Montauk Manor
➔
➔
Please select your travel dates to see rates and availability
Info
Summary of reviewsMontauk Manor stands out for its splendid location, historic charm and tranquil environment, making it a favorite retreat for guests. Perched on a hilltop, the manor offers breathtaking panoramic views, especially during sunset, enhancing its appeal. Its proximity to the center of Montauk, along with easy access to shopping, the train station and the beach, offers both convenience and serenity. A complimentary shuttle service to town further ensures a hassle-free exploration of local attractions.
Accommodations at Montauk Manor are broadly praised for their spaciousness, cleanliness and elegant décor. Guests often mention that the rooms feel more like small apartments, providing ample space and comfort with full kitchens being a notable feature. The views from the rooms, particularly those overlooking the sea, are frequently described as magnificent. While some rooms are noted to be dated or in need of renovation, the overall cleanliness and luxurious ambiance are significant positives. The grounds are beautifully maintained with facilities such as a pool and shuttle service adding to the manor's charm.
The staff at Montauk Manor is frequently credited for their friendliness and helpfulness, significantly enhancing the overall guest experience. From the front desk to housekeeping, the team is generally attentive and accommodating, contributing to a welcoming environment. There are occasional reports of inconsistent service, but these are exceptions rather than the rule.
Breakfast at Montauk Manor receives mixed reviews. While the weekend offerings at Montes are well-received for their delicious and high-quality food, guests have expressed disappointment over the limited weekday breakfast options and lack of variety, particularly for vegetarians. When available, breakfast is seen as a delightful start to the day despite occasional concerns about cost.
Dinner experiences at Montes Restaurant are similarly varied. Many guests commend the delicious food and excellent service, particularly noting staff members who go above and beyond. However, the restaurant's sporadic operating hours often cause frustration, forcing guests to seek alternatives. When operational, the restaurant is considered a valuable amenity despite some critiques about portion sizes and cost.
The hotel's cleanliness is a standout feature with many guests highlighting the immaculate condition of their rooms and common areas. The housekeeping staff is frequently praised for their thoroughness and accommodating nature, although some reviews point out minor issues like dust and outdated décor.
Free Wi-Fi is offered at Montauk Manor, but its reliability varies. While some guests have no issues accessing the internet, others experience inconsistent connectivity, particularly in their rooms.
The spa and gym facilities receive mixed feedback due to their frequent unavailability. While guests enjoy the spa services and well-maintained pools when accessible, many express disappointment over the inconsistent operational hours and closures. The gym is also noted as small and often inaccessible, leaving room for improvement.
The outdoor pool is a highlight, appreciated for its warmth, cleanliness and ample space, making it a favorite spot for relaxation. However, the closure of the indoor pool and jacuzzi during renovations has been a point of contention.
Montauk Manor's tennis facilities are well-regarded when available, adding to the overall positive guest experience. The property is particularly well-suited for families, offering family-friendly amenities and activities, making it a popular choice for those traveling with children.
Lastly, while the beds receive mixed reviews with some guests finding them very comfortable and others pointing out issues with firmness and outdated mattresses, the overall comfort and cleanliness of the accommodations are generally appreciated.
In summary, Montauk Manor provides a picturesque and comfortable stay, complemented by friendly staff and stunning views. While there are areas for improvement, particularly with dining options, amenities availability and bed quality, the manor's charm and tranquil environment make it a favored destination for many visitors.
Categories
Accommodations at Montauk Manor are broadly praised for their spaciousness, cleanliness and elegant décor. Guests often mention that the rooms feel more like small apartments, providing ample space and comfort with full kitchens being a notable feature. The views from the rooms, particularly those overlooking the sea, are frequently described as magnificent. While some rooms are noted to be dated or in need of renovation, the overall cleanliness and luxurious ambiance are significant positives. The grounds are beautifully maintained with facilities such as a pool and shuttle service adding to the manor's charm.
The staff at Montauk Manor is frequently credited for their friendliness and helpfulness, significantly enhancing the overall guest experience. From the front desk to housekeeping, the team is generally attentive and accommodating, contributing to a welcoming environment. There are occasional reports of inconsistent service, but these are exceptions rather than the rule.
Breakfast at Montauk Manor receives mixed reviews. While the weekend offerings at Montes are well-received for their delicious and high-quality food, guests have expressed disappointment over the limited weekday breakfast options and lack of variety, particularly for vegetarians. When available, breakfast is seen as a delightful start to the day despite occasional concerns about cost.
Dinner experiences at Montes Restaurant are similarly varied. Many guests commend the delicious food and excellent service, particularly noting staff members who go above and beyond. However, the restaurant's sporadic operating hours often cause frustration, forcing guests to seek alternatives. When operational, the restaurant is considered a valuable amenity despite some critiques about portion sizes and cost.
The hotel's cleanliness is a standout feature with many guests highlighting the immaculate condition of their rooms and common areas. The housekeeping staff is frequently praised for their thoroughness and accommodating nature, although some reviews point out minor issues like dust and outdated décor.
Free Wi-Fi is offered at Montauk Manor, but its reliability varies. While some guests have no issues accessing the internet, others experience inconsistent connectivity, particularly in their rooms.
The spa and gym facilities receive mixed feedback due to their frequent unavailability. While guests enjoy the spa services and well-maintained pools when accessible, many express disappointment over the inconsistent operational hours and closures. The gym is also noted as small and often inaccessible, leaving room for improvement.
The outdoor pool is a highlight, appreciated for its warmth, cleanliness and ample space, making it a favorite spot for relaxation. However, the closure of the indoor pool and jacuzzi during renovations has been a point of contention.
Montauk Manor's tennis facilities are well-regarded when available, adding to the overall positive guest experience. The property is particularly well-suited for families, offering family-friendly amenities and activities, making it a popular choice for those traveling with children.
Lastly, while the beds receive mixed reviews with some guests finding them very comfortable and others pointing out issues with firmness and outdated mattresses, the overall comfort and cleanliness of the accommodations are generally appreciated.
In summary, Montauk Manor provides a picturesque and comfortable stay, complemented by friendly staff and stunning views. While there are areas for improvement, particularly with dining options, amenities availability and bed quality, the manor's charm and tranquil environment make it a favored destination for many visitors.
Luxury Hotel
Montauk Manor is a historic resort offering condominium accommodations with hotel services. It provides significant amenities including indoor and outdoor pools, a health club, and tennis courts.
Hotel near Golf Courses
Situated in Montauk, guests are close to the highly-rated Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course. Montauk is a popular destination for its public golf options.
Hotel Taking Steps Towards Sustainability
Montauk Manor has an eco-friendliness rating of 10/10 and 8.8/10 based on reviews. The manor offers eco-friendly services.
Hotel for Honeymoon
Montauk Manor is known for its grand architecture and panoramic views of Block Island Sound. The combination of historic charm and modern amenities provides a memorable and romantic setting.
Hotel with Spa
Offering spa services and facilities.
Family Friendly Hotel
This hotel is known for its family-friendly environment and offers studios and apartments with one, two, or three bedrooms. The property includes a pool and tennis courts, along with sunset views.
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Montauk Manor offers a historic setting with an outdoor pool. The property provides spacious accommodations and scenic views.
Heated Pool Outdoor Pool
Accessible Hotel
Montauk Manor features ADA compliant guest rooms with accessible bathrooms that include grab bars, shower benches or chairs, adjustable shower wands, accessible vanities, and raised toilet seats with grab bars. Accessible closet rods and entry ramps for wheelchairs are available, as is a chair lift for the jacuzzi and wheelchair access to common areas.
Hotel with Tennis Courts
This historic hotel in Montauk provides tennis courts for its guests. Set on an estate overlooking the bay, it offers classic accommodations and recreational facilities.
Hotel with Rooms With Fireplace
Located in Montauk, some rooms in this hotel may offer fireplace amenities. The hotel boasts of beautiful grounds and an old world feel.
Hotel with EV Charging Stations
This hotel is listed as having EV charging stations.
Hotel with Outdoor Pool
Montauk Manor, a national landmark, offers both an outdoor and indoor swimming pool. The property provides a magnificent outdoor swimming pool and is noted for its elegant atmosphere and spectacular views.
Hotel with Heated Pool
This year-round resort features an outdoor heated pool.
Romantic Hotel
Business Hotel
Hotel with Gym
5-Star Hotel
Guest Reviews
Montauk Manor enjoys an enviable location that blends tranquility with convenience. Nestled on a hilltop, the manor boasts spectacular panoramic views, particularly breathtaking at sunset. Its beautiful architecture and historic charm draw guests to its peaceful and well-maintained grounds. Despite its isolation offering a peaceful retreat, the hotel is conveniently close to the center of Montauk with easy access to shopping, the train station and the beach. Guests appreciate the shuttle service that facilitates transport to town, making it a convenient base for exploring local attractions. The serene environment and friendly staff further enhance the relaxing atmosphere, while spacious, comfortable rooms with magnificent views add to the appeal of this historic property. The combination of stunning views, rich history and excellent location make Montauk Manor a favored choice for a restful and picturesque stay.
Guests at Montauk Manor consistently praised breakfast on weekends as delicious and excellent, particularly at Montes, which was highlighted as great for morning meals. Many appreciated the high quality and found the food offerings tasty, though some noted that breakfast could be expensive.
However, there were several critiques regarding the limited availability of breakfast. The restaurant is typically closed on weekdays, resulting in no breakfast or coffee options onsite during those days. This was disappointing for many visitors who wished for a full-week breakfast service. The off-season menu offered a more limited selection, often just breakfast sandwiches and some guests noted availability issues, like running out of breakfast potatoes.
Vegetarian options were noted as lacking and some guests desired better meal pricing and more variety. Despite the fluctuations in service availability, weekend breakfasts were generally well-received when available.
Montauk Manor is praised for its picturesque setting and convenient amenities, including an on-site restaurant that guests have mixed feelings about. Montes Restaurant, one of the dining options, has received accolades from several guests, who describe the food as delicious and the service outstanding. Notable mentions include the excellent service from staff members like Aneta and Kristina, who particularly impressed diners with their hospitality. Guests loved the delicious clam chowder and highlighted the variety of dinner options available.
However, the restaurant's operating hours have been a point of contention. Guests frequently encountered closures, even on nights they expected the restaurant to be open, which caused inconvenience and forced them to seek dining alternatives. For some, this included cooking their own meals or scrambling to find nearby restaurants. The limited hours and sporadic closures often caught guests by surprise, leaving them without on-site food and drink options.
Though some reviews cited the food as very good and convenient, others noted that the cost did not always align with the ambiance or quality with some diners describing their experiences as overpriced. Critiques also pointed out that portions could be small, service slow and the breakfast offerings poor. Despite these points of criticism, when operational, the restaurant was generally seen as a valuable amenity that contributed positively to the overall guest experience at Montauk Manor.
Montauk Manor's rooms generally receive high praise from guests for their cleanliness, comfort and elegant décor. Many reviewers highlight the spaciousness and well-appointed features of the rooms with numerous mentions of comfortable furnishings and full kitchens being particularly appreciated. The views, especially those overlooking the sea or the sound, are frequently noted as magnificent, adding to the overall appeal of the accommodation.
Several guests mention that their rooms felt like small apartments rather than standard hotel rooms, offering ample space and sometimes multiple bathrooms, making them suitable for families. The décor is often described as beautiful and tastefully done, although a few guests found it to be over-decorated or a mix of different styles. Despite some rooms being described as dated or in need of renovation, the majority of reviews emphasize that the rooms are impeccably maintained, clean and luxurious.
The manor itself is often described as beautiful and elegant with well-kept grounds and facilities such as a pool and shuttle service to town. There are occasional mentions of outdated furniture and minor maintenance issues like cracked tiles or old bedding, but these are contrasted by positive remarks about recently renovated and modern rooms.
Overall, Montauk Manor offers a comfortable and picturesque stay with plenty of space and amenities, making it a popular choice for those visiting the area. The friendly staff and exceptional views further enhance the guest experience.
Guest reviews of Montauk Manor reveal mixed feelings about the quality of the beds. While a number of guests found the beds super comfortable or particularly comfortable, others reported issues such as firmness, outdated mattresses and even malfunctioning sofa beds. Several mentioned that specific rooms, like room 109, had beds that were worn out and in dire need of replacement.
Some guests appreciated the cleanliness of the blankets and the overall comfort of the beds, while others found the pillows flimsy and the mattress too hard. The pullout couches garnered both positive reviews for comfort and criticisms for their condition. A recurring point was the need for updated mattresses and bedroom furniture.
In summary, Montauk Manor appears to offer generally comfortable and clean beds, but consistency in quality and updates to older mattresses are areas that could use improvement.
Montauk Manor receives a lot of praise for its cleanliness with many guests highlighting the spotless condition of their rooms. The housekeeping staff is often mentioned as great, accommodating and ensuring that everything remains fresh and well-maintained. Many reviews describe the property as very clean, immaculate and well-kept with indoor spaces noted for their bright and inviting ambiance. Visitors appreciate the clean and comfortable rooms, noting that even sheets smell really good. The well-maintained surroundings and beautiful grounds also add to the positive experience.
However, a few reviews point out issues with dust, inconsistent room cleaning and outdated decor. Some guests noticed mold in the bathroom, dirty carpets and worn furniture. There were isolated complaints about ants and housekeeping service not meeting expectations, emphasizing the importance of addressing these concerns.
Overall, Montauk Manor impresses with its high standards of cleanliness, complemented by its beautiful setting, clean rooms and friendly housekeeping staff. Despite some minor issues, the property provides a welcoming and comfortable environment for its guests.
Situated in a charming and picturesque location, Montauk Manor is widely praised for its clean environment and well-maintained amenities. The reviews highlight the exceptional friendliness of the staff, noting their helpfulness and accommodating nature. This genuine warmth extends across various roles, from the front desk to housekeeping, giving guests a truly welcoming experience.
Despite these positive aspects, there are instances where service fell short, including reports of unprofessionalism and unwelcoming attitudes, particularly from some front desk personnel and restaurant staff. However, these negative experiences appear to be exceptions rather than the rule.
Overall, Montauk Manor's staff generally receive high marks for their attentiveness and quick responses, contributing significantly to the positive guest experience. With friendly and helpful front desk representatives, efficient housekeeping and considerate service, many guests have enjoyed their stays. Specific mentions of the staff going above and beyond, like shuttle drivers and front desk personnel, add to the hotel's appeal.
In summary, Montauk Manor's staff largely enhance the quality of guests' stays through their friendliness and professionalism, although there is room for improvement in consistency across all interactions.
Montauk Manor offers free Wi-Fi to its guests, which is a highly appreciated amenity. Some guests found the Wi-Fi to be very good or even excellent, particularly when accessing it in the reception area. However, quite a few guests experienced difficulties with the Wi-Fi in their rooms. Reports included unreliable connections, weak signals and sometimes no internet service at all. These issues occasionally made the Wi-Fi inoperable or caused problems when trying to connect. While the hotel provides LED TVs in the rooms and great accommodation features, it's clear that the Wi-Fi service could benefit from improvements to ensure consistent and reliable internet access throughout the property.
Montauk Manor’s spa has received a mix of feedback from guests. Positively, those who experienced the spa services found them to be great and the hot tub was particularly noted for its relaxing ambiance. The pools were also well-maintained, contributing to a pleasant and clean environment. However, several guests were disappointed with the unavailability of the indoor pool and spa, as these facilities were frequently closed during their stays. The inconsistency in the operation of the spa left some visitors without access to these amenities, suggesting a need for improved availability and clearer communication about the spa’s hours of operation.
Visitors have noted certain issues regarding the gym facilities at Montauk Manor. The gym was frequently cited as closed or unavailable with some guests highlighting that it was advertised but not accessible during their stay. There were also remarks about the gym being too small and a suggestion that its operational hours should be extended. Furthermore, there were comments on the need for improvements in the gym and mentions of the indoor pool and fitness center also being closed at times. Overall, guests generally felt that the gym facilities were not up to expectations during their visits.
Montauk Manor boasts an inviting pool area that guests find particularly appealing. The outdoor pool, often described as warm, clean and well-maintained, provides a delightful respite for visitors. The pool area is large and scenic, offering plenty of umbrellas and private spaces, making it a preferred spot for relaxation. Many appreciate that the pool is heated to a comfortable 85 degrees, creating a cozy atmosphere akin to a warm bath. Families and couples alike enjoy the spacious surroundings, which include beautiful grounds and impressive views.
However, there have been some notable disappointments. The indoor pool and jacuzzi have often been closed for renovations, impacting guests who were looking forward to these amenities. This has led to some confusion and frustration among visitors. Additionally, the timing of pool closures has been inconvenient for some, who wished the pool opened earlier or stayed open later into the evening.
Despite these setbacks, the outdoor pool remains a highlight of Montauk Manor, delivering a great experience when available and contributing positively to the overall stay at the hotel.
The tennis facilities at Montauk Manor receive generally favorable remarks from guests. While there were mentions of the tennis courts being closed at times, many visitors highlight the courts positively, stating that tennis was good and even great. Additionally, the courts were noted to be well-equipped with benches and water. Overall, these amenities, along with the pool and helpful attendants, contribute to an enjoyable stay. However, it's worth noting that the availability of the courts can vary, affecting the experience for some guests.
Montauk Manor has been a cherished destination for family vacations, boasting a range of activities that make it ideal for children and parents alike. It's a place where many families return year after year, creating lasting memories during special occasions and holiday weekends. The hotel is widely described as family-friendly with guests highlighting its suitability for children and its overall family-oriented atmosphere.
Visitors appreciate the comfortable, bright rooms and the availability of family suites, which accommodate the needs of both parents and kids. Families with young children particularly value the provisions like cribs and children's menus, ensuring a hassle-free stay. The on-site playground offers a dedicated space for children to play, adding to the Manor's appeal for younger guests.
Reviews frequently mention the attentive, family-oriented staff who contribute to the pleasant experience. Despite occasional concerns about the upkeep of outdoor areas, most families have a wonderful time. Overall, Montauk Manor is celebrated as an excellent place to relax, reset and spend quality time together, making it a top choice for those seeking a family-friendly getaway.
Montauk Manor boasts what many guests describe as five-star accommodations with exceptional service and food. The property is praised as fabulous and immaculate, standing out as a wonderful and stunning place to stay. Reviewers frequently use terms like exceptional, superb and phenomenal to describe their experiences and consistently mention the manor as their favorite place to stay. The hotel is said to be fantastic for both families and couples with amazing views that contribute to its luxurious atmosphere.
However, some guests found the stay to be below their five-star expectations, noting issues such as a lack of activities in Montauk, inadequacies in housekeeping and a general perception that the hotel's standards fell short of true five-star status. Despite these comments, the majority sentiment highlights the hotel as an outstanding, excellent and beyond expectations location for a memorable stay.
Montauk Manor offers an array of fireplace-equipped rooms that guests found cozy and inviting. The fireplaces added a nice touch to the beautiful suites, enhancing the overall ambiance. Many guests appreciated the cozy and relaxing atmosphere that the room fireplaces created and the electric fireplaces in particular were noted as great features. There were also mentions of fireplaces in the loft and lobby areas, providing additional cozy spots for relaxation. However, there were a few concerns, such as the fireplaces running out of gas, making noises through thin walls and not being operational at times. Despite these issues, the fireplaces largely contributed to a memorable and enjoyable stay with great views of the sunset adding to the charm.
Montauk Manor offers a range of facilities and services tailored to business travelers. The hotel features a business center, though it could benefit from some improvements. Despite this, the overall business-friendly environment is positively noted by guests. Wifi is available in rooms, making it convenient for work purposes. An added advantage for business travelers is the complimentary shuttle service, which is highlighted as a very nice and unexpected touch. While some guests would have appreciated more business-friendly options in the room, Montauk Manor generally provides a useful and accommodating experience for those on business trips.
Montauk Manor boasts various heated pool options, ensuring a comfortable swim throughout the year. The indoor pool is heated, offering a cozy retreat especially during the winter months. Guests have found the outdoor pool to be adequately heated as well, describing it as warm and pleasant. Some enthusiasts even likened the temperature to that of a warm bathtub, enhancing their overall experience. The added touch of pools being salted furthers the appeal, contributing to the hotel's well-maintained facilities. On colder days, the availability of individual heaters adds to guests' comfort, underscoring the thoughtful amenities provided by the hotel.
The outdoor pool at Montauk Manor receives mixed feedback, but highlights reveal a largely positive experience. Many guests appreciated the outdoor pool, describing it as large, clean and well-maintained. The heated feature was particularly noted with some enjoying its warmth and the pool area overall was found to be very relaxing and a great place to unwind after a busy day. However, there were mentions of the pool being closed at times or undergoing renovations, which detracted from some stays. Guests also pointed out that the pool doesn't open early enough in the morning to satisfy everyone’s schedules. Despite these issues, the heated pool remains a nice touch, especially during colder seasons and adds a valuable aspect to the guest experience at Montauk Manor.
Montauk Manor offers an exceptionally luxurious experience, drawing praise for its elegant stay and high-end, well-kept resort ambiance. Guests frequently highlight the beautiful, spacious rooms and their luxurious comfort, complemented by stunning architecture and beautifully decorated interiors. The property itself is described as a gorgeous, classy place to stay with beautifully maintained grounds and a luxurious spa that promises relaxation.
This lavish setting features elegant interiors and a hotel lobby noted for its luxurious decor, creating an overall elegant and luxurious atmosphere. The accommodations are described as perfect with separate heating and well-maintained spaces contributing to a lovely experience. Guests appreciate the hotel's rich history and the centrally located spot, making it a great place to explore the surrounding area.
The resort boasts gorgeous views, especially of the water, enhancing the already perfect accommodations. Whether for a serene getaway or a lavish retreat, Montauk Manor promises a beautiful and unforgettable stay.
Montauk Manor offers a truly romantic experience that seems perfect for couples looking for a memorable getaway. The hotel features romantically decorated rooms and stunning grounds reminiscent of The Great Gatsby era, creating an enchanting atmosphere for guests. The setting itself is described as both beautiful and historical, adding a unique charm that enhances any visit.
Many guests have chosen Montauk Manor for special occasions, such as anniversaries and off-season Valentine’s getaways, noting the romantic views and the overall quiet, serene environment. The presence of a piano player and a romantic spa further contribute to the intimate and relaxing ambiance.
Overall, it's highly recommended for couples seeking a grand romantic spot to spend their evenings, relishing in the picturesque and romantic surroundings.
Location Show Map
Location
Breakfast
However, there were several critiques regarding the limited availability of breakfast. The restaurant is typically closed on weekdays, resulting in no breakfast or coffee options onsite during those days. This was disappointing for many visitors who wished for a full-week breakfast service. The off-season menu offered a more limited selection, often just breakfast sandwiches and some guests noted availability issues, like running out of breakfast potatoes.
Vegetarian options were noted as lacking and some guests desired better meal pricing and more variety. Despite the fluctuations in service availability, weekend breakfasts were generally well-received when available.
Dinner
However, the restaurant's operating hours have been a point of contention. Guests frequently encountered closures, even on nights they expected the restaurant to be open, which caused inconvenience and forced them to seek dining alternatives. For some, this included cooking their own meals or scrambling to find nearby restaurants. The limited hours and sporadic closures often caught guests by surprise, leaving them without on-site food and drink options.
Though some reviews cited the food as very good and convenient, others noted that the cost did not always align with the ambiance or quality with some diners describing their experiences as overpriced. Critiques also pointed out that portions could be small, service slow and the breakfast offerings poor. Despite these points of criticism, when operational, the restaurant was generally seen as a valuable amenity that contributed positively to the overall guest experience at Montauk Manor.
Rooms
Several guests mention that their rooms felt like small apartments rather than standard hotel rooms, offering ample space and sometimes multiple bathrooms, making them suitable for families. The décor is often described as beautiful and tastefully done, although a few guests found it to be over-decorated or a mix of different styles. Despite some rooms being described as dated or in need of renovation, the majority of reviews emphasize that the rooms are impeccably maintained, clean and luxurious.
The manor itself is often described as beautiful and elegant with well-kept grounds and facilities such as a pool and shuttle service to town. There are occasional mentions of outdated furniture and minor maintenance issues like cracked tiles or old bedding, but these are contrasted by positive remarks about recently renovated and modern rooms.
Overall, Montauk Manor offers a comfortable and picturesque stay with plenty of space and amenities, making it a popular choice for those visiting the area. The friendly staff and exceptional views further enhance the guest experience.
Beds
Some guests appreciated the cleanliness of the blankets and the overall comfort of the beds, while others found the pillows flimsy and the mattress too hard. The pullout couches garnered both positive reviews for comfort and criticisms for their condition. A recurring point was the need for updated mattresses and bedroom furniture.
In summary, Montauk Manor appears to offer generally comfortable and clean beds, but consistency in quality and updates to older mattresses are areas that could use improvement.
Cleanliness
However, a few reviews point out issues with dust, inconsistent room cleaning and outdated decor. Some guests noticed mold in the bathroom, dirty carpets and worn furniture. There were isolated complaints about ants and housekeeping service not meeting expectations, emphasizing the importance of addressing these concerns.
Overall, Montauk Manor impresses with its high standards of cleanliness, complemented by its beautiful setting, clean rooms and friendly housekeeping staff. Despite some minor issues, the property provides a welcoming and comfortable environment for its guests.
Staff
Despite these positive aspects, there are instances where service fell short, including reports of unprofessionalism and unwelcoming attitudes, particularly from some front desk personnel and restaurant staff. However, these negative experiences appear to be exceptions rather than the rule.
Overall, Montauk Manor's staff generally receive high marks for their attentiveness and quick responses, contributing significantly to the positive guest experience. With friendly and helpful front desk representatives, efficient housekeeping and considerate service, many guests have enjoyed their stays. Specific mentions of the staff going above and beyond, like shuttle drivers and front desk personnel, add to the hotel's appeal.
In summary, Montauk Manor's staff largely enhance the quality of guests' stays through their friendliness and professionalism, although there is room for improvement in consistency across all interactions.
Wi-Fi
Spa
Gym
Pool
However, there have been some notable disappointments. The indoor pool and jacuzzi have often been closed for renovations, impacting guests who were looking forward to these amenities. This has led to some confusion and frustration among visitors. Additionally, the timing of pool closures has been inconvenient for some, who wished the pool opened earlier or stayed open later into the evening.
Despite these setbacks, the outdoor pool remains a highlight of Montauk Manor, delivering a great experience when available and contributing positively to the overall stay at the hotel.
Tennis
Family
Visitors appreciate the comfortable, bright rooms and the availability of family suites, which accommodate the needs of both parents and kids. Families with young children particularly value the provisions like cribs and children's menus, ensuring a hassle-free stay. The on-site playground offers a dedicated space for children to play, adding to the Manor's appeal for younger guests.
Reviews frequently mention the attentive, family-oriented staff who contribute to the pleasant experience. Despite occasional concerns about the upkeep of outdoor areas, most families have a wonderful time. Overall, Montauk Manor is celebrated as an excellent place to relax, reset and spend quality time together, making it a top choice for those seeking a family-friendly getaway.
5 Star
However, some guests found the stay to be below their five-star expectations, noting issues such as a lack of activities in Montauk, inadequacies in housekeeping and a general perception that the hotel's standards fell short of true five-star status. Despite these comments, the majority sentiment highlights the hotel as an outstanding, excellent and beyond expectations location for a memorable stay.
Rooms with Fireplace
Business
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Luxury
This lavish setting features elegant interiors and a hotel lobby noted for its luxurious decor, creating an overall elegant and luxurious atmosphere. The accommodations are described as perfect with separate heating and well-maintained spaces contributing to a lovely experience. Guests appreciate the hotel's rich history and the centrally located spot, making it a great place to explore the surrounding area.
The resort boasts gorgeous views, especially of the water, enhancing the already perfect accommodations. Whether for a serene getaway or a lavish retreat, Montauk Manor promises a beautiful and unforgettable stay.
Romantic
Many guests have chosen Montauk Manor for special occasions, such as anniversaries and off-season Valentine’s getaways, noting the romantic views and the overall quiet, serene environment. The presence of a piano player and a romantic spa further contribute to the intimate and relaxing ambiance.
Overall, it's highly recommended for couples seeking a grand romantic spot to spend their evenings, relishing in the picturesque and romantic surroundings.
Yes, Montauk Manor has pool(s) that belong to one or more of the following categories: Heated Pool, Outdoor Pool.
Yes, a spa is available at Montauk Manor.
No, Montauk Manor doesn't allow dogs.
No, parking facilities aren't available at Montauk Manor.
Yes, Montauk Manor has a gym.
Location Show Map
More Options
