Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

4-Star Hotels in Water Mill

30 HOTELS IN AND AROUND WATER MILLRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Harpoon House main photo
Harpoon House
3.6 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Southampton NYUS flag
7.4
Good
From $327
$
+2
Info
Categories
4 Star
Parking
Small
The 1708 House main photo
The 1708 House
3.6 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Southampton NYUS flag
9.8
Excellent
$
4 Star
This bed and breakfast offers a unique and charming experience. It is known for its cozy atmosphere and personalized service.
Southampton Inn main photo
Southampton Inn
3.9 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Southampton NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $370
$
+2
4 Star
Located in the heart of Southampton, this inn offers a seasonal outdoor pool and is pet-friendly. It provides comfortable accommodations with easy access to local attractions, making it ideal for a relaxing getaway.
Faraway Sag Harbor main photo
Faraway Sag Harbor
5.5 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Sag Harbor NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $421
$
+9
4 Star
This hotel offers waterfront views and provides guests with a blend of comfort and elegance. It is known for its excellent service and prime location.
The Maidstone Hotel main photo
The Maidstone Hotel
8.2 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in East Hampton NYUS flag
8.9
Excellent
$
+2
Info
Categories
4 Star
Small
The Hedges Inn main photo
The Hedges Inn
8.3 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in East Hampton NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $628
$
+4
Info
Categories
4 Star
Historic
Parking
Vine & Sand--Southold NY's Newest B&B main photo
Vine & Sand--Southold NY's Newest B&B
9.7 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Southold NYUS flag
9.4
Excellent
$
+8
Info
Categories
4 Star
Sustainability Journey
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
The Pridwin Hotel main photo
The Pridwin Hotel
9.9 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Shelter Island NYUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $436
$
+6
4 Star
The hotel is known for its beachfront location and offers a relaxing getaway with stunning water views. It features comfortable rooms and a range of amenities for a pleasant stay.
Shelter Island House main photo
Shelter Island House
10.0 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NYUS flag
8.7
Very Good
From $315
$
+6
4 Star
Offering comfortable accommodations and a relaxing atmosphere, this hotel is a great choice for those looking to explore Shelter Island. It is praised for its friendly service and convenient location.
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach main photo
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach
10.0 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island NYUS flag
9.9
Excellent
From $365
$
+10
4 Star
Located in Shelter Island Heights, this inn offers comfortable accommodations and a convenient location near the beach. It is praised for its friendly service and relaxed atmosphere.
Sunset Beach main photo
Sunset Beach
10.1 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Shelter Island NYUS flag
10
Excellent
From $400
$
+2
Info
Categories
4 Star
Boutique-Style
House on Chase Creek main photo
House on Chase Creek
10.6 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island Heights NYUS flag
9.1
Excellent
From $212
$
+5
Info
Categories
4 Star
Luxury
Parking
The Shoals Suites & Slips main photo
The Shoals Suites & Slips
10.6 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Southold NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
$
+4
4 Star
The hotel provides guests with a waterfront experience, offering suites and boat slips. It is recognized for its convenient location and comfortable amenities.
The Chequit main photo
The Chequit
10.7 mi from Water Mill
Inn in Shelter Island Heights NYUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $437
$
+1
4 Star
Located on Shelter Island, this inn offers a blend of historic charm and modern amenities. It is praised for its comfortable rooms and convenient location.
Gansett Green Manor main photo
Gansett Green Manor
11.3 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Amagansett NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $646
$
+11
Info
Categories
4 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows main photo
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
11.6 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Greenport NYUS flag
9.7
Excellent
$
+6
Info
Categories
4 Star
Sustainability Journey
Business
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast main photo
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
11.8 mi from Water Mill
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NYUS flag
9.9
Excellent
From $426
$
+5
Info
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Small
The Menhaden Hotel main photo
The Menhaden Hotel
12.0 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Greenport NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $372
$
+4
4 Star
The hotel offers stylish accommodations and a rooftop terrace with panoramic views. It is praised for its modern design and convenient location in Greenport.
American Beech Hotel main photo
American Beech Hotel
12.2 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Greenport NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
From $349
$
+4
4 Star
Situated in Greenport, this hotel offers stylish accommodations and a unique atmosphere. Guests appreciate its proximity to local attractions and dining options.
Hotel Moraine main photo
Hotel Moraine
12.2 mi from Water Mill
Hotel in Greenport NYUS flag
9.6
Excellent
$
+11
Info
Categories
4 Star
Golf
Parking
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 30 hotels in and around Water Mill
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities