Baron's Cove 5.8 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Sag Harbor NY
8.5
Very Good
From $281
From $281
Info Categories
Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
EHP Resort & Marina 10.3 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in East Hampton NY
8.5
Very Good
From $550
From $550
Info Categories
Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
East Hampton House Resort 12.4 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in East Hampton NY
8.6
Very Good
From $222
From $222
Info Categories
Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Water's Edge Resort & Spa 15.2 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Westbrook CT
8.5
Very Good
From $271
From $271
Info Categories
Resort with Swimming Pool

Indoor Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort for Honeymoon

Resort with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Windward Shores Ocean Resort 17.7 mi from Shelter Island
Aparthotel in Amagansett NY
Info Categories
Aparthotel for Honeymoon

Aparthotel with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Aparthotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Windward Shores 17.8 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Amagansett NY
8.4
Very Good
From $185
From $185
Info Categories
Resort for Honeymoon

Resort with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Sea Crest 18.2 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Amagansett NY
8.7
Very Good
From $214
From $214
Info Categories
Resort for Honeymoon

Resort with Swimming Pool

Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk 21.4 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.5
Very Good
From $218
From $218
Info Categories
Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
Montauk Manor 21.9 mi from Shelter Island
Hotel in Montauk NY
8.7
Very Good
From $184
From $184
Info Categories
Hotel for Honeymoon

Hotel with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Hotel with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
The Surf Club Resort 22.5 mi from Shelter Island
Resort in Montauk NY
5.0
Rated
From $271
From $271
Info Categories
Resort for Honeymoon

Resort with Swimming Pool

Heated Pool    Outdoor Pool  

Resort with Tennis Courts

Show more
 
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.
Categories:
  •     Honeymoon (10)
  •     Tennis (10)
  •     Pool (10)
  •     Outdoor Pool (10)
  •     Heated Pool (5)
  •     Indoor Pool (1)
  •     Parking (9)
  •     Family (9)
  •     Gym (7)
  •     3 Star (5)
  •     Beach (4)
  •     Accessible (4)
  •     Golf (4)
  •     Free Wi-Fi (4)
  •     Business (4)
  •     Spa (3)
  •     Beachfront (3)
  •     Luxury (2)
  •     Rooms with Fireplace (2)
  •     EV charging stations (2)
  •     Romantic (2)
  •     Small (2)
  •     Yoga (2)
  •     4 Star (1)
  •     5 Star (1)
  •     Sustainability Journey (1)
×
Checkin
×
Categories
3
Map
× Home About Press Categories Blog Hotel Awards Travelmyth GPT Contact Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookies Policy FAQ