Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In
SmallParkingDog FriendlyFree Wi-FiAdult OnlyPoolOutdoor PoolHoneymoon3 StarFamily4 StarAccessibleLuxuryTennisVineyardRooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-TubGymBeachHeated PoolHistoricGolf5 StarRooms with FireplaceEV charging stationsSustainability JourneyCheapRomanticBusinessSpaBoutique-StyleBeachfrontYoga
  1. World
  2. >North America
  3. >United States
  4. >New York
  5. >Suffolk
  6. >Middle Island

Small Hotels in Middle Island

54 HOTELS IN AND AROUND MIDDLE ISLANDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Aj & TJ BnB main photo
Aj & TJ BnB
4.3 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Sound Beach NYUS flag
9.8
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Parking
Cozy unit main photo
Cozy unit
5.5 mi from Middle Island
Guest House in Centereach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
112 Motel main photo
112 Motel
5.9 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Medford NYUS flag
7.5
Good
From $140
$
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub
The Fox and Owl Inn main photo
The Fox and Owl Inn
6.1 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Port Jefferson NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $178
$
Info
Categories
Small
Sustainability Journey
Parking
JD COZYNEST LLC main photo
JD COZYNEST LLC
6.2 mi from Middle Island
Guest House in Shirley NYUS flag
9.1
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Honeymoon
Parking
67 Lake House main photo
67 Lake House
8.7 mi from Middle Island
Hostel in Brookhaven NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Three Village Inn main photo
Three Village Inn
9.7 mi from Middle Island
Inn in Stony Brook NYUS flag
7.6
Good
From $181
$
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Historic
Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach main photo
Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach
10.3 mi from Middle Island
Country House in Shirley NYUS flag
7.3
Good
From $4,501
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
The SkyBreeze Inn main photo
The SkyBreeze Inn
10.4 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Bohemia NYUS flag
5.8
Rated
$
Info
Categories
Small
Family
Smithpoint motel main photo
Smithpoint motel
10.7 mi from Middle Island
Motel in Shirley NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Come As You Are Inn LLC main photo
Come As You Are Inn LLC
12.0 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Sayville NYUS flag
9.6
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Adult Only
Parking
A Victorian on the Bay Bed and Breakfast main photo
A Victorian on the Bay Bed and Breakfast
13.6 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Eastport NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
From $209
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
The Madison Fire Island Pines main photo
The Madison Fire Island Pines
16.3 mi from Middle Island
Guest House in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.2
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Small
Adult Only
Honeymoon
Westhampton Seabreeze Motel main photo
Westhampton Seabreeze Motel
16.4 mi from Middle Island
Motel in Westhampton NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $233
$
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Commack Inn main photo
Commack Inn
17.2 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Commack NYUS flag
5.6
Rated
$
Info
Categories
Small
4 Star
Seven Beach Lane main photo
Seven Beach Lane
18.0 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Hampton Getaway main photo
Hampton Getaway
18.2 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Free Wi-Fi
A sweet suite main photo
A sweet suite
18.2 mi from Middle Island
Guest House in Westhampton Beach NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
The Surfcomber Unit 3 main photo
The Surfcomber Unit 3
18.7 mi from Middle Island
Motel in Ocean Bay Park NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Accessible
The Ocean Bay House main photo
The Ocean Bay House
18.7 mi from Middle Island
Bed & Breakfast in Bay Shore NYUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $379
$
Info
Categories
Small
Adult Only
Luxury
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 54 hotels in and around Middle Island
Save more on the App
View all hotels in Middle Island
Popular destinations users search for in this category:
Small Hotels in Palm SpringsSmall Hotels in JapanSmall Hotels in Las VegasSmall Hotels in New YorkSmall Hotels in Costa RicaSmall Hotels in Caribbean IslandsSmall Hotels in San FranciscoSmall Hotels in HawaiiSmall Hotels in ArubaSmall Hotels in CharlestonSmall Hotels in Myrtle BeachSmall Hotels in New OrleansSmall Hotels in BermudaSmall Hotels in FloridaSmall Hotels in TulumSmall Hotels in Puerto RicoSmall Hotels in WashingtonSmall Hotels in Playa del CarmenSmall Hotels in PortlandSmall Hotels in TunisiaSmall Hotels in Philadelphia
Categories
1
Map
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities
Featured popular searches
Hotels with Indoor Pool in Ocean City
Hotels in Las Vegas where Dogs Stay Free
Former Castle Hotels in Wales
Hotels near The Beach in Florida
Hotels with Outdoor Pool in Detroit
Hotels near Ski Resorts in New York
Romantic Hotels in Kansas City
Historic Hotels in New Hampshire
5-Star Hotels in Greensboro
Hotels with Rooms With Jacuzzi / Hot-tub in Tucson
Hotels near Golf Courses in Tampa
Family Friendly Hotels in Krabi
Boutique-style Hotels in Greece
Hotels in the Bahamas
Hampton Falls Inn
Evanthia Best View Thirassia Island Hotel