The Pridwin Hotel
Hotel in Shelter Island NY
9.0
Excellent
From $359
From $359
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Hotel
Hotel near Golf Courses
Show more
 
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island NY
9.9
Excellent
From $430
From $430
Info Categories
Luxury Bed & Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool
Bed & Breakfast for Yoga

Show more
 
21 more hotels nearby!
Shelter Island House 0.6 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Shelter Island Heights NY
4.0
Rated
From $225
From $225
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel for Honeymoon

Show more
 
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast 2.2 mi from Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in Greenport NY
8.8
Excellent
From $368
From $368
Info Categories
Luxury Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Baron's Cove 5.8 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Sag Harbor NY
8.5
Very Good
From $247
From $247
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
Topping Rose House 9.5 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Bridgehampton NY
7.9
Good
From $553
From $553
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Boutique-style Hotel

Show more
 
A Room at The Beach 9.6 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Bridgehampton NY
8.1
Very Good
From $457
From $457
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Outdoor Pool  

Luxury Hotel
Hotel for Honeymoon
Show more
 
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast 10.9 mi from Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast in East Hampton NY
9.7
Excellent
From $464
From $464
Info Categories
Bed & Breakfast with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Indoor Pool    Children's Pool  

Heated Pool    Indoor Pool    Children's Pool  

Luxury Bed & Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast with Free Wi-Fi
Show more
 
Southampton Inn 12.6 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Southampton NY
8.4
Very Good
From $198
From $198
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Hotel near Golf Courses
Show more
 
Villa Romina 12.6 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Southampton NY
From $2,331
From $2,331
Info Categories
Luxury Villas
Villas with Swimming Pool
Dog Friendly Villas
Show more
 
Journey East Hampton 12.7 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in East Hampton NY
7.9
Good
From $229
From $229
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Hotel for Honeymoon
Show more
 
Villa Isaiah 13.3 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Southampton NY
Info Categories
Luxury Villas
Villas with Swimming Pool
Dog Friendly Villas
Show more
 
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina 15.0 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Old Saybrook CT
9.0
Excellent
From $340
From $340
Info Categories
Hotel with Swimming Pool
Luxury Hotel
Hotel with Spa

Show more
 
The Hermitage 18.0 mi from Shelter Island
Accommodation in Amagansett NY
8.7
Very Good
From $197
From $197
Info Categories
Luxury Accommodation

Accommodation with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Accommodation near The Beach

Show more
 
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 19.9 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
8.0
Very Good
From $454
From $454
Info Categories
Luxury Resort

Resort with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Parking

EV charging stations  

Show more
 
Hero Beach Club 21.8 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
8.3
Very Good
From $260
From $260
Info Categories
Luxury Resort

Resort with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Boutique-style Resort

Show more
 
Montauk Manor 21.9 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.7
Very Good
From $173
From $173
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Rooms With Fireplace

Show more
 
The Montauk Soundview 22.2 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.0
Very Good
From $294
From $294
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Parking

Show more
 
Haven Montauk 22.2 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.6
Very Good
From $134
From $134
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel near Golf Courses

Show more
 
The Montauk Beach House 22.2 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.3
Very Good
From $285
From $285
Info Categories
Luxury Hotel

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel where Extra Health & Safety Measures Have Been Taken

Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
Categories:
  •     Luxury (23)
  •     Pool (23)
  •     Outdoor Pool (20)
  •     Heated Pool (9)
  •     Indoor Pool (6)
  •     Private Pool (2)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (1)
  •     Children's Pool (1)
  •     Parking (18)
  •     Family (12)
  •     Honeymoon (10)
  •     Accessible (10)
  •     Dog Friendly (10)
  •     Romantic (8)
  •     Golf (8)
  •     Small (7)
  •     Business (7)
  •     Spa (7)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (7)
  •     Gym (7)
  •     Sustainability Journey (6)
  •     Tennis (5)
  •     Yoga (5)
  •     Beach (5)
  •     4 Star (5)
  •     5 Star (5)
  •     Boutique-Style (4)
  •     EV charging stations (3)
  •     Beachfront (3)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (2)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Vineyard (1)
  •     Health & Safety (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
2
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ