7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
5-Star Hotels in Montclair
76 HOTELS IN AND AROUND MONTCLAIRRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
$
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
WestHouse Hotel New York, an SLH Hotel appears to fall short of the five-star expectations set by its rating. Many guests pointed out that the hotel does not meet the standards and quality typically associated with a five-star establishment. Criticisms were particularly aimed at the rooms and overall service, which were frequently described as not up to par for a hotel with a five-star designation.
While some reviews did mention excellent location and five-star service, these positives were overshadowed by issues of cleanliness, service inconsistency and the lack of amenities expected at this level. Guests noted that the hotel could be more accurately described as a four-star establishment with several reviewers emphasizing that it does not deserve its five-star label.
Additionally, some guests highlighted the disparity between the hotel's online presentation and the actual experience, indicating that the pictures found online were overrated. Issues such as overcharging for late arrivals despite prior notice and below-par breakfast offerings also contributed to the sentiment that the hotel lacked true five-star qualities.
Overall, while WestHouse Hotel New York, an SLH Hotel does have some commendable aspects, many guests feel disappointed with the discrepancy between its advertised high standards and the actual experience, suggesting that it’s more of a four-star hotel.
While some reviews did mention excellent location and five-star service, these positives were overshadowed by issues of cleanliness, service inconsistency and the lack of amenities expected at this level. Guests noted that the hotel could be more accurately described as a four-star establishment with several reviewers emphasizing that it does not deserve its five-star label.
Additionally, some guests highlighted the disparity between the hotel's online presentation and the actual experience, indicating that the pictures found online were overrated. Issues such as overcharging for late arrivals despite prior notice and below-par breakfast offerings also contributed to the sentiment that the hotel lacked true five-star qualities.
Overall, while WestHouse Hotel New York, an SLH Hotel does have some commendable aspects, many guests feel disappointed with the discrepancy between its advertised high standards and the actual experience, suggesting that it’s more of a four-star hotel.
$
+4
Info
Categories
5 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Accessible
$
+7
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
The Refinery Hotel - New York is highly regarded for its prime Midtown location, making it an ideal base for exploring Manhattan. Guests appreciate the proximity to major attractions like Bryant Park, Times Square and Grand Central Station. Despite being centrally located, the hotel offers a peaceful retreat from the city's hustle and bustle.
Guests find the hotel’s breakfast served in a pub-style restaurant to be tasty and of high quality with a particularly good brunch menu. Complimentary morning coffee is a welcomed touch, although some suggest that the breakfast selection could be more varied and offer better value.
The spacious, stylish rooms at the Refinery Hotel receive praise for their cleanliness, comfort and historic character. High ceilings, luxurious decor and large comfortable beds contribute to a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The bathrooms are also noted for their exceptional quality. Despite minor complaints about storage and the absence of in-room coffee machines, the overall room experience exceeds expectations.
Cleanliness is a strong point with rooms often cleaned twice daily. While isolated lapses in housekeeping are occasionally mentioned, the general consensus is that the hotel maintains a high standard of tidiness and comfort.
The staff at the Refinery Hotel are frequently lauded for their exceptional service. Guests find the team to be incredibly friendly, attentive and helpful, enhancing the overall guest experience. Specific employees often receive shout-outs for going above and beyond.
The hotel's nightlife scene is bolstered by its standout rooftop bar, renowned for live jazz and soul music, a pleasant ambiance with a fireplace and DJ services. This venue is especially popular for its romantic atmosphere. Other dining establishments in the hotel also receive high marks, adding to a vibrant nightlife experience.
The beds at the Refinery Hotel are widely praised for their comfort with excellent quality linens and a range of bed sizes, though the majority find them conducive to a good night’s sleep.
Overall, the Refinery Hotel offers a blend of style, comfort, excellent service and a prime location, making it a standout option for visitors looking to experience the best of New York City.
Guests find the hotel’s breakfast served in a pub-style restaurant to be tasty and of high quality with a particularly good brunch menu. Complimentary morning coffee is a welcomed touch, although some suggest that the breakfast selection could be more varied and offer better value.
The spacious, stylish rooms at the Refinery Hotel receive praise for their cleanliness, comfort and historic character. High ceilings, luxurious decor and large comfortable beds contribute to a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The bathrooms are also noted for their exceptional quality. Despite minor complaints about storage and the absence of in-room coffee machines, the overall room experience exceeds expectations.
Cleanliness is a strong point with rooms often cleaned twice daily. While isolated lapses in housekeeping are occasionally mentioned, the general consensus is that the hotel maintains a high standard of tidiness and comfort.
The staff at the Refinery Hotel are frequently lauded for their exceptional service. Guests find the team to be incredibly friendly, attentive and helpful, enhancing the overall guest experience. Specific employees often receive shout-outs for going above and beyond.
The hotel's nightlife scene is bolstered by its standout rooftop bar, renowned for live jazz and soul music, a pleasant ambiance with a fireplace and DJ services. This venue is especially popular for its romantic atmosphere. Other dining establishments in the hotel also receive high marks, adding to a vibrant nightlife experience.
The beds at the Refinery Hotel are widely praised for their comfort with excellent quality linens and a range of bed sizes, though the majority find them conducive to a good night’s sleep.
Overall, the Refinery Hotel offers a blend of style, comfort, excellent service and a prime location, making it a standout option for visitors looking to experience the best of New York City.
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Historic
The London, a Luxury Collection Hotel, New York City12.8 mi from Montclair
Hotel in New York NY
8.0
Very GoodFrom $708
$
+9
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
The London, a Luxury Collection Hotel, New York City has garnered enthusiastic praise from its guests for its exceptional quality and luxurious accommodations. Visitors have been particularly impressed by the spacious rooms, elegant furnishings, and the sense of opulence that enhances their stay. The hotel staff are frequently lauded for their friendliness and promptness, contributing to a level of service that many describe as worthy of a five-star rating. Numerous guests express satisfaction with their decision to stay at the hotel, noting that their experience surpasses their expectations. Despite some comments suggesting a mid-tier service experience, the overall consensus remains highly positive, with the hotel being considered one of the best options in New York City for those seeking a luxurious retreat.
$
+6
5 Star
AI-generatedPark Hyatt New York offers contemporary luxury and sophisticated design in Midtown. Its spacious rooms, exceptional spa, and prime location near Central Park and Fifth Avenue make it a top choice for discerning travelers.
$
+8
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
The JW Marriott Essex House New York is a top-notch hotel that offers excellent service and a prime location. Guests consistently praised the staff for their friendliness, professionalism and attention to detail with many highlighting the exceptional concierge services. The breakfast was delicious and served by helpful staff and the large rooms were comfortable and well-appointed. The hotel's staff went above and beyond to ensure guests' comfort and satisfaction, even in celebrating special occasions. While a few guests had minor complaints, the vast majority of guests had an exceptional experience and highly recommend the hotel. Overall, the JW Marriott Essex House New York is an excellent choice for travelers seeking a memorable stay in New York City.
Categories
5 Star
Historic
Spa
$
+13
Info
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel12.9 mi from Montclair
Hotel in New York NY
8.5
Very GoodFrom $334
$
+3
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
The The Iroquois Times Square, a Small Luxury Hotel, nestled in a prime location, draws mixed reactions regarding its status as a luxury accommodation. While some reviewers confidently label it as one of the best hotels in NYC, others question its five-star classification. The common consensus is that the hotel's location and staff service are exceptional, with many guests praising it as a warm, welcoming establishment staffed by kind professionals. The hotel's ambiance, described as comfortable and peaceful, enhances the overall guest experience.
However, there are notable shortcomings, particularly concerning the breakfast offerings, which many find inadequate for a hotel of its purported five-star caliber. Criticisms include limited options, pre-made meals lacking freshness, and a dining area that doesn’t quite meet expectations. The rooms, though clean and equipped with good amenities, are perceived as small for a luxury establishment and contribute to the debate surrounding the hotel’s star rating.
Despite these drawbacks, a significant number of guests express intent to return, highlighting the strength of its location and overall service as compelling reasons to stay at the Iroquois again. While it may not universally be regarded a five-star hotel by its guests, it remains a favored choice for those seeking a cozy and well-situated New York City stay.
However, there are notable shortcomings, particularly concerning the breakfast offerings, which many find inadequate for a hotel of its purported five-star caliber. Criticisms include limited options, pre-made meals lacking freshness, and a dining area that doesn’t quite meet expectations. The rooms, though clean and equipped with good amenities, are perceived as small for a luxury establishment and contribute to the debate surrounding the hotel’s star rating.
Despite these drawbacks, a significant number of guests express intent to return, highlighting the strength of its location and overall service as compelling reasons to stay at the Iroquois again. While it may not universally be regarded a five-star hotel by its guests, it remains a favored choice for those seeking a cozy and well-situated New York City stay.
$
+8
Info
Just few blocks away from Central Park, MOMA, Carnegie Hall, Broadway theaters and Fifth Avenue’s famous shops, this hotel is the perfect place if you want to experience everything New York has to offer. All rooms are over 300 sq.ft, whereas the suites offer a variety of options to suit your needs, such as separate living room with queen-size sofa bed, dining area and kitchenettes.
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Thompson Central Park - New York is a highly recommended hotel for anyone looking for a mid-town stay in New York. The hotel's exceptional location makes it easy for guests to explore the city on foot with easy access to Central Park, Times Square, Broadway and other attractions. The hotel offers a variety of breakfast options to suit different preferences and the rooms are clean, spacious and well-maintained with modern facilities and classy interiors. The staff is exceptional with friendly and helpful service throughout the stay. While there were a few minor issues with housekeeping and breakfast quality, the overall experience at Thompson Central Park is highly positive with many guests praising the hotel's superb location, exceptional staff and comfortable rooms.
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Family
$
+8
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Le Meridien New York, Central Park, presents a mixed bag of experiences for its guests. The hotel's standout feature is undoubtedly its prime location, just a block from Central Park and conveniently close to a subway station, making it ideal for shopping and exploring the city. Guests appreciate the nice rooms and the restaurant, which receives praise for its excellent food and impeccable five-star service.
However, the hotel falls short of delivering a consistent five-star experience. Several guests mention that the service and facilities need improvement, suggesting that it does not meet the expected standards of even a four-star hotel. While the staff and overall service receive high marks for excellence, the absence of amenities like a pool and the sense of the hotel requiring a facelift contribute to a perception that it does not live up to its advertised star rating.
However, the hotel falls short of delivering a consistent five-star experience. Several guests mention that the service and facilities need improvement, suggesting that it does not meet the expected standards of even a four-star hotel. While the staff and overall service receive high marks for excellence, the absence of amenities like a pool and the sense of the hotel requiring a facelift contribute to a perception that it does not live up to its advertised star rating.
$
+5
Info
Categories
5 Star
Family
Dog Friendly
From $1,094
$
+5
5 Star
AI-generatedLocated in TriBeCa, the Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown provides a luxurious and modern experience. Its sleek design, exceptional dining, and proximity to downtown attractions make it ideal for both business and leisure travelers.
$
+2
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
The Evelyn NoMad enjoys an excellent location with wonderfully friendly and professional staff, garnering praise for their personalized service. While some guests were delighted by the superb and spacious suites and found the hotel to fully meet their expectations, many expressed disappointment regarding its five-star rating.
Several reviews pointed out that aspects such as the grab-and-go breakfast and room cleaning services did not live up to the standards traditionally associated with a five-star establishment. The hotel appears to be more suitable for business travelers rather than those seeking a luxury experience. There is a consensus among some guests that The Evelyn NoMad, despite being listed and rated as a five-star hotel, aligns closer to a four-star or even a good quality three-star accommodation by European standards.
The frequent mention of the hotel's failure to meet a five-star experience highlights a significant gap between expectations and reality. Consequently, there is an evidently repeated call for the property's rating to be reevaluated to more accurately reflect the level of service and amenities offered.
Several reviews pointed out that aspects such as the grab-and-go breakfast and room cleaning services did not live up to the standards traditionally associated with a five-star establishment. The hotel appears to be more suitable for business travelers rather than those seeking a luxury experience. There is a consensus among some guests that The Evelyn NoMad, despite being listed and rated as a five-star hotel, aligns closer to a four-star or even a good quality three-star accommodation by European standards.
The frequent mention of the hotel's failure to meet a five-star experience highlights a significant gap between expectations and reality. Consequently, there is an evidently repeated call for the property's rating to be reevaluated to more accurately reflect the level of service and amenities offered.
$
+3
5 Star
AI-generatedThe Langham offers contemporary luxury and exceptional service on Fifth Avenue. Its spacious rooms, Michelin-starred restaurant, and central location make it a top choice for discerning travelers.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
If you're looking for luxurious service during your stay in New York City, The Langham on Fifth Avenue should be at the top of your list. Guests have praised the 5-star hotel for its exceptional service and facilities, making it one of their favorite hotels in the city. With elegant rooms and breathtaking views over NYC, it's the perfect place to stay for a NYC getaway. The friendly staff and impeccable cleanliness have left guests feeling like the hotel is absolute perfection and they can't wait to return. Though some have noted minor flaws, overall, The Langham has been deemed one of the best hotels in New York City by its guests. Its classic yet modern style elevates the hotel to a class of its own and its prime location makes it a top recommendation for anyone's first trip to NYC. Though the prices may be high, guests say it's well worth it for the exceptional service and overall experience.
$
+12
Info
Categories
5 Star
Nightlife
Luxury
$
+4
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
1 Hotel Central Park offers a distinctive blend of eco-friendly luxury and exceptional service, creating a memorable stay in the heart of New York City. The spacious and calming rooms serve as a tranquil oasis amidst the city's bustle, providing guests with a feeling of relaxation and comfort. Many visitors describe their time here as one of the best stays they've had in New York, with everything about the hotel delivering an exceptional experience. Guests commend the property for its excellent service, noting the staff's attention to detail and unbeatable treatment. The on-site restaurant and bar, coupled with the hotel's commitment to sustainability, further enhance the overall experience, making it a worthwhile choice for visitors seeking both luxury and environmental consciousness. Despite some contrasting opinions regarding its five-star status, numerous guests vow to return, indicating that a stay here is certainly worth considering.
$
+8
5 Star
AI-generatedLocated in the Flatiron District, this hotel offers stylish accommodations and a sophisticated atmosphere. It is known for its minimalist design, exceptional service, and a prime location near Madison Square Park.
From $1,503
$
+6
5 Star
AI-generatedOverlooking Central Park, this hotel offers luxurious accommodations and unparalleled service. Its prime location provides easy access to the park's attractions, and the hotel itself is synonymous with elegance and sophistication.
From $1,453
$
+5
5 Star
AI-generatedThe Baccarat Hotel is a dazzling display of modern luxury and crystal artistry. Its shimmering interiors, lavish rooms, and exceptional dining experiences create a glamorous and sophisticated atmosphere, perfect for those seeking a unique and opulent stay.
$
5 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Park Lane New York receives mixed reviews about its five-star rating, facilities and services. Some guests appreciate the ideal location and iconic views, describing their experience as perfect, excellent and superb. Others highlight good amenities and great service, feeling it provides a true five-star experience.
However, several reviewers mention that the hotel does not live up to its five-star classification. Complaints include old and noisy rooms, missing simple amenities like coffee makers and services only available upon request at an additional cost. Some guests felt that the quality of the furnishings and the overall service were not up to five-star standards, describing the hotel as more akin to a four-star establishment or even less.
This mix of positive and negative feedback denotes that while some guests are delighted with their stay, others feel the hotel's offerings do not justify its five-star rating and price.
However, several reviewers mention that the hotel does not live up to its five-star classification. Complaints include old and noisy rooms, missing simple amenities like coffee makers and services only available upon request at an additional cost. Some guests felt that the quality of the furnishings and the overall service were not up to five-star standards, describing the hotel as more akin to a four-star establishment or even less.
This mix of positive and negative feedback denotes that while some guests are delighted with their stay, others feel the hotel's offerings do not justify its five-star rating and price.
Categories
1
Map