Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Small Hotels in New Buffalo

47 HOTELS IN AND AROUND NEW BUFFALORanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
stayAPT Suites Harrisburg-Hershey main photo
stayAPT Suites Harrisburg-Hershey
18.0 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Harrisburg PAUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Dog Friendly
Carriage Stop Bed & Breakfast main photo
Carriage Stop Bed & Breakfast
18.3 mi from New Buffalo
Bed & Breakfast in Palmyra PAUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $170
$
+6
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
The Marshall House B & B main photo
The Marshall House B & B
18.5 mi from New Buffalo
Bed & Breakfast in Palmyra PAUS flag
9.8
Excellent
From $62
$
+3
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
SpringHill Suites by Marriott Camp Hill main photo
SpringHill Suites by Marriott Camp Hill
18.6 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Camp Hill PAUS flag
9.0
Excellent
$
+9
Info
Categories
Small
Business
Parking
EV charging stations
Red Roof Inn Harrisburg - Hershey main photo
Red Roof Inn Harrisburg - Hershey
19.0 mi from New Buffalo
Motel in Harrisburg PAUS flag
4.5
Rated
From $67
$
+2
Small
Red Roof Inn Harrisburg - Hershey offers a simple and cozy stay. Its smaller size and personalized service contribute to a more intimate experience.
Cumberland Inn By OYO New Cumberland-Hershey South main photo
Cumberland Inn By OYO New Cumberland-Hershey South
19.7 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in New Cumberland PAUS flag
4.7
Rated
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Highland Inn New Cumberland main photo
Highland Inn New Cumberland
20.3 mi from New Buffalo
Motel in New Cumberland PAUS flag
8.2
Very Good
From $58
$
+3
Info
Summary of reviews
Highland Inn New Cumberland offers a well-rounded and positive experience for travelers seeking convenience, comfort, and affordability. Positioned near major highways such as Interstate 15 and I-83, the hotel's location is ideal for exploring Harrisburg and nearby attractions, while still providing a quiet and serene environment for a restful stay. Despite some background noise from the highway, guests appreciate the peaceful ambiance and value the good balance of cost and convenience.

The inn's rooms are frequently praised for their comfort and cleanliness. Large and inviting, the accommodations feature cozy beds and essential amenities like new TVs, coffee makers, and refrigerators. Although the decor reflects an older style, it is complemented by modern conveniences. Guests often find the cleanliness to exceed expectations and appreciate the smoke-free environment and thoughtful touches such as bottled water upon arrival.

The staff at Highland Inn stands out for their friendliness and attentiveness, with many guests recounting warm welcomes and helpful assistance. Abby, a staff member, is particularly noted for her hospitality and insightful recommendations about the local area, enhancing the guest experience.

While a few minor issues such as occasional room odor, outdated furniture, and isolated reports of bed bugs and worn towels have been mentioned, these are overshadowed by the overall positive reviews. The beds are often highlighted for their comfort, contributing to restful nights and a pleasant overall experience.

Overall,
Highland Inn New Cumberland is a solid choice for those seeking a clean, comfortable, and budget-friendly accommodation solution, with its standout features being the convenient location, attentive staff, and cozy accommodations.
Categories
Small
Ski
Parking
Travelodge by Wyndham Carlisle North main photo
Travelodge by Wyndham Carlisle North
20.3 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Carlisle PAUS flag
5.2
Rated
$
+4
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Accessible
Hollywood Motel main photo
Hollywood Motel
20.6 mi from New Buffalo
Motel in Middletown PAUS flag
6.2
Rated
$
+3
Info
Categories
Small
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Red Roof Inn Carlisle main photo
Red Roof Inn Carlisle
20.6 mi from New Buffalo
Motel in Carlisle PAUS flag
6.9
Rated
From $92
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Dogs Stay Free
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Spark By Hilton Hummelstown Hershey main photo
Spark By Hilton Hummelstown Hershey
20.6 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Hershey PAUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $120
$
+4
Info
Summary of reviews
Spark By Hilton Hummelstown Hershey enjoys a highly favorable location, praised for its proximity to Hershey Park and other local attractions. Visitors appreciate its convenience for not just leisure activities but also for needs such as nearby hospitals, making it a strategically advantageous choice. The added perks of cleanliness, friendly staff and included breakfast options contribute significantly to a pleasant stay.

Guests often highlight the breakfast, describing it as good, excellent and plentiful, especially appreciating its inclusion with the room. The breakfast buffet often exceeds expectations for many, although there are calls for more variety and fresher options with specific notes on the lack of protein and hot breakfast choices.

The rooms receive mixed feedback. Many commend the cleanliness and comfort with special mentions for spacious suites and comfortable beds. However, some guests point out that the rooms appear outdated and in need of renovation with certain issues such as low water pressure, inconsistent housekeeping and inadequate facilities.

Cleanliness is generally rated highly with frequent praises for clean and tidy rooms and a secure, quiet environment. Nonetheless, there are sporadic mentions of specific cleanliness issues in some reviews, which detract from the overall experience.

The staff at
Spark By Hilton Hummelstown Hershey consistently earn high marks for their friendliness, helpfulness and efficient service. Early check-ins and readiness to assist enhance the positive impression guests have of the hotel, making staff interactions a standout aspect of many stays.

The pool, while offering a delightful experience when fully functional, receives mixed reviews. Guests appreciate its unique features and attractiveness, especially for kids. However, maintenance issues such as cleanliness, occasional closures and cold temperatures have been a source of disappointment.

Families find the hotel an excellent base for visiting Hershey Park with the pool and pet-friendly amenities being highlights. The overall feedback suggests that most families enjoy a comfortable and fun experience with the hotel being a repeat choice for many.

The comfort of the beds is broadly praised, contributing positively to guests' experiences, although a few mention occasional discomfort and unusual smells.

In summary,
Spark By Hilton Hummelstown Hershey is recognized for its exceptional location, friendly staff and comfort, though some areas, particularly the rooms and pool maintenance, have room for improvement. The hotel remains a popular choice, especially among families and those visiting Hershey Park.
Categories
Small
Golf
Family
The Suites at Hershey No Resort Fee 2 Bdr main photo
The Suites at Hershey No Resort Fee 2 Bdr
20.7 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Hershey PAUS flag
0.0
$
+10
Info
Categories
Small
Honeymoon
Pool
Indoor Pool
Outdoor Pool
Days Inn Hershey main photo
Days Inn Hershey
20.9 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Hershey PAUS flag
1.0
Rated
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Pool
Parking
Selinsgrove Inn main photo
Selinsgrove Inn
21.6 mi from New Buffalo
Inn in Selinsgrove PAUS flag
9.6
Excellent
From $161
$
+4
Info
Categories
Small
Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub
Parking
Budget Inn Carlisle main photo
Budget Inn Carlisle
22.0 mi from New Buffalo
Motel in Carlisle PAUS flag
4.5
Rated
From $60
$
+2
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Stocks Manor Bed and Breakfast main photo
Stocks Manor Bed and Breakfast
22.2 mi from New Buffalo
Bed & Breakfast in Mechanicsburg PAUS flag
0.0
$
+2
Info
Categories
Small
Parking
Pheasant Field Bed and Breakfast main photo
Pheasant Field Bed and Breakfast
22.3 mi from New Buffalo
Bed & Breakfast in Carlisle PAUS flag
9.7
Excellent
From $195
$
+5
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Parking
EV charging stations
1825 Inn Bed and Breakfast main photo
1825 Inn Bed and Breakfast
22.4 mi from New Buffalo
Bed & Breakfast in Palmyra PAUS flag
9.9
Excellent
From $221
$
+3
Info
Categories
Small
3 Star
Rooms with Fireplace
Scottish Inns - Middletown main photo
Scottish Inns - Middletown
23.9 mi from New Buffalo
Hotel in Middletown PAUS flag
6.5
Rated
$
+1
Small
Scottish Inns in Middletown offers a simple and cozy stay. Its smaller size and personalized service contribute to a more intimate experience.
Entire rear squad-bay main photo
Entire rear squad-bay
24.0 mi from New Buffalo
Guest House in Carlisle PAUS flag
7.0
Good
$
+3
Info
Categories
Small
Dog Friendly
Parking
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 21-40 out of 47 hotels in and around New Buffalo
  • «
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • »
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities