Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

5-Star Hotels in Bethpage

43 HOTELS IN AND AROUND BETHPAGERanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
20 hotels nearby!
The Vanderbilt Hotel Suites main photo
The Vanderbilt Hotel Suites
5.0 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Westbury NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $337
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Parking
EV charging stations
Luxury
Garden City Hotel main photo
Garden City Hotel
7.2 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Garden City NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $300
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Garden City Hotel receives high praise from guests for various aspects of its service and amenities, creating a compelling choice for visitors to Long Island. Its prime location in the charming area of Garden City offers convenient access to local shops, restaurants, and Adelphi University, making it an ideal option for both leisure and business travelers. The proximity to the Long Island Railroad and JFK Airport further enhances its appeal, providing seamless connectivity to New York City and broader travel needs. Leisure features such as a nearby golf course add to the attraction for guests seeking relaxation and recreation.

The breakfast experience at the hotel is consistently lauded, with guests appreciating the diverse and delicious offerings of the buffet. Even though some find the cost high, the quality and variety of food ensure that guests start their day on a satisfying note. Accommodations at the Garden City Hotel are spacious, luxurious, and remarkably clean, reinforcing a sense of comfort and relaxation. The hotel's grounds complement the well-equipped rooms, adding to an overall positive environment that guests enjoy.

Cleanliness is a notable strength of the hotel, with rooms and common areas maintained to impeccable standards, contributing significantly to guest comfort. This high level of cleanliness, paired with the hotel’s convenient location, presents an attractive option for those seeking a blend of accessibility and tranquility.

The hotel staff plays a crucial role in enhancing the guest experience, earning accolades for their warmth, attentiveness, and exceptional service. Individuals like Anthony Lambert and Maria receive special mention for their outstanding efforts, and the team overall is recognized for their ability to manage high-pressure events, such as weddings, with professionalism and enthusiasm. The staff’s dedication to hospitality creates a welcoming atmosphere that guests deeply appreciate, making the Garden City Hotel not just a place to stay, but a memorable experience.
Categories
5 Star
Golf
Historic
Hyatt Regency Long Island main photo
Hyatt Regency Long Island
18.1 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Hauppauge NYUS flag
7.8
Good
From $175
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Hyatt Regency Long Island consistently earns praise for its strategic and convenient location, which offers visitors a peaceful, accessible base from which to explore the broader region. Guests particularly appreciate the hotel's beautiful views, easy access to local amenities, and well-maintained facilities, such as ample parking and clean, inviting spaces.

Breakfast at the hotel is widely appreciated for its variety and quality, featuring a buffet spread that includes pastries, fruits, cheeses, and more. Despite some comments on the high cost, the offering is generally well-received, with friendly staff enhancing the dining experience.

The spacious, well-appointed rooms are highlighted for their cleanliness and comfort, with guests expressing satisfaction over the inviting atmosphere and the superb service from housekeeping staff. Beds receive special acclaim for their comfort, although some minor updates to the rooms could improve guest experiences further.

The hotel staff, from front desk to cleaning personnel, are celebrated for their exceptional service and professionalism, with particular mentions of individuals going above and beyond to ensure a smooth and welcoming stay. This high level of customer service significantly contributes to the hotel's positive reputation.

The pool facilities at Hyatt Regency Long Island add to the appeal, offering a relaxing and enjoyable experience with both indoor and outdoor options. The pools are particularly noted for their pleasant conditions and ambiance, making them a favorite feature among visitors, including families with children.

Families visiting the hotel find it accommodating and friendly, highlighting its suitability for trips with children due to its welcoming atmosphere and convenient amenities. Despite some room configuration challenges for larger families, the hotel's responsiveness to requests, like extra beds, enhances its family-oriented appeal.

Overall, the Hyatt Regency Long Island provides a memorable and satisfying experience with its combination of strategic location, excellent service, comfortable accommodations, and appealing amenities.
Categories
5 Star
Golf
Family
Delamar Greenwich Harbor main photo
Delamar Greenwich Harbor
19.8 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Greenwich CTUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $485
$
5 Star
Located in Greenwich, this hotel offers luxurious rooms with city or harbor views, marble vanities in the bathrooms and high-end amenities. It stands out for its exceptional service and prime waterfront location.
Nova Hotel Brooklyn main photo
Nova Hotel Brooklyn
22.6 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Brooklyn NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Small
Reservation Homes Manhattan main photo
Reservation Homes Manhattan
23.4 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Small
The William Vale main photo
The William Vale
23.7 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Brooklyn NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $386
$
5 Star
Located in Williamsburg, this hotel features a 60-feet rooftop swimming pool and dining options overseen by an award-winning chef. It offers a dynamic blend of indoor and outdoor experiences embodying Brooklyn's creative spirit. The hotel has sleek, futuristic interiors and floor-to-ceiling windows.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The William Vale is an incredible luxury hotel, perfect for its location and stunning views. Guests consistently rate it as exceptional and a fabulous place to stay. The staff is extremely professional and gracious and the property is truly five-star quality. The balcony is a favorite feature and guests highly recommend the hotel, despite some mixed reviews about facilities and service not always matching up to five-star standards. Overall, The William Vale is a magnificent hotel that provides a comfortable and unforgettable stay in the heart of Brooklyn.
Stylish Brooklyn Retreat - Steps to G Train main photo
Stylish Brooklyn Retreat - Steps to G Train
23.7 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in Brooklyn NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Family
Free Wi-Fi
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel main photo
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
24.0 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $851
$
5 Star
Located on the Upper East Side, a block from Central Park, this hotel offers guests an elegant and sophisticated experience. It is known for its classic New York spots like Bemelmans Bar and Cafe Carlyle, providing guests with exclusive dining and entertainment options.
Cambria Hotel White Plains - Downtown main photo
Cambria Hotel White Plains - Downtown
24.0 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in White Plains NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $242
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Honeymoon
Luxury
The Mark New York main photo
The Mark New York
24.0 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $1,004
$
5 Star
The Mark combines avant-garde design with exceptional amenities and personalized service. Located in the heart of the Upper East Side, it's known for its stylish rooms, a Frederic Fekkai salon, and a Bergdorf Goodman express store, catering to a fashion-forward clientele.
The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel main photo
The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel
24.0 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $1,289
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
The Opus Westchester, Autograph Collection main photo
The Opus Westchester, Autograph Collection
24.1 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in White Plains NYUS flag
8.1
Very Good
From $373
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Family
Dog Friendly
The West Tower at ONE UN Plaza - Millennium Hotels and Resorts main photo
The West Tower at ONE UN Plaza - Millennium Hotels and Resorts
24.2 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
The hotel offers spectacular New York City accommodations and panoramic views. Set across from the United Nations Headquarters adjacent to the East River, the hotel’s location is ideal if you want to visit some of the Manhattan icons, such as the Empire State building, Grand Central Terminal and the theater district.
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Family
Hôtel Plaza Athénée main photo
Hôtel Plaza Athénée
24.2 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $195
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
Loews Regency New York Hotel main photo
Loews Regency New York Hotel
24.3 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.2
Very Good
From $558
$
Info
On famous Park Avenue, this modern hotel is just 2 blocks away from Central Park, featuring dining and 24-hour concierge services.
Summary of reviews
The Loews Regency New York Hotel is a top-notch hotel with exceptional staff who provide outstanding service. The front desk staff, particularly Ella and Kathleen, were praised for their professionalism and welcoming demeanor. The bell staff were also commended for their helpfulness and kindness. Guests felt well-cared for and special throughout their stay with the staff going above and beyond to ensure their comfort. While one guest noted some noise disturbance due to construction work, the majority of guests had a wonderful experience and highly recommend this hotel.
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
Lowell Hotel main photo
Lowell Hotel
24.3 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $865
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
Fasano Fifth Avenue I Private Members Club & Hotel main photo
Fasano Fifth Avenue I Private Members Club & Hotel
24.4 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
5 Star
Family
Free Wi-Fi
The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York main photo
The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
24.4 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $613
$
5 Star
Located on Fifth Avenue, The Pierre offers classic elegance and exceptional service with a touch of Indian hospitality. Its luxurious rooms, stunning views, and refined ambiance create a sophisticated and memorable experience.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The Pierre, A Taj Hotel in New York is an exceptional 5-star hotel that will make you feel like royalty. The staff, including Crystal and Dennis, are amazingly helpful and the location is priceless. With a glamorous old world feel, this hotel is perfect for a fantastic stay in the heart of Manhattan. Although some reviewers noted that the rooms are small, the overall experience is described as superb and true five-star quality. The Pierre Hotel is a brilliant choice for those seeking an oasis in the city and a chic and perfect stay. Guests leaving enthusiastic reviews say that they will definitely come back to this hotel.
Four Seasons Hotel New York main photo
Four Seasons Hotel New York
24.4 mi from Bethpage
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
From $1,097
$
5 Star
The Four Seasons on 57th Street is known for its sleek design, spacious rooms, and impeccable service. Its central location and luxurious amenities cater to travelers seeking a sophisticated and comfortable stay in the heart of Manhattan.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 43 hotels in and around Bethpage
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities