Rosemorran Retreat 6.0 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
10
Excellent
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Villa Lavender 6.3 mi from Shelter Island
Accommodation in Noyack NY
From $4,963
From $4,963
Info Categories
Accommodation with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Accommodation

Show more
 
Seashell Collector Estate 6.3 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Villa Kimaal - Luxury with pool 6.5 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Sag Harbor Beauty 6.5 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Villa Zainip - Luxury with pool 6.5 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Private Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Solara Resort 1564 6.5 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Cutchogue NY
From $338
From $338
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Cottage in the Hamptons 6.5 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
5.5
Rated
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

4-Star Vacation Home

Show more
 
Colonial Gem Near the Bay 6.6 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Villa Gosculo - Luxury with pool 6.7 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Southampton Chic 6.8 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Southampton NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Villa Charlotte 6.8 mi from Shelter Island
Cottage in Noyack NY
Info Categories
Cottage with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Cottage with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Hamptons Home w/Solar-Heated Pool-Walk to Beach! 6.8 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Villa KeyLime 6.8 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Sag Harbor NY
From $662
From $662
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool    Private Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Bayview Beauty 6.8 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Southampton NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Wonderful 6 Bedroom Home At Hamptons 6.9 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Noyack NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Family Friendly Vacation Home

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Show more
 
Villa Azeeka - Luxury with pool 7.0 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Water Mill NY
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Private Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Villa Red Hut 7.0 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Water Mill NY
From $2,579
From $2,579
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Private Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
Deerfield Dream House 7.1 mi from Shelter Island
Vacation Home in Sag Harbor NY
Info Categories
Vacation Home with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Vacation Home with Free Wi-Fi

Vacation Home with Parking

Show more
 
Villa Admore - Luxury with pool 7.1 mi from Shelter Island
Villas in Water Mill NY
Info Categories
Villas with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Dog Friendly Villas

Villas with Parking

Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
View all hotels in Shelter Island.
Categories:
  •     Pool (459)
  •     Outdoor Pool (401)
  •     Heated Pool (68)
  •     Private Pool (50)
  •     Indoor Pool (28)
  •     Pool Lap Lanes (2)
  •     Children's Pool (1)
  •     Parking (357)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (266)
  •     Dog Friendly (161)
  •     4 Star (90)
  •     Family (69)
  •     3 Star (52)
  •     Beach (45)
  •     Golf (44)
  •     Accessible (39)
  •     Honeymoon (37)
  •     Gym (30)
  •     Small (28)
  •     Luxury (23)
  •     Business (22)
  •     Tennis (18)
  •     Spa (13)
  •     EV charging stations (13)
  •     Sustainability Journey (13)
  •     Beachfront (12)
  •     Yoga (10)
  •     Romantic (8)
  •     Adult Only (5)
  •     5 Star (5)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (4)
  •     Boutique-Style (4)
  •     Vineyard (3)
  •     Historic (1)
  •     Health & Safety (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
1
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ