Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

3-Star Hotels with Swimming Pool in Middle Island

23 HOTELS IN AND AROUND MIDDLE ISLANDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven, NY main photo
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven, NY
4.2 mi from Middle Island
Aparthotel in Yaphank NYUS flag
8.7
Very Good
From $181
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Honeymoon
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven main photo
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
4.4 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Yaphank NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $181
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven receives high praise for its strategic and convenient location, making it an ideal base for exploring Long Island's attractions, such as the Hamptons and Montauk. Guests appreciate the proximity to major routes, shopping venues, and dining options, enhancing their stay experience. The hotel is modern, offering convenient amenities and ample parking, which adds value for families and travelers.

Breakfast reviews are mixed, with many guests highlighting the variety and satisfaction of the offerings, particularly the omelettes and unlimited coffee. Despite some suggestions for more fresh options and critiques of disposable dining ware, the breakfast is generally appreciated as a solid complimentary offering.

The rooms are frequently described as spacious, comfortable, and well-furnished, with a kitchenette and amenities that suit both short and extended stays. Cleanliness stands out across the hotel, from rooms to common areas, and this contributes significantly to the positive guest experience. The attentive and friendly staff further enhance this impression, although there are isolated notes for improvement regarding breakfast service and front desk engagement.

The hotel's fitness room and indoor pool offer additional recreational options, with the gym being well-equipped and including a Peloton bike. The pool is popular among families, providing a nice space for children, despite occasional feedback on temperature and chlorination.

Parking facilities receive positive remarks, with guests appreciating the ample, free, and secure parking options. The hotel is particularly noted for being a great choice for families, thanks to its spacious rooms, family-friendly amenities, and a satisfying breakfast that caters well to guests with children.

Overall, Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven offers a comfortable, clean, and convenient stay with excellent service and amenities, making it a favored option for various types of travelers, especially families.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Sustainability Journey
Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island main photo
Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island
4.8 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Medford NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
From $123
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island is highly regarded for its strategic and ideal location, making it an excellent base for exploring Long Island, the Hamptons, and nearby areas. Situated conveniently off the Long Island Expressway, this hotel provides easy access to major roadways and a safe, peaceful environment. Its proximity to restaurants, convenience stores, and gas stations further enhances guests' experiences, while the clean and well-maintained surroundings ensure a restful stay.

Guests frequently commend the complimentary breakfast for its quality and variety. The breakfast includes an impressive selection of both hot and cold options, with standout offerings such as waffles and cheese omelets, providing a delightful start to the day. The breakfast area is noted for its cleanliness, while the staff receives high praise for their efficiency and politeness, contributing to a pleasant morning routine.

The accommodations at Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island are lauded for their spaciousness, cleanliness, and comfort. Guests appreciate the restful beds and plush pillows, with the inclusion of amenities like a refrigerator and microwave in each room adding to the convenience. The overall atmosphere of the hotel is serene, and the rooms are equipped with modern amenities such as smart TVs and high-quality toiletries, despite some minor concerns about outdated furnishings.

Cleanliness is a standout feature at this hotel, with many guests describing the property as immaculate. Both the rooms and common facilities like the pool and gym are consistently maintained to high standards. The staff's dedication to guest satisfaction enhances the overall experience, with team members like Dawn, Michael, and Lexy being particularly highlighted for their exceptional service.

The pool area, though modest in size, offers a warm and inviting space for relaxation, adding to the hotel’s appeal for families and individuals alike. Its cleanliness and maintenance are consistently praised, providing a spa-like experience for guests. While occasional maintenance issues are noted, these do not detract significantly from the positive feedback.

In summary, the Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island offers a dependable and convenient lodging option with excellent service, cleanliness, and comfort. The enthusiasm of the staff, combined with the location's strategic advantages and quality amenities, ensures that guests have a delightful and relaxing stay.
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Gym
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven main photo
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
5.2 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Farmingville NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $143
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven receives a wealth of positive feedback across numerous categories, making it a preferred choice for travelers seeking a convenient and comfortable stay. Strategically located near McArthur Airport and major highways, the hotel offers easy access to shopping centers, dining options, and local attractions, while maintaining a safe and quiet atmosphere with ample parking.

Guests often commend the complimentary breakfast, lauded for its variety and quality, with substantial options making it a great start to the day. The clean, spacious rooms are highlighted for their comfort, featuring modern amenities and well-maintained spaces. Although some rooms may appear slightly outdated, the cleanliness and attentiveness of the accommodating staff ensure a pleasant stay.

The hotel's commitment to cleanliness extends throughout the property, with guests frequently remarking on the immaculate condition of common areas, including the indoor heated pool, which provides a great family-friendly retreat. The exceptional hospitality of the staff, characterized by friendliness and efficiency, further enhances the guest experience, earning specific praise for the warm and accommodating service.

The hotel also draws attention for its pet-friendly policy, offering convenience for guests traveling with pets, and the comfortable beds, despite receiving mixed reviews regarding firmness and pillow options. Parking is generally sufficient, although clearer communication about fees would improve guest satisfaction. While the WiFi service presents a mixed experience, the overall sentiment is that Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven delivers a solid and reliable accommodation choice, balancing quality and value for a memorable visit.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Family
Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville main photo
Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville
6.7 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Holtsville NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $163
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Business
Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook main photo
Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook
8.0 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Stony Brook NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $174
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with guests praising its prime location, exceptional service, and quality amenities. Situated conveniently on Stony Brook University's campus, the hotel provides easy access to the university, local attractions, and nearby towns such as Port Jefferson. The tranquil setting complements the attentive and hospitable staff, known for their friendliness and professionalism, which enhances the overall guest experience.

Guests consistently commend the hotel's dining services. The breakfast is noted for its variety and quality, with standout options such as fresh-cooked eggs and exceptional French toast, complemented by a welcoming staff. The dinner offerings, including flavorful tacos and wine, are equally lauded, with in-room dining adding a layer of convenience for visitors.

The rooms are described as spacious, modern, and exceptionally clean, equipped with amenities that cater to both leisure and business travelers. Comfortable beds and a welcoming decor ensure a restful stay, while the hotel's cleanliness standards—praised particularly in light of COVID-19 concerns—are consistently highlighted by guests.

The fitness room, although small, is well-equipped and well-maintained, providing a reliable option for guests pursuing fitness. Similarly, the indoor pool and jacuzzi offer a delightful reprieve, with guests appreciating their cleanliness and inviting warmth.

Families find the hotel especially accommodating, given its proximity to the university and hospital, as well as its family-friendly amenities such as the pool and engaging lobby decor. The hotel proves ideal for gatherings and celebrations, like weddings, thanks to its ample space and accommodating service.

Overall, the Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook offers a satisfying and memorable stay characterized by comfort, convenience, and excellent customer service, making it a highly recommended choice for visitors to the region.
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Family
Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport main photo
Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport
8.7 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Ronkonkoma NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $154
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Gym
The Inn and Spa at East Wind main photo
The Inn and Spa at East Wind
8.8 mi from Middle Island
Inn in Wading River NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
From $170
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Spa
Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma main photo
Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma
8.8 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Ronkonkoma NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $175
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Gym
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia main photo
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
12.6 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Islandia NYUS flag
8.2
Very Good
From $146
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia garners widespread praise, making it a favored choice for many travelers. Its prime location is frequently highlighted for convenience, being near amenities such as restaurants, gas stations and entertainment venues like Dave & Buster's. Additionally, its proximity to major highways like the Long Island Expressway and Route 495 makes it exceptionally accessible for those visiting local universities or exploring the area.

Guests compliment the hotel's breakfast, describing it as high-quality and varied, often outshining other comparable hotels. Terms like "awesome” and “plentiful” are commonly used, although occasional remarks suggest room for improvement in selection and presentation. Clean amenities, such as the pool and gym, further enhance the dining experience.

Accommodations at the hotel are considered both spacious and reasonably priced with cleanliness being a prominent theme. Reviews consistently note the rooms and bathrooms as clean and well-maintained. The hotel itself also receives commendations for its overall cleanliness and thoughtful design, despite some mentions of minor issues like stained carpets or occasional appliance malfunctions.

The staff at
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia stands out for their friendliness and helpfulness with numerous guests pointing out their exceptional service. Standout mentions like front desk attendant Bobby underscore the positive impact of the staff on guests’ experiences.

The pool area receives favorable remarks for its cleanliness and upkeep, though its small size and occasional closures are noted. Similarly, beds at the hotel are often described as comfortable, though a few guests have reported inconsistencies with bed sizes and pillow quality.

Overall, the
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia offers a generally positive experience, marked by a convenient location, commendable breakfast, clean facilities and a friendly, attentive staff.
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Sustainability Journey
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End by IHG main photo
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End by IHG
13.1 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Riverhead NYUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $180
$
Info
Categories
Pool
3 Star
Golf
Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia main photo
Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia
13.2 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Hauppauge NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $198
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Business
Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead main photo
Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead
13.4 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Riverhead NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $165
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead presents itself as an attractive accommodation option primarily due to its prime location, outstanding cleanliness and friendly staff. Positioned conveniently on the main road, the hotel offers easy access to Long Island, the Hamptons and popular nearby attractions like Tanger Outlets, an aquarium and Splish Splash water park. This central location is ideal for shopping, dining and fueling up, contributing significantly to its appeal for guests.

While the breakfast experience at the
Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead has received mixed feedback, many guests enjoyed the variety and quality of the food, complemented by the attentive service from the staff. Despite occasional issues with food quality and service efficiency, the overall breakfast experience was positive for many visitors.

The rooms have been praised for their cleanliness, space and comfortable beds, which often guarantees a restful night's sleep. Although some guests noted that the rooms and bathtubs could use modern updates, the overall sentiment is positive with many appreciating the combination of decent pricing and room size.

The hotel's cleanliness extends beyond the rooms to common areas, contributing to a consistently pleasant environment. Guests commend the well-maintained and modern appearance of the property, including the warm indoor pool and convenient amenities.

Staff members are frequently highlighted for their friendliness and professionalism with particular commendations for individuals like Patrick Wheeler. Their courteous and helpful demeanor contributes positively to the guest experience, despite occasional mentions of unwelcoming behavior and slow service during breakfast.

The pool area, featuring both indoor and outdoor hot tubs, is another well-loved amenity, especially appreciated during the colder months. It adds to the overall enjoyable guest experience, alongside other hotel facilities like the bar and restaurant.

However, opinions on the beds were mixed with some guests finding them super comfortable while others noted discomfort and issues with the pillows. There is a general call for improvements in bedding to enhance comfort.

In summary, the
Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead stands out for its excellent location, high standards of cleanliness and friendly staff, making it a comfortable and convenient choice for travelers. Though there are areas for improvement, particularly in breakfast consistency and bedding comfort, the overall guest experience remains highly positive.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Family
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG main photo
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG
14.3 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Hauppauge NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $141
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG is favorably regarded by guests for its strategic location, particularly appealing to both leisure and business travelers. Situated in the heart of Long Island and in close proximity to major highways like the Long Island Expressway, it offers convenient access to local attractions and nearby business engagements. The ease of travel and spacious, secure parking enhance the guest experience, making it an ideal retreat in central Long Island.

Guests consistently commend the hotel for its breakfast offerings, which feature a broad array of options from traditional favorites to choices catering to different dietary needs. The breakfast experience is enriched by the friendly and courteous staff, contributing to a pleasant start to the day.

The rooms receive positive feedback for their cleanliness, modern decor following recent renovations, and generous size, which includes amenities such as a coffeemaker, fridge, and microwave. The beds are especially noted for their comfort, with guests appreciating the selection of soft and firm pillows. Although some isolated issues with cleanliness have been reported, these are exceptions. The attentive customer service further elevates the stay, as guests encounter a helpful and professional team dedicated to accommodating their needs.

Cleanliness is a strong point of the hotel, with both rooms and common areas being well-maintained, creating a cozy atmosphere. The hotel ensures a tranquil environment at night, and despite some minor maintenance issues, the overall impression remains positive.

The friendly and welcoming staff is frequently highlighted, with guests often mentioning the excellent service provided by individuals such as Otilia. Their positive interactions contribute significantly to the overall pleasant environment of the hotel.

Families particularly enjoy the indoor pool, which is clean, well-maintained, and kid-friendly, providing a great opportunity for children to have fun. Despite some feedback on water temperature, the pool remains a positive aspect and complements the overall guest experience.

In summary, the Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island by IHG provides a reliable and restful stay with its strategic location, comprehensive breakfast offerings, comfortable and clean rooms, and exceptionally friendly staff, ensuring a welcoming environment for all guests.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Golf
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex main photo
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
14.6 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Central Islip NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $173
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Parking
EV charging stations
Hyatt Place Long Island East End main photo
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
16.4 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Riverhead NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $178
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Hyatt Place Long Island East End features an enviable central location on Long Island, making it an ideal base for exploring the rich attractions of the North and South Forks. Positioned adjacent to the Long Island Aquarium and Treasure Cove Marina, the hotel offers scenic waterfront views and easy access to numerous dining and shopping options. This strategic positioning, combined with the peaceful neighborhood atmosphere, makes it a family-friendly choice, complemented by the convenience of free parking and breakfast.

Guests consistently appreciate the hotel's breakfast offerings, which boast a variety of high-quality items, including traditional favorites and options catering to diverse dietary needs. The ever-changing buffet selection ensures a refreshing start to each morning. The clean, inviting breakfast areas and accommodating staff fulfilling special requests enhance the experience.

The spacious and modernly updated rooms are notable for their cleanliness and delightful views of the harbor or river. Equipped with amenities like cozy beds and designated workspaces, the rooms cater to families with features such as sleeper sofas. Guests find the generous size and quality worthwhile, despite occasional mentions of high rates.

Cleanliness is a standout feature of this hotel, with both common areas and rooms meticulously maintained. The efficient and friendly staff contribute to a welcoming environment, enhancing guests' experiences with thoughtful service. Free Wi-Fi ensures business travelers remain connected, adding to the hotel's appeal.

For leisure activities, guests enjoy access to both indoor and outdoor pools, well-maintained and complemented by an outdoor bar. These amenities provide a cozy spot for relaxation and are a hit with families. The hotel also offers a fitness center, which, although small, is appreciated for its cleanliness.

Families particularly enjoy the hotel's ambiance and child-friendly amenities, with easy access to nearby attractions making it a convenient choice. Activities like movie nights for kids add to the fun experience. Additionally, the property is pet-friendly, accommodating families traveling with small dogs.

Overall, Hyatt Place Long Island East End consistently delivers a high-quality stay with its thoughtful offerings and attentive service, making it an appealing choice for both families and business travelers.
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
Outdoor Pool
3 Star
Family
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island main photo
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
16.5 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Hauppauge NYUS flag
6.5
Rated
From $136
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island generally earns positive reviews, particularly for its advantageous location, attentive staff, and comfortable accommodations. Its strategic positioning near major highways makes it a convenient choice for travelers visiting both Long Island and New York City, with easy access to local attractions and amenities. The hotel's ample parking facility further enhances convenience, accommodating guests with their own transportation needs.

The staff consistently receives high praise, with numerous mentions of their friendliness and professionalism. Employees like Steven, Dahkari, Josh, Zekiyah, Christi, and Toni have been specifically commended for their exceptional service, contributing significantly to the overall positive guest experience.

Guests frequently highlight the cleanliness and comfort of the rooms, especially the beds, which are noted for providing a restful night’s sleep. While there are occasional remarks about the dated facilities and minor maintenance issues, the general sentiment remains favorable for short stays, with the quiet and spacious rooms allowing for relaxation.

Breakfast offerings receive mixed reviews, with many guests enjoying the variety and quality, including an omelet bar. However, there is some inconsistency in pricing and availability, impacting overall satisfaction.

The pool, while appreciated by some for its warmth and enjoyable activities, has issues with cleanliness and accessibility that may hinder the experience for some guests. Potential visitors are advised to check with the hotel for current pool conditions.

Overall, the Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island provides a comfortable and welcoming environment, thanks to its stellar staff and convenient location, making it a solid choice for business and leisure travelers alike.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
3 Star
Business
Grove Hotel main photo
Grove Hotel
17.0 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Cherry Grove NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $170
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
3 Star
Dog Friendly
Hamptons Vacation Inn main photo
Hamptons Vacation Inn
22.5 mi from Middle Island
Inn in Hampton Bays NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
From $241
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
3 Star
Dog Friendly
Residence Inn Milford main photo
Residence Inn Milford
23.3 mi from Middle Island
Hotel in Milford CTUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $195
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
3 Star
Family
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 23 hotels in and around Middle Island
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities