Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

3-Star Hotels in Carnegie

127 HOTELS IN AND AROUND CARNEGIERanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
Chadstone Executive Motel main photo
Chadstone Executive Motel
1.3 mi from Carnegie
Motel in OakleighAU flag
6.7
Rated
From $83
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Small
Lamplighter Motel main photo
Lamplighter Motel
1.8 mi from Carnegie
Motel in OakleighAU flag
4.8
Rated
From $67
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Parking
Nightcap at Matthew Flinders Hotel main photo
Nightcap at Matthew Flinders Hotel
2.0 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in ChadstoneAU flag
8.4
Very Good
From $89
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Parking
Malvern Backpackers main photo
Malvern Backpackers
2.7 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in MelbourneAU flag
7.5
Good
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Malvern Backpackers stands out as an ideal accommodation choice for budget-conscious travelers seeking comfort and accessibility in Melbourne. Set in the charming neighborhood of Malvern, the location strikes a perfect balance between tranquility and convenience, offering seamless connectivity to the city's vibrant attractions via nearby tram and train stations. The proximity to a shopping center, supermarkets, and a variety of lively restaurants enhances the overall experience, ensuring guests have all essentials within easy reach.

The high standards of cleanliness further elevate the experience at Malvern Backpackers, with guests frequently praising the tidy and well-maintained rooms. Bathrooms are consistently highlighted for their modern and clean facilities, contributing to a comfortable stay. While minor improvements are suggested for areas like windows and carpets, the overall impression remains positive. Guests appreciate the well-kept kitchen facilities and the comfortable beds, creating a restful environment that complements the property's affordability.

The backbone of Malvern Backpackers is its remarkable staff, who earn glowing praise for their friendliness and attentiveness. Efficient communication and easy self-check-in procedures ensure a smooth operation and warm welcome for guests. Noteworthy staff members, including Nick, demonstrate exceptional dedication to accommodating guests' needs, offering guidance and assistance that consistently contribute to a positive experience.

Bed experiences at Malvern Backpackers offer a mix of comfort and, occasionally, varied feedback. Many guests enjoy the comfort of clean and big beds, with some appreciating the feather beds for a touch of luxury. While there are mentions of hard or squeaky mattresses, the overall consensus points to a satisfactory sleep experience for most visitors.

In summary, Malvern Backpackers provides excellent value for money through its combination of prime location, reliable cleanliness, and outstanding staff service. The hostel's commitment to creating a welcoming and comfortable environment makes it a top choice for travelers exploring Melbourne.
Categories
3 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Cheap
Chic One-Bedroom Studio in the Heart of Elsternwick main photo
Chic One-Bedroom Studio in the Heart of Elsternwick
2.7 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in MelbourneAU flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Small
Nightcap at Sandbelt Hotel main photo
Nightcap at Sandbelt Hotel
3.2 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MoorabbinAU flag
8.3
Very Good
From $85
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Nightcap at Sandbelt Hotel proves to be an ideal choice for travelers, primarily due to its prime location and exceptional service. Guests continually praise the convenience and serenity of its location, close to key attractions like Moorabbin Airport and medical facilities, while being tucked away from heavy traffic for a restful environment. The hotel's ample parking, easy city access, and excellent on-site amenities, including a sports bar and restaurant, further add to its appeal.

Dining at the hotel stands out, with the on-site bistro and restaurant offering delicious meals often described as brilliant and providing excellent value for money. Many guests appreciate the room service, which brings hot and tasty meals directly to the room, creating a comfortable dining option complemented by friendly, helpful staff.

The rooms at Nightcap at Sandbelt Hotel are consistently praised for their cleanliness and modern accommodations. Guests find the rooms neat, tidy, and spotless, with well-organized and equipped layouts for a satisfying stay. Comfortable beds and excellent shower pressure contribute to a quiet and relaxing experience, enriched by accommodating staff.

Cleanliness is a notable highlight, with rooms described as exceptionally clean and featuring modern décor. Large TVs, plush couches, and superb shower facilities add to the overall sense of relaxation, while the housekeeping team's meticulous attention to detail ensures a fresh and well-stocked environment. Friendly reception staff enhance guest experiences with their efficient and courteous service.

The staff at the hotel are frequently acknowledged for their exemplary hospitality, with individuals like Victoria at the check-in desk leaving lasting positive impressions. The team’s friendliness and helpfulness contribute significantly to memorable stays.

Although the hotel's wifi receives mixed reviews, with some facing connectivity issues, this does not detract from the largely positive dining and accommodation experiences. Overall, Nightcap at Sandbelt Hotel offers comfortable and modern accommodations, outstanding dining, and exemplary service, making it a highly recommended option for travelers seeking a convenient and pleasant stay.
Categories
3 Star
Golf
Honeymoon
Hawthorn Gardens Serviced Apartments main photo
Hawthorn Gardens Serviced Apartments
3.3 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
6.1
Rated
From $88
$
3 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' category
Hawthorn Gardens Serviced Apartments offers an affordable stay with reasonable prices, making it a decent value for money. The accommodation suits budget-conscious travelers and those needing extra space, as there are affordable three-bedroom options available. While it may not provide a five-star experience, the essential services and basic amenities it offers can meet most guests' needs.

The property's overall look is somewhat dated and in need of maintenance or a facelift. Some guests have noted that it appears tired and could be cleaner, reflecting its three-star rating. Despite these points, it provides fair value for money, considering its price point and spacious accommodations. For those managing their budget, this hotel can be a fitting choice, as you get what you pay for.
Royalty Living Unit 3 main photo
Royalty Living Unit 3
3.8 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in Clayton NorthAU flag
9.0
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Adorabe 1-Bedroom guesthouse with free parking on premises main photo
Adorabe 1-Bedroom guesthouse with free parking on premises
4.3 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in MelbourneAU flag
6.6
Rated
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Sustainability Journey
Parking
Habitat HQ main photo
Habitat HQ
4.5 mi from Carnegie
Hostel in MelbourneAU flag
8.2
Very Good
From $12
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Windsor Green Hotel main photo
Windsor Green Hotel
4.6 mi from Carnegie
Guest House in MelbourneAU flag
7.3
Good
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Cheap
Nightcap at Monash Hotel main photo
Nightcap at Monash Hotel
4.6 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in Clayton NorthAU flag
8.2
Very Good
From $98
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Nightcap at Monash Hotel is favorably reviewed by guests for its combination of prime location, excellent facilities, and welcoming atmosphere. Strategically located near Monash University and M-City, the hotel offers easy access to local attractions and important sites like Monash Children's Hospital, making it ideal for both families and business travelers. Its proximity to transportation routes simplifies travel to Melbourne's CBD, and guests appreciate the quiet environment despite being centrally located.

The hotel provides a satisfactory breakfast experience with convenient breakfast packs. While there is room for improvement with additional offerings, the existing provisions are appreciated for their taste and accessibility. The on-site bistro delivers a satisfying dining experience, noted for its delightful menu and efficient room service, contributing to repeat visits.

Rooms are consistently noted for their cleanliness and modern appeal. Recent renovations have resulted in spacious and comfortable accommodations that cater well to families. Guests highlight the comfort of the beds, which significantly enhance the overall stay experience. The outstanding cleanliness of the hotel is a recurring theme, with crisp sheets and fluffy towels adding to the comfort.

The staff consistently impress with their exceptional service and friendly demeanor, ensuring a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Guests feel valued and supported, with special mention of the hotel manager's personable approach. Families traveling with children find the hotel especially accommodating, with spacious rooms and a play area for kids. Convenient parking adds to the ease and comfort of family stays.

Overall, Nightcap at Monash Hotel offers a pleasant and well-rounded choice for travelers seeking comfort, convenience, and friendly hospitality.
Categories
3 Star
Family
St Kilda Hostel main photo
St Kilda Hostel
4.6 mi from Carnegie
Hostel in MelbourneAU flag
4.7
Rated
From $89
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Nightlife
Free Wi-Fi
The Glenferrie Hotel Hawthorn main photo
The Glenferrie Hotel Hawthorn
4.9 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.7
Very Good
From $124
$
3 Star
This boutique hotel, built in 1888, features rooms with a spa bath and free Wi-Fi. The Glenferrie Hotel Hawthorn provides a restaurant, a bar, and free parking, offering a blend of historic charm and modern amenities in a convenient location.
Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' category
The Glenferrie Hotel Hawthorn offers a delightful stay within a charming old heritage building, delivering a unique blend of history and comfort. Despite its age, the establishment maintains a cozy ambiance and decent services, making it a commendable choice for travelers. Its strategic location enhances its appeal, while the friendly staff add a touch of warmth to the overall experience. Guests appreciate its affordability and perceive it as a home away from home, embodying a balance between a beautiful boutique hotel setting and upmarket pub accommodation. It's an ideal place for those seeking a restful night's sleep or a convenient base for exploring the area.
Roamer St Kilda main photo
Roamer St Kilda
5.0 mi from Carnegie
Hostel in MelbourneAU flag
8.0
Very Good
$
3 Star
This hotel is near St Kilda Beach and offers budget-friendly accommodations. It provides a social atmosphere and easy access to the beach and local attractions, making it suitable for young travelers.
Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' category
Roamer St Kilda, formerly Selina St Kilda Melbourne, has garnered mixed reviews from guests. While some found the facilities lacking, others noted its appeal largely resembles that of a hostel. The atmosphere may not meet everyone's expectations, especially if one anticipates more than the basic amenities typical of hostels.

Travelers looking for comfort may find the rooms somewhat disappointing due to their bare presentation and the absence of fixed furniture. There's a desire among guests for enhanced communal spaces, such as a rooftop area, which would add to the overall experience.

Though not explicitly reflected in the reviews, guests should be mindful of their personal safety, particularly solo travelers, as some found the location uncomfortable. The cost of staying here might seem high relative to the facilities provided. Overall, this accommodation might cater best to those with modest expectations seeking a hostel-like environment.
Punt Road Apartment Hotel main photo
Punt Road Apartment Hotel
5.0 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
7.4
Good
From $103
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Nightlife
Free Wi-Fi
Easystay Studio Apartments main photo
Easystay Studio Apartments
5.1 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
8.1
Very Good
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Beach
Nightlife
Hotel Claremont Guest House main photo
Hotel Claremont Guest House
5.2 mi from Carnegie
Hostel in MelbourneAU flag
7.5
Good
From $60
$
Info
Categories
3 Star
Historic
South Yarra Central Apartment Hotel main photo
South Yarra Central Apartment Hotel
5.2 mi from Carnegie
Aparthotel in MelbourneAU flag
7.5
Good
From $91
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The South Yarra Central Apartment Hotel is highly praised for its exceptional location in the heart of South Yarra. Its proximity to dining, shopping and public transport options makes it an ideal base for exploring Melbourne. The central position on Chapel Street provides easy access to a variety of bars, restaurants, cafes and beauty salons, adding to the convenience for guests. A nearby shopping centre and accessible trams and trains enhance the overall experience, making the hotel's location a frequently mentioned strong point.

Apartments at South Yarra Central are spacious, well-laid-out and equipped with fully functional kitchens, enabling comfortable and extended stays. The rooms are clean and comfortable with many guests appreciating their generous sizes and good views. Despite minor issues like fluctuating internet and TV quality or the occasional need for more thorough cleaning, the overall impression of the accommodations is positive.

Cleanliness receives mixed feedback with some guests noting inconsistencies. While many apartments are spotlessly clean and comfortable, others report issues such as mould in bathrooms and litter in hallways. Nevertheless, the comfort and well-maintained kitchens are often highlighted as significant advantages.

The hotel's staff stand out for their friendliness and exceptional service. Guests frequently commend the reception team, especially individuals like Peter and Ouzman, for their welcoming and helpful demeanor. The general manager is also noted for excellent customer service, contributing to numerous pleasant and hassle-free stays.

On-site parking is another benefit, although it comes at an additional cost of $30 per night. The secure and convenient setup is appreciated by many with straightforward access to entry doors and lifts enhancing the experience. Despite a few challenges, such as finding parking spaces during busy times, the feedback on parking remains positive overall.

The hotel's beds are generally well-received with numerous guests remarking on their comfort and the quality of the mattresses and pillows. Although there are occasional comments about the size of the beds or pillow comfort, the majority of reviewers praise the restful experience.

Overall,
South Yarra Central Apartment Hotel offers excellent value for money with its balance of location, price and amenities. The combination of spacious apartments, friendly staff, secure parking and prime location makes it a highly recommended choice for anyone visiting Melbourne. While there are minor areas for improvement, the hotel's comfort, value and service position it as a strong contender in the four-star category.
Categories
3 Star
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Nightcap at Sandringham Hotel main photo
Nightcap at Sandringham Hotel
5.2 mi from Carnegie
Hotel in SandringhamAU flag
8.0
Very Good
From $94
$
3 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '3 Star' category
Nightcap at Sandringham Hotel is a great choice for budget-conscious travelers. The hotel offers good value and pleasant accommodation that has been nicely renovated. While the hotel is not five-star, it is definitely more than adequate for a few nights. The location is excellent and the price is fantastic. Guests feel that the hotel provides good value for what you pay and it is comfortable accommodation for a great price. However, some guests experienced poor service and organization, which detracted from their overall experience. Additionally, the hotel could use some improvement regarding noise levels, which were too loud to get a good night's sleep. Despite these drawbacks, the Nightcap at Sandringham Hotel remains a good option for travelers looking for an affordable, convenient place to stay.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 127 hotels in and around Carnegie
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities