Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

4-Star Hotels in South Yorkshire

39 HOTELS IN SOUTH YORKSHIRERanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
Whitley Hall Hotel main photo
Whitley Hall Hotel
Hotel in ChapeltownGB flag
8.5
Very Good
From $106
$
+3
4 Star
Whitley Hall Hotel is set in a historic building with beautiful grounds, offering a unique and charming stay. The hotel features comfortable rooms and a peaceful atmosphere.
Mercure Sheffield St Paul's Hotel & Spa main photo
From $84
$
+2
4 Star
This hotel is centrally located in Sheffield city centre, providing easy access to transport links and attractions. It offers modern bedrooms, including classic, privilege rooms and a junior suite with views over Sheffield, and features a spa.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Mercure Sheffield St Paul's Hotel & Spa is a lovely hotel in Sheffield, perfect for a few nights stay. While there were a few issues that needed addressing, guests overall had a lovely stay at this four-star hotel. The excellent location and nice facilities made for a good stay with many guests describing it as superb and exceptional. However, some guests found the price to be a little high for what is expected of a four-star hotel. While the hotel was good for most guests, some felt it didn't quite meet the standard of other rival 4-star hotels with the pool and sauna areas in particular needing some attention. Nevertheless, many guests appreciated the hotel's central location and found their rooms to be comfortable and clean. Overall, Mercure Sheffield St Paul's Hotel & Spa received positive feedback and was a good choice for those looking for a central location in Sheffield.
DoubleTree by Hilton Sheffield Park main photo
From $91
$
+4
4 Star
This hotel provides a relaxing environment with excellent facilities and services. The location is ideal for those seeking a quieter stay while still being close to Sheffield's attractions.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The DoubleTree by Hilton Sheffield Park is a hotel that seems to divide opinions among its guests. While some of them were impressed and declared it "very good" or "really nice," others couldn't help but feel disappointed. Several guests felt that the hotel did not live up to its 4-star rating with one even saying "4 stars hotel? no way." The food, in particular, was singled out with some guests saying that the selection was underwhelming or didn't meet their expectations. Many guests felt that the hotel needed a revamp with comments about it "looking a bit tired" and needing repainting. That being said, some guests had an okay experience and felt that the hotel was acceptable but not exceptional. If you're looking for a hotel of this calibre and don't mind if it's slightly dated, then the DoubleTree might work for you.
Best Western Premier Doncaster Mount Pleasant Hotel main photo
From $160
$
4 Star
This hotel is a delightful Georgian country house, it offers an AA-Rosette awarded restaurant, an indulgent spa and rooms with four-poster beds and jacuzzi baths. All of which is located in stunning parkland.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Best Western Premier Doncaster Mount Pleasant Hotel is an excellent choice for visitors to the area with superb facilities and services making for a very comfortable stay. Although some guests note that the food isn't the greatest for a 4-star hotel and it can be a little bit expensive, overall this hotel impresses with its country charm and well-run atmosphere. Those looking for a high-quality experience will find 4-star excellence at its best here and many guests would happily return for another pleasant stay.
Leopold Hotel main photo
Leopold Hotel
Hotel in SheffieldGB flag
8.4
Very Good
From $92
$
+3
4 Star
This unique hotel is situated in the heart of Sheffield's city centre, surrounded by shops, restaurants, and bars. Housed in a building dating back to 1800, it offers stylish, air-conditioned rooms and a lounge bar.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Leopold Hotel is a superb four-star hotel located in a lovely location that guests absolutely love. The hotel has top-notch facilities and services that have been given high ratings by guests. Reviews show that the hotel offers fantastic amenities and visitors can attest to its incredible value for money. Overall, Leopold Hotel receives great reviews from happy guests who highly recommend it.
Hellaby Hall Hotel, BW Signature Collection main photo
From $93
$
+2
4 Star
This hotel has an indoor pool, sauna, and steam room. It is a relaxing and well-equipped stay.
Earl Of Doncaster Hotel main photo
From $118
$
4 Star
This iconic Art Deco hotel, established in 1938, is located near Doncaster's town center and racecourse. It offers stylish accommodations, a restaurant, bars, and event spaces, making it suitable for both business and leisure travelers. The hotel's ballroom features a stage, dance floor, and private bar.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Earl Of Doncaster Hotel consistently delivers high standards and overall four-star quality, particularly evident in its bedrooms and service. Guests repeatedly commend the exceptional service, praising the lovely receptionist and overall good service for a four-star property. The hotel is noted for its excellent value and great pricing for the quality received. Furthermore, the beautiful ambiance and fabulous experiences enhance the appeal for visitors. However, some aspects, such as the lack of complimentary water and breakfast not being included, were noted as missing for a four-star establishment. Minor details, like the scrappy looking telephone at the reception desk, were also mentioned. Despite these points, the hotel remains a solid choice with a good location and generally better-than-most four-star quality for the price.
Doubletree By Hilton Sheffield City main photo
$
+3
4 Star
This hotel provides a comfortable stay with excellent service. It's well-situated for accessing city attractions and offers a range of amenities for a pleasant experience.
Mercure Sheffield Kenwood Hall & Spa main photo
From $84
$
+2
4 Star
Located in a serene setting, this hotel offers comfortable accommodations and a spa for relaxation. Its facilities cater to both leisure and business travelers, ensuring a pleasant stay.
Crowne Plaza Royal Victoria - Sheffield by IHG main photo
From $93
$
+5
4 Star
The Crowne Plaza offers a luxurious experience with high-quality amenities and services. Its location provides easy access to key areas, making it ideal for both leisure and business travelers.
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse main photo
From $94
$
+2
4 Star
This hotel is perfectly situated for racegoers, near Lakeside Village shopping, and other attractions. It offers a restaurant, fitness center, business center, and versatile function space. The Garden Grille restaurant and bar is open for breakfast, lunch, and evening meals daily.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse provides a modern and clean environment, consistently praised for its spotlessly maintained rooms and excellent facilities. Guests frequently highlight the hotel as offering exceptional value and convenience, noting that it is reasonably priced for a four-star property. The rooms are modern, beautifully finished and the hotel maintains a high standard of cleanliness throughout.

While the hotel is lauded as a genuine four-star experience by many, some guests have pointed out that it lacks certain complementary amenities typically found in hotels of similar rating, such as shower caps and bars of soap. Despite this, the overall experience is described as positive with friendly and helpful staff enhancing the stay.

There have been isolated comments about room assignments not meeting specific requests, such as being given a disabled room without needing one. However, the hotel's modern appeal and overall maintenance seem to outweigh these minor issues for most visitors.

In terms of service, the clean toilets and food offerings add to the positive experience, making
Hilton Garden Inn Doncaster Racecourse a strong contender for those seeking a four-star experience at a reasonable price.
Sandman Signature Sheffield Quays Hotel main photo
From $87
$
+4
4 Star
This hotel stands out with its excellent service and comfortable accommodations. Guests appreciate the convenient location and the overall quality of the hotel.
Mercure Barnsley Tankersley Manor Hotel main photo
From $100
$
+5
4 Star
This hotel offers a mix of historic charm and modern amenities. It provides a comfortable and well-equipped experience.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Mercure Barnsley Tankersley Manor Hotel is a lovely property in beautiful surroundings, offering facilities like a great spa, comfortable rooms with everything you need provided and exceptional cleanliness. Although some guests found the hotel disappointing for a 4-star rating with poor service and old, wobbly beds, overall it was considered an average hotel with very good aspects. The hotel is just the right size, not too busy or crowded, making it a pleasant place to stay. The food and drinks served were good and the hotel offers great facilities overall.
Leonardo Hotel Sheffield main photo
From $78
$
4 Star
Centrally located, this hotel offers convenient amenities and comfortable guestrooms featuring flat-screen televisions. Guests can enjoy meals at the restaurant or snacks in the coffee shop/cafe, as well as relax at the bar/lounge.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Leonardo Hotel Sheffield garners a blend of positive and mixed reviews regarding its four-star rating, facilities and services. Guests frequently highlight the hotel’s perfect location, offering easy access to Sheffield City Centre, the train station and main shopping areas, making it a very convenient choice for travelers. The hotel's cleanliness stands out with many guests noting spotlessly clean rooms and excellent overall standards of cleanliness.

The decor has been described as modern and contemporary, providing a visually pleasing and comfortable environment. Guests appreciated the comfy beds, making for a restful stay. The bar and room facilities were also well-received, being acknowledged as lovely, especially for the price. Many guests considered the hotel to provide great value for money and highlighted it as a financially efficient option.

However, there are a few contrasting opinions. Some guests did not find the hotel's offerings entirely reflective of a four-star standard, pointing to outdated rooms and poor breakfast options. The absence of room service also drew some criticism and a few felt the pricing was high for the level of service and amenities provided.

Despite these mixed sentiments, numerous travelers expressed contentment with their stay, noting that the hotel meets the expectations of a four-star establishment and offers a pleasant overall experience. The majority of reviews suggest that while there might be room for improvements, the
Leonardo Hotel Sheffield still stands as a solid choice for both leisure and business travelers with high standards of cleanliness and comfort at its core.
Holiday Inn Rotherham-Sheffield M1,Jct.33 by IHG main photo
From $81
$
+5
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Holiday Inn Rotherham-Sheffield M1,Jct.33 by IHG has recently received mixed reviews regarding its four star rating. While some guests feel that it falls a bit short and could use some updating, others have thoroughly enjoyed their stay and found it to be a great value for money. Despite rumors of it only being a three star hotel, many guests have found it to be lovely and superb, praising the facilities and services offered. Those who were passing through and needed a quick stay have found it to be a great choice for the price. Ultimately, the reviews are average and indicate that the hotel is neither good nor bad, but comfortable enough to spend a weekend at.
The Manor House Hotel main photo
The Manor House Hotel
Hotel in DronfieldGB flag
8.0
Very Good
From $102
$
+2
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
The Manor House Hotel is a charming and quaint four-star hotel located in a lovely area in Dronfield. It offers exceptional value for money, making it a great choice for those looking for a relaxing and pleasant stay. The hotel is highly recommended with guests praising its superb facilities and services. The staff are great and the breakfast is excellent. Although there are some minor issues with the rooms that need attention, such as cleanliness and new toilet seats, the hotel is overall comfy and characterful with a good location for touring. The beds, unfortunately, are not very comfy for everyone and some guests reported noise at night, but this is understandable with the location. Despite these issues, the hotel offers a remarkable value for money and it exceeded the expectations of many guests who booked last minute. The hotel is perfect for adults-only and offers lovely quirky rooms like the Hepburn Suite.
The Crown Hotel Bawtry-Doncaster main photo
From $121
$
+3
Info
Summary of reviews
The Crown Hotel Bawtry-Doncaster is a well-situated establishment set in the charming market town of Bawtry, offering easy access to a variety of local shops, pubs and restaurants. Guests consistently highlight the hotel's central location and the convenience of nearby amenities, making it an attractive choice for visitors attending events, weddings or those simply exploring the area. Additionally, the hotel's proximity to Doncaster Airport further enhances its appeal.

Dining at
The Crown Hotel Bawtry-Doncaster receives significant praise, particularly for its restaurant ambiance and the quality of food served during dinner. Guests commend the delicious and well-presented meals, as well as the attentive and friendly service. The breakfast receives mixed reviews; while many appreciate the high quality and variety of offerings, others find it overpriced and note occasional issues such as cold food and crowded dining spaces.

The hotel rooms present a mixed picture. Positive comments highlight large, comfortable and clean accommodations, though many guests point to the need for refurbishment. Complaints about outdated decor, cleanliness issues such as black mold and inadequate temperature control suggest that some rooms fall short of modern standards. Noise disturbances and the need for better ventilation were other points of criticism.

Cleanliness within the hotel varies with some guests finding their rooms spotless and well-maintained, while others note neglected areas, particularly in bathrooms and communal spaces. The mixed feedback suggests inconsistencies in the housekeeping standards.

The staff at
The Crown Hotel Bawtry-Doncaster are frequently praised for their friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism. Their positive attitude and willingness to go above and beyond contribute significantly to guests' overall enjoyment of their stay. Even during busy periods, the team maintains good manners and efficiency, particularly noticeable during breakfast service.

WiFi at the hotel, however, receives mixed reviews. Guests have experienced poor signal strength and connectivity issues, which hinder work and leisure activities. This inconsistency in WiFi service detracts from the overall experience.

Beds at the hotel also receive varied feedback. Many guests find them comfortable and conducive to a restful night's sleep, but others report issues such as lumps, dips and an overall need for mattress replacements.

Overall,
The Crown Hotel Bawtry-Doncaster offers a pleasant stay, bolstered by its prime location, quality dining experiences and commendable staff. However, there is room for improvement in the areas of room updates, cleanliness and WiFi reliability to better meet guests' expectations.
Categories
4 Star
Golf
Business
Holiday Inn Barnsley by IHG main photo
From $81
$
+4
Info
Summary of reviews
Holiday Inn Barnsley by IHG is highly regarded for its strategic location near the M1 motorway, making it convenient for both business and leisure travelers. The hotel's peaceful environment and proximity to local attractions provide a nice balance for guests seeking both tranquility and accessibility. The staff are frequently praised for their friendliness and attentiveness, contributing significantly to a warm and welcoming atmosphere throughout the stay.

Accommodations are appreciated for being spacious and clean, with guests highlighting the comfortable beds and overall room amenities. Although some areas show signs of aging, the hotel's cleanliness and well-maintained facilities stand out positively. The food offerings receive mixed reviews, but the dining experience is generally satisfactory, with the quality of food and attentive service being well-noted features.

Families find the hotel accommodating, with ample room for larger groups and amenities like pet-friendly policies adding to its appeal. Despite not having an on-site pool, access to the Bannatyne Gym and pool next door is a valued addition, enhancing the leisure options for guests. Breakfast is often highlighted as a positive experience with a variety of choices, despite occasional comments on limited options for longer stays.

Business travelers appreciate the hotel’s practical features, including a well-equipped workspace and smooth check-in/out processes. Ample free parking and complimentary access to nearby leisure facilities are added benefits that guests appreciate. Overall,
Holiday Inn Barnsley by IHG offers a comfortable and convenient stay, backed by exceptional service and strategic location, making it a recommendable choice for visitors to the area.
Categories
4 Star
Family
Dog Friendly
Mercure Sheffield Parkway main photo
From $87
$
4 Star
The Mercure Sheffield Parkway provides comfortable and convenient accommodations with easy access to major routes. It's a practical choice for travelers seeking a comfortable stay with good connectivity.
Novotel Sheffield Centre main photo
From $83
$
+4
4 Star
The Novotel is centrally located, offers modern accommodations, and provides easy access to the city's attractions. Guests can enjoy on-site dining and utilize the hotel's amenities for a comfortable stay.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 39 hotels in South Yorkshire
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities