The Gates Hotel Key West offers a generally positive experience for its guests, marked by a convenient and peaceful location, spacious rooms, clean facilities and accommodating staff. Situated at the entrance of Key West, the hotel is praised for its easy access to the beach, main highways and various local amenities. Despite being a bit away from the bustling downtown area, the hotel strikes a balance by providing a regular shuttle service to Old Town, allowing guests to explore central attractions effortlessly.
While the breakfast service received mixed reviews due to limited options and additional charges, some found the breakfast to be tasty and fast. Dinner experiences are also varied with the bar area and certain fish dishes receiving high praise, though the food ordering process and limited variety could benefit from improvements. The poolside dining area remains a popular spot, especially for its lively atmosphere and Tiki bar.
Rooms at The Gates Hotel present a mixed bag. Many visitors enjoyed the spacious, modernly decorated rooms equipped with essential amenities and nice views. However, some guests encountered cleanliness issues and dated furniture, indicating inconsistent room quality. Cleanliness, in general, is well-maintained across the property with particular praise for the cleaning staff ensuring a neat and comfortable environment.
The staff are often highlighted for their friendliness and helpfulness, particularly at the front desk and bar areas. Yet, some guests experienced less favorable interactions, pointing to issues of understaffing and occasional unprofessional behavior. Despite these instances, the majority of guests found the staff courteous and attentive.
WiFi at the hotel receives mixed feedback with some guests appreciating the good connectivity while others faced issues with weak signals or intermittent service. The gym facilities are well-regarded, offering convenient and well-maintained options both on-site and at an adjacent hotel.
A standout feature of The Gates Hotel is its pool area, frequently described as clean, expansive and well-maintained, providing ample seating and a pleasant atmosphere for relaxation. The outdoor pool area, complemented by BBQ spots and gym facilities, enhances the overall guest experience.
The hotel's proximity to nearby beaches and the provision of beach towels cater well to those seeking a beachside experience, even though the hotel is not directly on the beach itself. Additionally, parking options are generally appreciated for their convenience and ample space, despite some concerns about associated fees.
In summary, The Gates Hotel Key West offers a tranquil retreat with easy access to Key West’s attractions, comfortable and clean facilities and a generally positive guest service experience, albeit with certain areas that could benefit from improvement.
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West is a highly recommended hotel in Key West, thanks to its convenient location and shuttle service that takes guests to Old Town. The hotel is close to main attractions and features great pool views, providing a relaxing atmosphere for guests. While some guests experienced issues with room cleanliness and maintenance, the majority found the rooms to be clean and comfortable. The hotel's communal areas were generally found to be modern and well-appointed. The staff is highly regarded for their friendliness and helpfulness with many guests praising specific staff members. The pool is a standout feature with many positive reviews praising its cleanliness and overall appearance. While parking received mixed reviews, many agreed that it was convenient and ample. Overall, Blue Flamingo Resort Key West is a great choice for a Key West vacation.
The 'Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns' enjoys a prime location towards the quieter end of Duval Street, offering guests easy access to shopping, dining and notable Key West attractions, including the Ernest Hemingway House and the iconic lighthouse. The beautiful, green surroundings and historical charm of the older building create a welcoming and serene atmosphere, further enhanced by friendly and helpful staff.
The breakfast experience varies with some guests praising the well-presented, plentiful selection of continental breakfast items served on a cozy terrace. However, others found the breakfast timing and variety lacking, impacting their overall satisfaction.
Rooms at the Lighthouse Hotel are well-decorated and clean, boasting comfortable beds that many guests appreciated. However, space can be an issue with small rooms and occasional maintenance problems like inconsistent air conditioning and water temperatures. Cleanliness is generally commendable, though some guests noticed lapses in housekeeping and detailed cleaning.
The staff generally receive high marks for their friendliness and helpfulness with particular individuals noted for exceptional service. Nonetheless, there are occasional instances of less favorable interactions, suggesting potential improvements in consistency.
The pool area provides a pleasant retreat amidst lush greenery, complemented by poolside music. While enjoyable, the pool's small size, limited sun exposure and occasional cleanliness issues were highlighted as drawbacks.
Guests found the beds mostly comfortable, contributing to a restful stay despite a few reports of overly soft or lumpy mattresses and noisy air conditioning units.
Overall, the Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns offers a charming stay with a fantastic location and generally positive experiences, though it is essential for potential guests to consider the noted caveats, particularly regarding room size and breakfast variety.
Wicker Guesthouse offers a delightful stay in Key West, highlighted by its exceptional location on Duval Street. This prime spot provides guests with easy access to the city's vibrant nightlife, historic sites and various attractions, all within walking distance. Despite its central position, the guesthouse maintains a surprisingly quiet ambiance, creating a peaceful retreat amidst the bustling city. The convenience of free parking and proximity to trolley stops further adds to the appeal, making Wicker Guesthouse an excellent choice for those wanting to fully immerse themselves in the dynamic spirit of Key West.
Guests start their day with a complimentary continental breakfast served in a charming tropical garden setting. The selection, while simple and adequate, includes bagels, toast, cereals, fruits and yogurt. The serene poolside and garden settings enhance this morning experience, despite occasional feedback calling for more variety and timely replenishment of breakfast items.
The guesthouse's rooms receive mixed but generally positive reviews. They are largely praised for cleanliness, cozy ambiance and rustic charm with amenities like kitchens and modern bathrooms enhancing comfort. However, some guests have found the rooms small with a need for updated furnishings and better sound insulation. Despite these occasional downsides, the clean, well-maintained rooms and friendly staff contribute to a pleasant overall experience.
Cleanliness at Wicker Guesthouse is a notable highlight. Many guests commend the spotless rooms and well-kept communal areas, including the poolside and breakfast areas. While there are occasional reports of overlooked spots and maintenance needs, the general sentiment is of a clean and tidy environment, reinforcing the guesthouse’s welcoming atmosphere.
The staff at Wicker Guesthouse receive high praise for their friendliness, efficiency and helpfulness. Specific individuals are often mentioned for going above and beyond to ensure guest satisfaction. The professional demeanor and welcoming attitude of the staff, from management to housekeeping, add significantly to the guests' positive experience, making Wicker Guesthouse a hospitable and pleasant place to stay.
The convenience of free, high-speed WiFi is another appreciated amenity with guests generally finding it reliable and fast, though some did encounter occasional connectivity issues. The pool facilities, featuring two well-maintained pools surrounded by lush greenery, offer a serene and inviting atmosphere. While some guests mentioned the pools being small and occasionally crowded, the overall experience is positive with the beautiful landscaping adding to the charm.
Parking is praised for being secure and free, though finding a spot can sometimes be a challenge. The availability of valet parking adds convenience, even with occasional delays. The vibrant nightlife of Duval Street is a major draw, offering guests easy access to bars, clubs and restaurants, though the proximity to nightlife venues can result in higher noise levels, particularly affecting light sleepers.
Opinions on the beds are varied with some guests finding them comfortable and well-maintained, while others experienced issues with firmness, size and overall comfort. Cleanliness and a generally quiet atmosphere help mitigate some of these concerns.
Wicker Guesthouse offers a reliable three-star experience with its appealing design and functional amenities making it a solid choice for budget-conscious travelers. While the breakfast and some maintenance aspects could be improved, the overall ambiance, combined with commendable cleanliness and exceptional staff, ensures a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic Inns offers guests an inviting and well-rounded experience that highlights its exceptional location, friendly staff, and comfortable accommodations. Situated in a picturesque area of Key West, the lodge serves as an ideal base for exploring the island, with close proximity to popular attractions like Duval Street and the Harbor Walkway. The lodge's peaceful yet accessible location, enhanced by amenities such as a swimming pool and a welcoming atmosphere for pet owners, makes it perfect for adventurers and those seeking relaxation alike.
The breakfast experience at Fitch Lodge is notably praised, particularly for its innovative approach of providing daily vouchers to a nearby bakery or cafe. This arrangement, which allows guests to enjoy a freshly prepared meal, earns high marks for quality and proximity, adding an appreciated touch to the start of the day.
Cleanliness is another strong point, with numerous guests commending the well-maintained and tidy rooms that contribute to a pleasant stay. While there have been occasional mentions of room and pool maintenance issues, the overall impression remains positive.
The lodge's staff stands out for their friendliness and attentiveness, with many guests highlighting their exceptional service. The front desk, in particular, is praised for creating a welcoming environment, demonstrated by personalized attention and accommodating service.
Complementing these aspects, the lodge offers a charming pool area that provides a refreshing escape after a day of exploring. Despite its limited size and occasional maintenance comments, the pool adds to the overall positive guest experience.
Lastly, the comfort of the beds is frequently highlighted, with guests enjoying restful sleep facilitated by the quality of the bedding and pillows. Despite minor preferences, the consensus remains that the beds contribute significantly to the lodge's appeal.
Overall, Fitch Lodge is celebrated for its alluring blend of location, service, and comfort, making it a cherished destination for travelers visiting Key West.
Courtney's Place Historic Cottages & Inns in Key West consistently garners positive reviews for its prime location, charming accommodations and exceptional staff. Situated in the heart of the historic Old Town, the hotel is within easy walking distance to Duval Street and major attractions such as the Hemingway House & Museum and Mallory Square. Despite its central position, the inn offers a peaceful retreat away from the bustling city, allowing guests to explore the vibrant island on foot or bike without the need for a car.
Guests appreciate the continental breakfast provided with many enjoying the outdoor dining experience in the patio area. The breakfast selection, though basic, is generally found to be satisfactory and convenient for the start of the day. The poolside area and the small but clean pool add to the charm, providing a pleasant spot for relaxation.
The rooms, often lauded for their cleanliness, cozy and updated decor, offer a quiet and comfortable stay. Many feature island-style aesthetics, private patios and modern amenities, making them a comfortable retreat after a day of exploring. Though some rooms and bathrooms are noted to be smaller than expected, the overall atmosphere of charm and tranquility largely outweighs these minor inconveniences.
Cleanliness is a strong point at Courtney's Place with both rooms and common areas consistently maintained to high standards. Guests also appreciate the well-kept gardens and pool area, which add to the overall appeal. The staff are frequently praised for their friendliness, helpfulness and professional demeanor, contributing significantly to the welcoming and homely environment. The reception staff, in particular, receive commendations for their efficiency and personal touch.
The free WiFi receives mixed reviews; while many find it satisfactory, others experience issues with the signal strength and consistency. The same goes for the pool, which is celebrated for its cleanliness and cozy atmosphere but sometimes noted to be too small and crowded.
Parking, though free, can be tight and challenging, especially for larger vehicles. However, the convenience of having free parking is still appreciated by many guests.
The proximity to vibrant nightlife makes it an ideal spot for those looking to enjoy Key West's evening entertainment while still being able to retreat to a quiet setting. Despite some disturbances from nearby roosters, the overall ambiance remains positive.
Pet owners find Courtney's Place particularly accommodating with reasonable pet policies and a welcoming atmosphere for dogs, despite limited grassy areas nearby.
In summary, Courtney's Place Historic Cottages & Inns is cherished for its excellent location, clean and charming accommodations and exceptional staff, making it a top choice for travelers seeking an authentic and comfortable Key West experience.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 21-40 out of 200+ hotels in and around Key West