Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

4-Star Hotels with Swimming Pool in Carnegie

120 HOTELS IN AND AROUND CARNEGIERanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Kimberley Gardens Hotel, Serviced Apartments and Serviced Townhouses main photo
Kimberley Gardens Hotel, Serviced Apartments and Serviced Townhouses
3.6 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.5
Very Good
From $101
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Kimberley Gardens Hotel, Serviced Apartments and Serviced Townhouses in Melbourne is a great value for money establishment that provides a comfortable and homely stay for guests. Its convenient and well-connected location, friendly and accommodating staff and clean and spacious rooms with comfortable beds and spa bathrooms were noted as main highlights by guests. The pool and spa, indoor and heated, were noted as relaxing and excellent, although some guests would have liked better temperature control. The parking situation was a bit hit or miss for some guests but overall appreciated, being free and available. This hotel is also suitable for families with plenty of space and well-stocked kitchens, air conditioning in all rooms, playroom and pool. Beds were described as "super comfy" and "extremely comfortable", providing a good night's rest. While some areas may look outdated, the hotel is impeccably clean and comfortable, making it a great choice for anyone wanting a great four-star stay that is affordable and convenient.
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
Family
Best Western Plus Buckingham International main photo
Best Western Plus Buckingham International
4.2 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MoorabbinAU flag
7.9
Good
From $78
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Best Western Plus Buckingham International has garnered an impressive reputation, particularly for its prime location. Guests appreciate its convenient proximity to the Highett train station, major roadways, shopping centers like Southland, cafes and restaurants, making it ideal for both personal and business needs. The quietness despite the nearby Nepean Highway, easy access to Melbourne and closeness to essential services, hospitals and supermarkets further add to its allure.

The hotel's amenities are another highlight with well-maintained rooms and friendly staff frequently mentioned. Guests commend its comfortable and spacious accommodations, modern amenities like pod coffee machines and air conditioning and clean environments. The secure parking facilities and overall safe environment receive high praise.

The breakfast offerings elicit mixed reviews, though many guests enjoyed the well-presented, tasty and good value options available. Service excellence enhances the breakfast experience despite occasional feedback regarding lack of variety and specific meal inconsistencies on weekends.

Dining experiences at the onsite restaurant are mostly positive with guests lauding the high-quality food, excellent service and enjoyable atmosphere. Particular dishes such as steaks and snails receive special mention. However, potential diners should be aware of the restaurant's closure on Mondays and Tuesdays, which has caused inconvenience for some.

Room cleanliness and comfort are strong points with guests often noting the cleanliness, fresh bedding and modern bathrooms. Though some reports of noise from nearby roads or internal areas exist, the overall sentiment is positive with regard to room maintenance and presentation. Minor cleaning discrepancies like dusty carports and occasional maintenance issues are noted but don’t overshadow the general satisfaction.

The staff at
Best Western Plus Buckingham International consistently receive glowing feedback for their friendliness, helpfulness and professional service, significantly enhancing the overall guest experience. Specific mentions of outstanding staff members highlight the team's commitment to excellent hospitality.

While the WiFi experience is mixed with some guests facing connectivity issues, those who had a smooth connection found it satisfactory. Parking facilities receive positive reviews for being plentiful, secure and conveniently located, though the tight spacing for larger vehicles is a minor complaint.

Lastly, the beds at the hotel are widely praised for their comfort, cleanliness and spaciousness. Most guests find them very comfortable, although there are a few critiques regarding bed softness and the quality of pillows.

In summary, the
Best Western Plus Buckingham International excels in location, service, room quality and dining, making it a favored choice for various types of stays. Minor areas for improvement do exist, but the overall guest experience remains highly positive.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
EV charging stations
Hotel Bruce County main photo
Hotel Bruce County
4.5 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Mount WaverleyAU flag
6.5
Rated
From $79
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Overall, Hotel Bruce County offers a great value for the price with clean and comfortable rooms. Its convenient and quiet location was a positive aspect for guests who appreciated its proximity to major highways and nearby dining options. The standout feature of the hotel was its high level of cleanliness in guest rooms with minor maintenance issues promptly addressed by the attentive staff. Speaking of, guests raved about the friendly and helpful staff members, including the accommodating receptionists and hospitable manager. The beds were also a highlight for guests with many remarking on their exceptional comfort and excellent pillows. While some rooms may appear dated, most guests found Hotel Bruce County to be a welcoming and comfortable base for exploring the local area.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
Gateway on Monash main photo
Gateway on Monash
4.5 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Clayton NorthAU flag
7.4
Good
From $79
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Gateway on Monash is a hidden gem located in a convenient area with easy access to hospitals, restaurants and shopping centers. The hotel offers lovely and spacious rooms with spa baths, comfortable furniture and luxurious bed linens, making for a relaxing stay. The staff is friendly, accommodating and known for their excellent service. The hotel boasts a large car parking area that is safe and easy to find. While some rooms may be a bit aged, the overwhelming consensus is that the rooms are very clean and comfortable. The only downside is that room cleaning may not occur until later in the afternoon and replenishment of toiletries may not always occur. Overall, Gateway on Monash is a tidy and cosy hotel with great amenities and a prime location, perfect for a hassle-free getaway.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Boutique-Style
Box Hill Motel main photo
Box Hill Motel
4.7 mi from Carnegie
Motel in BurwoodAU flag
9.1
Excellent
From $83
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Box Hill Motel, strategically located near public transport and Deakin University, is highly praised for its tranquil setting away from city noise. Guests appreciate its proximity to dining options and the serene bushland nearby. The rooms receive consistent accolades for cleanliness, modern amenities, and comfort, providing a restful retreat with contemporary bathrooms and comfortable beds. The motel’s dedication to immaculate conditions extends throughout the property, featuring well-maintained facilities and a quiet atmosphere conducive to relaxation.

Staff at Box Hill Motel stand out for their exceptional professionalism, kindness, and customer service, ensuring a welcoming environment. Guests often mention the friendly and accommodating nature of the team, highlighting special attention to check-in processes and personalized service. Jeanie, a team member, is frequently commended for her outstanding service. The dedicated staff contribute significantly to enhancing the overall experience, making each visit memorable.

Parking at Box Hill Motel is well-organized, offering designated spaces that guests find convenient and hassle-free. The ability to park directly in front of rooms adds to the ease of access, contributing to a seamless stay. Overall, Box Hill Motel is noted for its clean, comfortable accommodations and stellar service, making it a favored choice for travelers to the area.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
PARKROYAL Monash Melbourne main photo
PARKROYAL Monash Melbourne
4.7 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Clayton NorthAU flag
8.6
Very Good
From $123
$
Info
Summary of reviews
PARKROYAL Monash Melbourne is a modern and glamorous hotel that offers excellent value for money. Its location is convenient for both leisure and business travelers with easy access to shops, restaurants and public transport. The buffet breakfast is outstanding and included in the rate, while the rooms are spacious, clean and luxurious with incredibly comfortable beds. The staff is friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable, providing excellent customer service. The hotel's cleanliness standards are high, although some areas may need improvement. The parking arrangements are generally satisfactory and the pool is a nice addition, although it is shared with residents of a joint apartment complex. Overall, PARKROYAL Monash Melbourne is a great choice for those looking for a comfortable and stylish stay in Melbourne.
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham main photo
Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham
4.8 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in SandringhamAU flag
9.1
Excellent
From $155
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham earns high praise from guests for its strategic location, impressive facilities, and welcoming environment. Nestled in a serene suburb yet conveniently close to beautiful beaches and extensive local amenities, this accommodation serves as an excellent base for exploring the area. Visitors appreciate the easy access to public transport, shopping centers like Southland, and a variety of restaurants and local shops. The secure basement car park adds further convenience for travelers with vehicles.

The apartments are celebrated for their spaciousness, modernity, and immaculate cleanliness. Guests frequently highlight the generous size and tranquility of the rooms, making them ideal for families. Each unit is well-appointed with a fully equipped kitchen and modern washing facilities, ensuring a comfortable stay. The chic decor and lovely furnishings, complemented by charming balconies in some units, enhance the property's aesthetic appeal.

Cleanliness stands out as a hallmark of the Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham, with guests describing the property as spotlessly maintained and almost brand new. The cleaning staff receive special mention for their friendly and efficient service, contributing to the fresh and inviting atmosphere. This high standard of cleanliness, combined with modern amenities and restful features such as sound-absorbing curtains, underscores the comfort and relaxation guests experience during their stay.

The staff at Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham are frequently commended for their exceptional service. Known for their friendliness, professionalism, and attentiveness, the team ensures a welcoming atmosphere from check-in to check-out. From the front desk to housekeeping, staff members are recognized for their dedication to resolving any issues and enhancing the overall guest experience.

Parking also receives positive remarks, with secure and easy-to-navigate underground spaces that provide convenience and peace of mind. Despite some feedback on narrow spaces, guests appreciate the inclusion of parking in the stay cost and the proximity to a nearby IGA store and café.

Overall, Caroline Serviced Apartments Sandringham offers a modern, clean, and comfortable environment that meets the diverse needs of its guests, ensuring a memorable stay.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
Luxury Apartment Views Bay And City main photo
Luxury Apartment Views Bay And City
4.8 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Crest on Park main photo
Crest on Park
5.3 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
7.5
Good
From $94
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Crest on Park is a highly recommended accommodation praised for its prime location in St Kilda, offering a blend of tranquility and accessibility to both relaxation spots and urban attractions. Guests appreciate its proximity to beautiful beaches, the lively St Kilda CBD and ease of access to restaurants, bars, shops, public transportation and notable facilities like Albert Park. This makes it ideal for casual strolls, quick trips to local cafes or attending events.

The hotel's facilities are fresh and modern, highlighted by comfortable and well-appointed rooms that many guests find cozy and clean. The inclusion of a kitchenette adds a convenience factor for longer stays. While some rooms may feel smaller, particularly the corner and family rooms without windows, the overall ambiance and amenities meet guest expectations for comfort and basic needs.

Cleanliness remains a strong point with consistently positive feedback about the tidy and well-maintained rooms, particularly the bathrooms which visitors describe as very clean with modern fixtures. Despite a few minor criticisms regarding specific areas, the majority of guests are satisfied with the level of cleanliness and the rejuvenating atmosphere of the rooms.

Breakfast offerings at
Crest on Park, consisting of essentials such as cereal, bread and condiments, are seen as a pleasant addition, especially appreciated by families. While suggestions for healthier cereal options have been made, the overall sentiment is that the continental breakfast is a valuable and convenient extra.

The staff at
Crest on Park receive commendations for their friendliness and helpfulness, particularly the cleaning staff and receptionists. Though some guests experienced lapses in communication and instances of unprofessional behavior, the majority found the staff attentive and accommodating, enhancing the overall guest experience.

Parking facilities present a mix of opinions. Secure parking is available but limited, leading to a first-come, first-served scenario with some guests finding this arrangement inconvenient and the additional nightly fee undesirable. Despite these drawbacks, the secure nature of the parking is appreciated.

When it comes to sleeping arrangements, the main beds at
Crest on Park are frequently described as very comfortable and conducive to a restful night's sleep. Some auxiliary bedding like sofa beds, however, have received less favorable feedback, indicating occasional discomfort.

Overall, the combination of an excellent location, modern and clean facilities, friendly staff and the added convenience of breakfast and parking (albeit with some limitations) make
Crest on Park a well-rounded choice for both leisure and business travelers.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
4 Star
Parking
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park main photo
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park
5.4 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
7.4
Good
From $87
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park garners mostly positive reviews across various categories, often highlighted for its prime location across from Albert Park. Guests appreciate the hotel's serene setting away from the city center, yet with easy access to public transport, making it convenient for exploring Melbourne and attending nearby events. Its proximity to attractions like St. Kilda Beach and the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG), along with numerous restaurants and cafes, caters well to both leisure and business travelers. The on-site parking, despite some cost concerns, adds practicality to the experience.

The breakfast offerings at the hotel are generally well-received, praised for their variety and quality of food, though some feel it could be overpriced. The complimentary meals for children and the enjoyable atmosphere enhance the breakfast experience for families.

Dinner experiences are mixed with room service and the bar receiving positive feedback for their quality and reasonable prices. However, the restaurant itself faces criticisms of limited menu options and occasional inconsistency in service and food quality.

Rooms are noted for their spaciousness and comfort, especially the beds, but also receive feedback concerning their dated appearance and occasional maintenance issues. Cleanliness standards are generally satisfactory, though some guests report lapses that detract from their stay.

Staff at
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park are often commended for their friendliness and professionalism, particularly in housekeeping and concierge services. Specific staff members have been highlighted for their exceptional service, although some inconsistency at the reception desk is noted.

Complimentary WiFi at the hotel receives criticism for its unreliability and limited connections per room. Nonetheless, the gym and pool facilities are well-liked for their quality and convenience, adding value to guests' experiences. The gym's good equipment and flexible hours, along with a clean and family-friendly pool area, are significant highlights.

While parking is appreciated for its convenience, guests express concerns about its cost and the clarity of the parking process. However, families find
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park accommodating with its spacious rooms and child-friendly amenities, making it a favored choice for family stays.

In summary,
Mercure Melbourne Albert Park offers a balanced experience with standout features like location, family-friendly facilities and generally commendable service, while presenting areas for potential improvement in room updates, dining consistency and internet service.
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
Golf
View Melbourne main photo
View Melbourne
5.5 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.3
Very Good
From $77
$
Info
Summary of reviews
View Melbourne enjoys high praise from guests for its strategic location and access to key Melbourne areas. Situated on St Kilda Road, it offers seamless proximity to attractions, the CBD, St Kilda and healthcare facilities like the Alfred Hospital. Guests appreciate its balanced central yet tranquil setting, nearby public transport options and the scenic views from the rooms. Parking, while occasionally an extra cost, is deemed convenient, making the hotel a favored choice for both business and leisure travelers.

The breakfast offerings at
View Melbourne receive mostly positive feedback for their variety, quality and value with many guests enjoying the delicious buffet. However, some mention that the breakfast could be basic, especially for those with dietary restrictions and felt some items were overpriced or uninspiring. Despite these critiques, many found the breakfast experience satisfying.

Dining options at
View Melbourne have mixed reviews. The on-site Hop Garden is praised for its pleasant atmosphere and quality food, despite some noise issues. However, feedback on menu variety and food quality is inconsistent with some diners satisfied and others disappointed by limited and sometimes subpar options. Room service also elicited varied opinions, although the convenience and friendly staff received positive marks.

The rooms are widely praised for their spaciousness, cleanliness and comfort with many guests appreciating modern amenities and pleasant views. Some comments mention dated decor and minor maintenance issues, but overall, the accommodations are seen as functional and welcoming.

Cleanliness is a strong point for the hotel with frequent mentions of spotless rooms and well-maintained facilities. Occasional lapses are noted, such as dusty spots or issues in some bathrooms, but the general sentiment remains favorable.

The staff at
View Melbourne are celebrated for their exceptional service, friendliness and helpfulness, consistently going above and beyond to ensure a welcoming experience. Despite a few isolated negative interactions, the overall high level of customer satisfaction is a standout feature of the hotel.

Wifi services at the hotel receive mixed reviews. While many guests find the connectivity fast and reliable, others report frequent disconnections and slow speeds, impacting their ability to stream content or work effectively.

The pool and spa facilities present a mixed bag with guests appreciating the cleanliness and heated water when operational. However, many were disappointed by frequent closures for maintenance and the sometimes unappealing condition of the pool area.

Parking is generally viewed as convenient and reasonably priced, although the tight spaces can be challenging for larger vehicles. The availability of free street parking during weekends adds to the convenience.

View Melbourne is highly recommended for family stays, offering spacious accommodations, family-friendly amenities and a welcoming environment. The hotel’s amenities, such as the Hop Garden bar and Oakwood Café, cater well to families and special features like playgrounds and pet-friendly packages enhance the family experience.

Overall, the beds at
View Melbourne receive high praise for their comfort and cleanliness, significantly contributing to a restful and pleasant stay.
Categories
Pool
Indoor Pool
4 Star
Golf
Burwood East Motel main photo
Burwood East Motel
5.6 mi from Carnegie
Motel in BurwoodAU flag
8.6
Very Good
From $78
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Burwood East Motel is situated in an exceptionally convenient location, offering guests effortless access to essential amenities and transportation links. The motel is strategically placed near a major shopping complex that includes 24-hour supermarkets and diverse dining options, making it a perfect spot for daily needs. Visitors appreciate its proximity to restaurants, cafes, and service stations, and find it easy to reach the Melbourne CBD via tram services. This central location is particularly advantageous for those working nearby, providing a serene atmosphere for guests to unwind.

The motel's rooms are well-appointed and spacious, equipped with practical amenities such as a settee, table and chairs, along with a mini kitchenette that includes a microwave, fridge, and sink. Guests commend the rooms for their cleanliness and comfort, enjoying plush bedding that ensures a restful night's sleep. Despite its closeness to main roads, the accommodations maintain a peaceful quietness, lending to undisturbed relaxation and excellent value for money.

Burwood East Motel's commitment to cleanliness and comfort is consistently praised by guests. The rooms and surroundings are kept spotless, contributing to an inviting environment. Facilities such as the laundry, pool, and parking are meticulously maintained, enhancing the overall positive experience for visitors. Whether staying for family visits or seeking an economical option, guests appreciate the tidy and well-maintained environment.

The staff at Burwood East Motel are noted for their friendliness and helpfulness. Guests frequently commend the manager and team for their welcoming and cheerful demeanors, and appreciate the local insights provided at reception about nearby dining and shopping. Efficiency at the front desk ensures smooth check-ins and bookings, contributing to a pleasant stay. Combined with the convenience of a shopping center across the road, the staff's warm service highlights the motel as a standout location.

Lastly, the beds at the motel receive positive feedback for their comfort, with excellent pillows complementing the sleeping experience. Guests are generally satisfied with the cleanliness and comfort of the beds, although individual preferences for bed firmness may vary. On the whole, Burwood East Motel offers comfortable, clean, and cost-effective accommodations, making it a desirable choice for travelers.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
Novotel Melbourne Glen Waverley main photo
Novotel Melbourne Glen Waverley
5.7 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Glen WaverleyAU flag
8.3
Very Good
From $115
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Novotel Melbourne Glen Waverley consistently impresses its guests with its prime location, outstanding service, cleanliness and comfortable accommodations. Situated in the heart of Glen Waverley, the hotel is within walking distance of a range of shopping, dining and entertainment options, including a cinema complex and a luxurious shopping center. Public transport links, including a nearby train station, offer easy access to Melbourne's city center, ensuring convenience and ease for both leisure and business travelers.

Guests frequently praise the hotel's breakfast offerings, which feature a buffet with an extensive variety of high-quality foods and drinks. Though some minor issues were noted, such as the selection of hot foods and cost, most visitors find the breakfast delightful and excellent value for money.

The rooms at
Novotel Melbourne Glen Waverley receive high marks for their cleanliness, size and comfort. Furnished with modern amenities and super comfortable beds and pillows, the rooms are noted for their hygienic and spacious environment. Though there are occasional reports of minor cleanliness issues, the overall impression is overwhelmingly positive.

Cleanliness throughout the hotel is commendable with many guests highlighting the super tidy, fresh and comfortable rooms. The friendly and helpful staff contribute significantly to the pleasant atmosphere, consistently going above and beyond to meet guest needs. This exceptional service is often cited as a standout feature of the hotel.

Parking at the hotel is convenient but comes with a fee of $25 per night, which some guests find to be on the higher side. Despite the limited availability and added cost, the on-site parking is still appreciated for its convenience.

Families find the hotel particularly accommodating with special touches such as activity packs for kids and personalized welcome gestures enhancing the family-friendly experience. The shallow pool adds an extra layer of safety for young children and the hotel's location offers easy access to numerous family-friendly activities.

Overall, the
Novotel Melbourne Glen Waverley offers a reliable and welcoming stay with its exceptional location, high standards of cleanliness and comfort and top-notch service, making it a favored choice for both individuals and families visiting the area.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
4 Star
Family
Skygarden Luxury Condo main photo
Skygarden Luxury Condo
5.7 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in Glen WaverleyAU flag
8.3
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
Private Room and bathroom in Shared Apartment with Host main photo
Private Room and bathroom in Shared Apartment with Host
6.0 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in Box HillAU flag
9.0
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Avani Melbourne Box Hill Residences main photo
Avani Melbourne Box Hill Residences
6.1 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in Box HillAU flag
8.8
Excellent
From $92
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Avani Melbourne Box Hill Residences provides an exceptional living experience, highly reflected in guest reviews focusing on its numerous merits.

Situated in a charming suburb just outside Melbourne CBD, the property's location is particularly praised. Its proximity to essential amenities, like Box Hill Central, Epworth Eastern and Box Hill hospitals, makes it ideal for various travelers, whether for medical, leisure or business purposes. The accessible public transport links, including nearby tram and train stations, facilitate easy exploration of the broader Melbourne area. Despite its centrality, guests appreciate the quiet surroundings, balancing connectivity with serenity.

The rooms at
Avani Melbourne Box Hill Residences offer spacious, clean and modern accommodations that consistently win positive feedback. Guests highlight the well-maintained and contemporary decor, alongside features such as balconies with stunning city views, modern appliances and generous storage space. The multiple bedrooms, bathrooms and well-equipped kitchens make it especially suitable for families or groups. Additionally, the overall cleanliness and the thoughtful layout of the rooms enhance the comfort and relaxation of the stay.

The staff receives continual recognition for their welcoming, helpful and friendly demeanor. They are often described as accommodating, efficient and proactive in addressing guests’ needs. Guests frequently appreciate the reception team's attentiveness and the extra efforts of individual staff members, such as providing additional comforts. This level of personalized service significantly enhances the overall guest experience.

The fitness amenities, particularly the gym and rooftop pool, are significant attractions. The well-equipped gym, although its hours could be extended, is consistently praised for its cleanliness and quality. The rooftop infinity pool, often highlighted alongside the spa area, offers stunning views and a luxurious relaxation spot, especially noted for its warm waters during colder months. The combination of these facilities ensures a complete fitness and relaxation experience.

Parking facilities, while secure and convenient with easy lift access, come with an added cost, which some guests believe could be more affordable or inclusive. Nonetheless, the available spaces and security measures are generally appreciated, contributing to a hassle-free stay for those with vehicles.

Comfortable beds are a standout feature, frequently described as large and very comfortable, though some guests found the pillows too soft for their liking. Overall, the combination of a well-kept, clean environment and comfortable sleeping arrangements ensures a satisfying experience.

In summary,
Avani Melbourne Box Hill Residences is lauded for its prime location, modern and spacious accommodations, exceptional staff service, excellent fitness amenities including an admired rooftop pool and comfortable beds, making it a highly recommended choice for various types of travelers.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Parking
MainStay Suites Kew main photo
MainStay Suites Kew
6.1 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.0
Very Good
From $183
$
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Sustainability Journey
Best Western Plus The Tudor Box Hill main photo
Best Western Plus The Tudor Box Hill
6.4 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Box HillAU flag
7.2
Good
From $74
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Best Western Plus The Tudor Box Hill, nestled in the heart of Box Hill, combines convenience and comfort, making it a suitable choice for both leisure and business travelers. Its prime location within walking distance of Box Hill Central and proximity to public transport ensures easy access to Melbourne's city center and local attractions. Guests appreciate the tranquil, green surroundings that provide a serene contrast to the bustling metropolitan area. The strategic location facilitates access to nearby hospitals, cafes, restaurants and other amenities, enhancing the overall guest experience.

Breakfast at the hotel receives favorable comments for its quality and punctual service, though some guests note the need for clearer communication regarding breakfast arrangements and inclusions. The on-site dining experiences, particularly dinner, earn praise for tasty and reasonably priced meals, though the limited menu and occasional closures due to external factors like COVID-19 have posed challenges for some visitors.

The rooms are frequently highlighted for their spaciousness, comfort and modern amenities with features like well-equipped kitchens and ample storage making them ideal for extended stays. Positive remarks include good value for money, seamless check-in processes and thoughtful touches such as electric blankets. However, occasional maintenance issues and inconsistent cleanliness standards are noted, suggesting a need for more rigorous housekeeping protocols.

Cleanliness feedback is mixed; while many guests find the property clean with a homely ambiance, recurring issues such as dirty carpets, mold and overall worn-out facilities indicate areas for improvement. The staff receives generally positive reviews for their friendly, helpful and accommodating nature, contributing significantly to a pleasant stay despite some isolated incidents of unprofessional behavior.

The complimentary Wi-Fi service receives varied responses, working well for many guests but proving inconsistent and outdated for others. The on-site gym is appreciated for its functionality, though some guests point out the need for newer equipment and better maintenance. The indoor pool and spa are popular features, though temperature inconsistencies and occasional non-functional spa equipment are notable drawbacks.

Lastly, the beds mostly garner positive feedback for their comfort with many guests finding them exceptionally cozy. However, a few guests mention issues such as overly soft mattresses and outdated bedding, which underline the need for occasional updates to maintain the comfort standard.

Overall,
Best Western Plus The Tudor Box Hill provides a comfortable and convenient stay with numerous positive aspects that cater to a wide range of guest needs, though improvements in maintenance and clarity of services could further enhance the experience.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
4 Star
Gym
Seasons Botanic Gardens main photo
Seasons Botanic Gardens
6.4 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.0
Very Good
From $83
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Seasons Botanic Gardens in Melbourne garners largely positive feedback from its guests, particularly highlighting its prime location along St Kilda Road. The hotel is conveniently situated near significant attractions like the Shrine of Remembrance, Royal Botanic Gardens and Federation Square with tram stops facilitating easy access to Melbourne’s CBD, Southbank, Albert Park and numerous local dining spots. Despite its central location, the area is noted for its tranquility, offering a peaceful retreat amid the bustling city.

The spacious rooms and helpful, friendly staff contribute significantly to the positive experience of guests. Accommodations range from one-bedroom apartments to large two-bedroom suites, accommodating up to six people. The rooms are frequently described as clean, well-maintained and equipped with practical amenities such as full kitchens, laundry facilities and comfortable beds. Many rooms also boast beautiful views of the Botanic Gardens or cityscape, adding to the comfortable and homely ambiance.

Staff at
Seasons Botanic Gardens are regularly praised for their friendliness, professionalism and eagerness to assist guests. This includes the reception and housekeeping teams, both of which contribute to a welcoming and efficient service experience. Specific staff members are often highlighted for going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay.

While the hotel does offer valuable amenities such as free and reliable WiFi, a well-equipped gym and pleasant pool facilities, there are areas requiring improvement. The breakfast facilities are notably missing with many guests expressing a desire for a substantial breakfast option within the hotel. The restaurant closure and the need to venture out for breakfast detract slightly from the overall experience.

Cleanliness, despite generally positive feedback, does have some detractors. Issues such as rust stains, mold in bathrooms and occasional unpleasant odors have been reported, indicating a need for better maintenance in certain areas. Similarly, the pool and spa facilities, while praised when operational, have faced functionality issues, particularly with heating and cleanliness.

Parking facilities are another point of mixed reviews. They are convenient and secure but come with an additional cost and some logistical challenges, such as the need to carry luggage up stairs due to a lack of elevator access.

Overall,
Seasons Botanic Gardens is well-regarded for its spacious accommodations, strategic location and commendable staff service. It provides good value for money, especially for families and groups looking to explore Melbourne comfortably. However, addressing the breakfast, maintenance and specific facility issues would significantly enhance the guest experience.
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
Sustainability Journey
The Dingley Hotel main photo
The Dingley Hotel
6.7 mi from Carnegie
Motel in DingleyAU flag
8.9
Excellent
From $102
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Dingley Hotel has garnered strong positive feedback across various categories, making it an appealing choice for a diverse array of travelers. Its notable location stands out, offering easy access to a variety of local attractions, shops, dining spots and essential services. Guests find the hotel to be an excellent base for both business and leisure, appreciating the convenient parking and smooth check-in processes. The proximity to both entertainment and practical facilities, despite a slight distance from the city and public transport, contributes to its appeal.

The rooms at
The Dingley Hotel are another highlight, consistently praised for their spaciousness and cleanliness. Visitors appreciate the large, comfortable beds and modern bathrooms, alongside well-stocked amenities such as a mini bar and tea/coffee facilities. The peace and quiet of the locale add to the overall restful experience, even though some rooms are close to entertainment venues.

Dining is a strong suit for
The Dingley Hotel with guests frequently commending both breakfast and dinner offerings. Breakfast is generally viewed positively for its flavor, variety and value, although a few guests noted limited options and suggested a later service time. Dinner has received high praise, particularly the renovated bistro which offers delicious food, quick service and a pleasant dining atmosphere. The on-site restaurant and bar also contribute to a satisfying culinary experience.

The staff at
The Dingley Hotel are lauded for their friendliness, helpfulness and professionalism, fostering a welcoming and accommodating environment. Many guests highlight the excellent customer service and the staff's willingness to assist, forming a cornerstone of the hotel's positive reputation.

Cleanliness throughout the property is consistently praised with guests noting the spotless rooms and well-maintained facilities. The attention to detail in maintaining a clean and comfortable environment further enhances the overall guest experience.

While generally positive, a few areas require attention. The wifi service received mixed reviews with some guests experiencing weak or unstable connections. Additionally, the pool area was frequently noted for needing significant improvements in cleanliness and maintenance. Despite these issues, many children still enjoyed the pool.

Parking at
The Dingley Hotel is highlighted for its convenience and security, though not fully undercover. Most reviewers had no trouble finding a spot, though occasional minor issues like bird droppings were noted.

In conclusion,
The Dingley Hotel stands out for its excellent location, spacious and clean rooms, comfortable beds, commendable dining options and exceptional staff. While there are minor areas for improvement, particularly with the wifi and pool, the overall experience is highly positive, making it a recommended choice for visitors.
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 120 hotels in and around Carnegie
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities
4-Star Hotels, Aparthotels, Motels, Guesthouses with Swimming Pool in Carnegie