The Gardens Hotel
Hotel in Key West FL
9.6
Excellent
From $265
From $265
4-Star Hotel
Known for its lush, tranquil gardens, providing a serene escape. It offers luxurious accommodations and personalized service. This hotel is celebrated for its exceptional ambiance and attention to detail, ensuring a memorable stay.
Show more
 
Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Resort in Key West FL
8.4
Very Good
From $211
From $211
4-Star Resort
Features multiple pools and waterfront views, creating a relaxing island atmosphere. It offers spacious villas with private balconies. It provides a range of amenities including on-site dining and water sports activities.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categorySituated in a prime location, Parrot Key Hotel & Villas presents a mixed bag of experiences when viewed through the lens of a four-star rating. The hotel is praised for its beautiful, well-maintained property and great pool area, aligning with its upscale image. Many guests found the facilities to be excellent and on par with other four-star resorts, contributing to a very good overall experience.

However, opinions on the service are divided. While some guests identified the service and comfort as consistent with four-star expectations, others felt room for improvement, calling attention to poor service and maintenance issues like damaged furniture and walls. The valet parking service, charged at $23 per day, received mixed reactions with some seeing it as a standard for such a resort while others viewed it as an unnecessary expense.

Despite these shortcomings, the hotel's beautiful design and cozy atmosphere have made a lasting impression. Although various reviews argue whether Parrot Key truly deserves its four-star status, it certainly provides a memorable stay, albeit with a few areas needing refinement.
Show more
 
H2O Suites- Adults Only
Resort in Key West FL
9.5
Excellent
From $384
From $384
4-Star Resort
An exclusive, adults-only resort offering modern suites with private plunge pools. It features a rooftop deck with panoramic views and a full-service spa. The hotel provides a sophisticated and intimate atmosphere.
Show more
 
Santa Maria Suites Resort
Resort in Key West FL
9.3
Excellent
From $391
From $391
4-Star Resort
Offers spacious suites with full kitchens and private balconies, ideal for extended stays. It features a serene pool area and is located close to the beach and Duval Street. Guests enjoy personalized service and a relaxed ambiance.
Show more
 
Pier House Resort & Spa
Resort in Key West FL
8.4
Very Good
From $399
From $399
4-Star Resort
Features a private beach and multiple dining options with ocean views. It offers a full-service spa and live entertainment. Its prime location provides easy access to Key West's attractions.
Show more
 
Opal Key Resort & Marina
Resort in Key West FL
8.5
Very Good
From $327
From $327
4-Star Resort
Offers luxurious accommodations with private balconies overlooking the marina. It features waterfront dining and a lively pool scene. The resort provides direct access to water activities and is close to Duval Street.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryIf you're looking for a passable stay in Key West, Opal Key Resort & Marina may just do the trick. However, the majority of guest reviews suggest this hotel is much more than just passable - it's very good, exceptional and even superb. Guests have praised the hotel's facilities and services, noting the nice and clean rooms, fantastic location in the heart of Key West and the marina. The hotel's restaurant has also received high praise with guests raving about the delicious breakfast spread. Some guests have questioned whether the hotel truly deserves a four-star rating, but overall, guests have had wonderful experiences and would happily return for their next trip to Key West. So, if you're looking for a nice place to stay in the heart of Key West with great facilities and services, Opal Key Resort & Marina may just be the perfect choice for you.
Show more
 
Ocean Key Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort
Resort in Key West FL
8.5
Very Good
From $435
From $435
4-Star Resort
Located at the end of Duval Street, offering stunning sunset views. It features a luxurious spa, waterfront dining, and live music. The resort provides an upscale experience with exceptional service.
Show more
 
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Resort in Key West FL
8.9
Excellent
From $202
From $202
4-Star Resort
Located on Stock Island, offering a tranquil escape with marina views. It features multiple dining options, a waterfront pool, and modern amenities. The hotel provides a unique and relaxing experience away from the downtown crowds.
Show more
 
Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa
Resort in Key West FL
8.3
Very Good
From $338
From $338
4-Star Resort
Features a waterfront location with stunning views and a luxurious spa. It offers modern rooms with private balconies and a lively pool area. The resort provides easy access to Key West's attractions.
Show more
 
The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton
Resort in Key West FL
7.6
Good
From $376
From $376
4-Star Resort
Offers a private natural beach, a rarity in Key West, and upscale amenities. It features oceanfront dining and elegant rooms with balconies. The hotel provides a luxurious and relaxing experience.
Show more
 
Havana Cabana at Key West
Hotel in Key West FL
8.2
Very Good
From $211
From $211
4-Star Hotel
Features a Cuban-inspired theme with vibrant decor and a lively atmosphere. It offers a large pool with a swim-up bar, on-site dining, and comfortable rooms. The hotel provides a unique and festive experience.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHavana Cabana at Key West is widely recognized as a solid four-star hotel offering a true four-star experience. Guests appreciate the nice amenities and the overall quality of the property. The hotel is described as very fine, absolutely worthy of its four-star rating. However, some reviews mention management issues and noise factors as drawbacks, affecting the perceived value for money. Despite these concerns, the majority of reviews emphasize the positive aspects of the hotel, affirming it as a good four-star option. The hotel is pricier compared to other similar standards, which has led to some negative feelings regarding its value. Nevertheless, the general sentiment leans towards it being a well-regarded resort in the four-star category.
Show more
 
DoubleTree by Hilton Grand Key Resort
Resort in Key West FL
7.5
Good
From $191
From $191
4-Star Resort
Offers a tranquil location away from the downtown crowds, with a tropical ambiance. It features a large pool, on-site dining, and comfortable rooms with modern amenities. The resort provides a relaxing and convenient stay.
Show more
 
Beachside Resort & Residences
Resort in Key West FL
8.0
Very Good
From $215
From $215
4-Star Resort
This resort offers both rooms and residences, providing flexibility for different travelers. Its beachfront location and amenities contribute to a relaxing vacation.
Show more
 
8.9
Excellent
From $219
From $219
4-Star Hotel
As part of the Autograph Collection, this adult-only hotel offers a unique and upscale experience. Its focus on adults ensures a peaceful and sophisticated stay.
Show more
 
La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Resort in Key West FL
8.2
Very Good
From $269
From $269
4-Star Resort
This hotel, part of the Autograph Collection, offers a historic and stylish experience. Its location on Duval Street and unique amenities make it a standout choice.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryLa Concha Key West, Autograph Collection receives mixed reviews with some guests saying that the room was in poor condition despite its four-star rating and suggesting an inspection to validate the hotel's classification. However, many guests raved about their positive experience with some describing it as superb. The hotel's facilities and services were generally viewed as good or very good with some guests finding the hotel a little too expensive for them. The location was highly praised, being close to everything and yet offering a quiet and comfortable stay. Overall, guests would recommend this hotel and are willing to stay again despite some reservations about its price.
Show more
 
Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages
Inn in Key West FL
9.2
Excellent
From $196
From $196
4-Star Inn
This historic inn offers charming cottages and a tranquil atmosphere. Its unique character and amenities provide a relaxing and memorable stay.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categorySimonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages, a charming four-star property, boasts luxurious amenities that make it an ideal destination for a few days' retreat. Despite some concerns regarding value for money, the hotel delivers an overall superb experience, attracting guests with its comfortable and intimate environment. Visitors often express a desire to return with many highly recommending this small yet well-appointed hotel for its exceptional setting and inviting atmosphere.
Show more
 
Oceans Edge Key West
Resort in Key West FL
8.5
Very Good
From $207
From $207
4-Star Resort
This resort provides waterfront accommodations and a range of amenities. Its oceanfront location and services make it a desirable option.
Show more
 
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West
Hotel in Key West FL
8.0
Very Good
From $188
From $188
4-Star Hotel
This resort provides comfortable accommodations and a range of amenities. Its design and services make it a relaxing option.
Show more
 
The Capitana Key West
Hotel in Key West FL
9.0
Excellent
From $285
From $285
4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Capitana Key West hotel receives high marks for its stylish and modern design, leaving many pleasantly surprised by the impeccable decor and cleanliness. The hotel stands out as an excellent and high-quality four-star establishment, boasting newly updated facilities and a beautiful complex that contributes to an ideal holiday experience. Guests appreciate the reliable quality of the rooms and pool, which are consistently in line with four-star standards.

While some reviews point to shortcomings in breakfast options and staff service, many still find the hotel to be one of the better options with four-star amenities and services that contribute to a top-notch stay. The location is also a highlight, often making up for any perceived deficiencies. Overall, The Capitana Key West offers a luxurious experience with recent renovations enhancing its appeal, though some aspects may not always meet all four-star expectations.
Show more
 
Winslow's Bungalows - Key West Historic Inns
Inn in Key West FL
8.7
Very Good
From $228
From $228
4-Star Inn
This historic inn offers charming bungalows and a tranquil atmosphere. Its unique character and amenities provide a relaxing and memorable stay.
Show more
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryWinslow's Bungalows - Key West Historic Inns offers a pleasant stay, marked by its cleanliness, maintenance and elegant ambiance. The high standards of the property and its luxurious accommodations bring to mind the feel of more prestigious brands like Four Seasons. Guests have praised the excellent service, noting the exceptional and happy staff who contribute to a welcoming environment. The continental breakfast is a step above the typical offering and some guests appreciated the made-to-order options available.

Rooms at Winslow's Bungalows are described as hyper comfortable, spacious and up to high-class standards. The amenities provided are lovely, enhancing the overall experience at the hotel. However, there was some feedback indicating that the property didn't quite meet the expectations commonly associated with a four-star establishment, particularly in relation to the breakfast and overall value for the cost. Despite these critiques, many reviews emphasized the exceptional qualities of the property, describing it as fantastic, absolutely lovely and well worth the stay for those seeking a nice, clean and top-notch experience in Key West.
Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in Key West.
Categories:
  •     4 Star (39)
  •     Pool (35)
  •     Outdoor Pool (32)
  •     Parking (29)
  •     Luxury (26)
  •     Beach (23)
  •     Honeymoon (22)
  •     Romantic (21)
  •     Accessible (20)
  •     Gym (19)
  •     Business (19)
  •     Family (17)
  •     Heated Pool (17)
  •     Dog Friendly (15)
  •     EV charging stations (14)
  •     Nightlife (13)
  •     Golf (11)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (10)
  •     Sustainability Journey (9)
  •     Small (9)
  •     Spa (8)
  •     Beachfront (8)
  •     Adult Only (7)
  •     Cheap (7)
  •     Yoga (6)
  •     Boutique-Style (5)
  •     Indoor Pool (2)
  •     Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub (1)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Dog Play Area (1)
  •     Tennis (1)
  •     Health & Safety (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ