The Middlebury Inn offers clean and comfortable rooms with some being spacious and modernized. The staff is accommodating and helpful, even switching rooms when needed. Some rooms are beautifully decorated in traditional style, while others are simple and tidy. The beds are described as very comfy with soft, comfortable bedding. Some rooms offer mini fridges and coffee, although some guests note that not all rooms come with a fridge. Overall, the property is well kept, clean and nice. However, some guests have expressed disappointment in some outdated and worn-out rooms or rooms in the back annex that lack charm. Despite some mixed reviews, the Middlebury Inn offers a charming historic hotel with classic tiled bathrooms, comfortable beds, inviting lobby, restaurant and veranda overlooking the commons.
