite its age and some faded elements, which lend the hotel its unique character. As a three-star establishment, it provides standard three-star accommodations, dining experiences and comfort. The amenities and services align with what one might expect from a hotel of this rating.
However, the hotel is in need of renovation and maintenance to elevate the overall quality. The decor appears tired and could benefit from a refreshing update. Some guests noted basic services and facilities that are somewhat outdated given the pricing.
The breakfast experience has room for improvement with limited offerings and slow service reported by some visitors. Additionally, the absence of a lift and hot food service is a drawback.
Overall, West Highland Hotel offers a traditional, average three-star experience that holds a certain charm, though it could greatly benefit from updates and enhancements to meet modern expectations.
The West Highland Hotel consistently receives positive feedback for its dog-friendly facilities and services. Guests often mention feeling welcomed alongside their pets with staff going out of their way to make both them and their dogs feel comfortable. The hotel is described as very dog-friendly, allowing pets in most areas and providing clean accommodation that does not carry any pet odors, even in rooms like room 32 where dogs have stayed.
The hotel's location also lends itself well to pet owners, offering good walking opportunities for guests with dogs. Reviews highlight the hotel's pet-friendly atmosphere and commend the establishment for being accommodating to pets and their owners. However, one area for improvement noted by visitors is the lack of facilities to dispose of dog waste. Despite this, the overall sentiment is positive, making it an appealing choice for travelers with dogs.
Location Show Map
Location
The hotel's elevated site ensures breathtaking views from many rooms and public areas, adding to the overall charm of the place. The proximity to shops, bars, restaurants and local attractions makes it an excellent base for both short and extended stays. Reviewing visitors were particularly fond of the friendly staff, cozy and clean rooms and the lovely atmosphere, which complements the spectacular views offered by the hotel's location on the hill above the village.
In short, the West Highland Hotel is celebrated for its strategic and picturesque location, making it an ideal choice for travelers looking to explore Mallaig and its surrounding areas.
Breakfast
However, some recurring criticisms suggest that breakfast can be hit-or-miss. Multiple reviews pointed out that the cooked breakfast sometimes arrived cold, dried out or lacked appeal. The pricing was another common critique with several guests feeling that the breakfast was not worth the extra charge of £16 per person, particularly given the quality and variety offered. Issues such as limited selection, poor quality of specific items (like sausage and bacon) and occasional lapses in service efficiency were noted as areas needing improvement.
Overall, while many found the breakfast to be delicious and well-varied, there is a contingent of guests who experienced disappointment, primarily in terms of value for money and the quality of cooked items.
Dinner
However, the availability of the restaurant proved to be an issue for many guests, as there were numerous occasions when it was closed due to staff shortages, refurbishments or being out of season. The limited dinner menu was also mentioned multiple times, likely a result of these staff limitations. When the restaurant was open, some guests found the menu disappointing or limited and a few remarked on the basic or greasy nature of some dishes.
For those unable to dine at the hotel's restaurant, alternatives were available nearby, though the lack of an on-site evening meal was sometimes inconvenient. Despite these issues, when guests could dine in, the meals were often deemed high-quality with particular acclaim for the seafood and the pleasant ambiance.
Overall, while the quality of food and service at the West Highland Hotel's restaurant is generally good, potential guests should be aware of possible closures and limited menu options which might require planning ahead for alternative dining arrangements.
Rooms
However, the reviews also highlight several consistent issues. Many rooms were mentioned as being small with some described as tiny and cramped. There was frequent mention of outdated furnishings and facilities, uneven floors and poorly finished bathrooms. Some guests experienced problems with room temperature, poor insulation and non-functional windows. Soundproofing was often inadequate, leading to disturbed sleep. Basic amenities like hair dryers were sometimes missing and guests found the rooms weren't always serviced daily. Overall, while some found their stay pleasant due to the room views and comfort, others felt that the hotel needed significant updates and better maintenance to improve the guest experience.
Beds
However, a number of guests noted issues with the size and comfort of the beds. Some beds were described as small, narrow or too firm with a few guests mentioning specific discomforts such as sagging mattresses or beds that felt like trampolines. There were also comments about the bedding needing replacement and some pillows being too large or firm.
Ultimately, while many appreciated the comfort offered, the hotel's bed quality seemed to be inconsistent, highlighting a need for improvements in both bed size and mattress quality to ensure a universally satisfying guest experience.
Cleanliness
Despite a few comments on threadbare carpets and outdated elements, the overall sentiment points towards satisfaction with the hygiene and upkeep. The dining areas and public spaces also meet high cleanliness standards, contributing to a pleasant overall experience. Couples particularly appreciate the cozy and comfortable accommodations, while the refurbished rooms offer modern amenities and comfort.
However, there are isolated reports of cleanliness issues, such as stale bed linens and occasional room servicing lapses. Despite these minor drawbacks, the hotel's dedication to maintaining a clean and comfortable stay appears to be well-recognized by guests. The general consensus indicates that West Highland Hotel ensures a clean, hospitable environment, making it a reliable choice for those seeking tranquility and comfort in their travels.
Staff
The hotel’s front desk staff, including specific mentions of the morning receptionist and manager Fiona, consistently made a positive impression. They were noted for their friendliness, helpfulness and accommodating nature, often going out of their way to ensure guests' comfort, including upgrading rooms when necessary.
Guests also commended the cleaning, reception and lounge staff for their exceptional service. The personalized attention and genuine care towards guests were repeatedly acknowledged, creating a welcoming atmosphere that made guests feel truly valued.
There were a few isolated comments about some staff being too busy or not as welcoming. However, these were far outweighed by the glowing praise for the majority of the team.
Overall, the West Highland Hotel’s staff are recognized for their friendliness, efficiency and unwavering commitment to excellent service, contributing significantly to the hotel’s positive guest experience.
Wi-Fi
Parking
Family
However, there are mentions of limited amenities and a lack of family-friendly options, indicating that while the basic needs may be met, the hotel could improve in providing more comprehensive family-oriented facilities and services. Additionally, there are inconsistencies reported, such as a booked family room not being available upon arrival.
The support from staff in other areas stands out positively, including accommodating specific needs such as mobility problems, showcasing a willingness to assist guests effectively. Although some family amenities are lacking, the hotel staff's helpfulness and the room conditions offer a balanced experience for family travelers.
3 Star
However, the hotel is in need of renovation and maintenance to elevate the overall quality. The decor appears tired and could benefit from a refreshing update. Some guests noted basic services and facilities that are somewhat outdated given the pricing.
The breakfast experience has room for improvement with limited offerings and slow service reported by some visitors. Additionally, the absence of a lift and hot food service is a drawback.
Overall, West Highland Hotel offers a traditional, average three-star experience that holds a certain charm, though it could greatly benefit from updates and enhancements to meet modern expectations.
Dog Friendly
The hotel's location also lends itself well to pet owners, offering good walking opportunities for guests with dogs. Reviews highlight the hotel's pet-friendly atmosphere and commend the establishment for being accommodating to pets and their owners. However, one area for improvement noted by visitors is the lack of facilities to dispose of dog waste. Despite this, the overall sentiment is positive, making it an appealing choice for travelers with dogs.
No, West Highland Hotel doesn't have any pool.
No, a spa isn't available at West Highland Hotel.
Yes, West Highland Hotel welcomes dogs.
Yes, parking facilities are available at West Highland Hotel.
No, West Highland Hotel doesn't have a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
