Hawks Cay Resort offers a mixed experience when it comes to its accommodations. Many guests commend the rooms for being spacious and comfortable, with some offering fantastic views of the ocean and canals. The overall setup of the hotel and its amenities, such as the lagoon with free paddle boarding and canoeing, adds to the charm of the stay. Cleanliness is often highlighted positively, particularly in certain villas on the harbor, which are described as beautiful and well-kept.
However, there are notable drawbacks. Some rooms, while spacious, are considered dated and in need of modernization to match the cost of staying at the resort. Comfort varies significantly, with several guests finding the beds uncomfortable or hard. Issues with maintenance, such as broken bathroom doors, missing towel hooks, and blown light bulbs, detract from the experience. Noise also poses a problem, whether from neighboring rooms or noisy carpets in some accommodations. The descriptions of accommodations have occasionally led to some bewilderment, with rooms facing unexpected directions or lacking promised views, such as those of the harbor.
Despite these mixed reviews, the activities available, the scenic views, and the presence of dolphins contribute positively to the overall experience at Hawks Cay Resort, though guests suggest improvements in room comfort and maintenance are necessary.