7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
4-Star Hotels in Fire Island Pines
11 HOTELS IN AND AROUND FIRE ISLAND PINESRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.11 hotels nearby!
From $219
$
+6
Info
Categories
4 Star
Adult Only
Pool
Outdoor Pool
$
+3
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
The Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport is well-regarded for its strategic location, particularly convenient for travelers due to its proximity to the MacArthur/Islip Airport and key amenities like gas stations and restaurants. Many guests appreciate the tranquil setting and the hotel’s combination of reasonable pricing and cleanliness, which contributes to good value for money.
Guests consistently applaud the staff for their friendliness and helpful service, highlighting a seamless check-in and check-out experience. The employees are described as polite and professional, enhancing overall guest satisfaction despite the hotel’s older infrastructure.
The rooms receive positive remarks for their cleanliness and spaciousness. Many guests appreciate the comfortable beds and well-maintained bathrooms, though some mention issues with smoke odors, noise, and room size. Cleanliness is generally a strong point, although some areas like carpets could benefit from attention.
While the absence of a breakfast offering is noted, impacting convenience for some, the overall experience at Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport is described positively, with attentive service and a practical, accessible location contributing to a generally pleasant stay.
Guests consistently applaud the staff for their friendliness and helpful service, highlighting a seamless check-in and check-out experience. The employees are described as polite and professional, enhancing overall guest satisfaction despite the hotel’s older infrastructure.
The rooms receive positive remarks for their cleanliness and spaciousness. Many guests appreciate the comfortable beds and well-maintained bathrooms, though some mention issues with smoke odors, noise, and room size. Cleanliness is generally a strong point, although some areas like carpets could benefit from attention.
While the absence of a breakfast offering is noted, impacting convenience for some, the overall experience at Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport is described positively, with attentive service and a practical, accessible location contributing to a generally pleasant stay.
Categories
4 Star
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
From $407
$
+8
Info
Categories
4 Star
Adult Only
Luxury
$
+5
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island stands out as a commendable lodging choice with guests frequently praising its prime location and exceptional service. Conveniently situated off the Long Island Expressway, the hotel offers easy access to key destinations such as the Hamptons, Fire Island, and Stony Brook University, as well as local dining and recreational spots like Port Jefferson and Smith Point Beach. This, coupled with its proximity to Baseball Heaven, makes it an ideal base for exploring Long Island.
The hotel's complimentary breakfast receives positive mentions for its variety and quality, featuring traditional American fare such as eggs, bacon, and a make-your-own waffle station, alongside other staples. This spread contributes to a pleasant start to the day, appreciated for both its flavor and efficient service.
Guests enjoy the spacious, clean, and quiet rooms that provide a relaxing atmosphere, enhanced by comfortable beds that assure restful sleep. The cleanliness standard is consistently highlighted, with spotless rooms and well-maintained common areas adding to the overall positive experience. Despite minor inconveniences such as slow-draining showers, the hotel's cleanliness and comfort are frequently noted as high points.
Customer service is exceptional at Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island, with the staff described as friendly, accommodating, and attentive. Noteworthy personnel like Roger and Neal receive special commendations for their outstanding service, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Overall, the Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island delivers a comfortable stay with good value for money, particularly appealing to guests who prioritize cleanliness, convenience, and friendly service. Its ideal location and pleasant amenities make it a top choice for travelers on Long Island seeking practicality and comfort.
The hotel's complimentary breakfast receives positive mentions for its variety and quality, featuring traditional American fare such as eggs, bacon, and a make-your-own waffle station, alongside other staples. This spread contributes to a pleasant start to the day, appreciated for both its flavor and efficient service.
Guests enjoy the spacious, clean, and quiet rooms that provide a relaxing atmosphere, enhanced by comfortable beds that assure restful sleep. The cleanliness standard is consistently highlighted, with spotless rooms and well-maintained common areas adding to the overall positive experience. Despite minor inconveniences such as slow-draining showers, the hotel's cleanliness and comfort are frequently noted as high points.
Customer service is exceptional at Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island, with the staff described as friendly, accommodating, and attentive. Noteworthy personnel like Roger and Neal receive special commendations for their outstanding service, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Overall, the Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island delivers a comfortable stay with good value for money, particularly appealing to guests who prioritize cleanliness, convenience, and friendly service. Its ideal location and pleasant amenities make it a top choice for travelers on Long Island seeking practicality and comfort.
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$
+4
Info
Categories
4 Star
Pool
Parking
$
+4
Info
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$
+7
Info
Categories
4 Star
Rooms with Jacuzzi / Hot-Tub
Honeymoon
From $203
$
+5
4 Star
AI-generatedThis hotel provides modern amenities and comfortable accommodations for business and leisure travelers. It is recognized for its excellent service and convenient location.
Hamptons private guest cottage20.6 mi from Fire Island Pines
Guest House in Remsenburg NY
9.4
ExcellentFrom $162
$
+5
Info
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
$
+5
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
If you're planning a getaway to New York, consider pampering yourself at The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel. Our guests have heaped praise on the hotel's facilities and services, calling them 'superb' and 'very good'. While a few reviews had disappointing experiences, the majority of guests had a wonderful stay. One guest particularly enjoyed their room but had trouble with the thermostat block - a minor inconvenience. Although some guests felt there was misleading information, it seems this didn't detract too much from their overall experience. We would definitely recommend giving The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel a chance!
$
+7
Info
Categories
4 Star
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Categories
1
Map