4-Star Hotels, B&Bs in Siena

Hotel Certosa Di Maggiano

Hotel in Siena

9.5

Excellent

From $255

4-Star Hotel

This former monastery offers a unique and tranquil experience in the Tuscan countryside, featuring an outdoor pool and beautiful garden views. Guests can enjoy exceptional service and a serene atmosphere, just a short distance from Siena's city center.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryNestled in the heart of Tuscany, Hotel Certosa Di Maggiano boasts luxurious four-star accommodations that are sure to impress. With an impressive four-star rating, this high-quality hotel offers an excellent property that is all in very fine taste and generosity. From the moment you arrive, you'll be struck by the extraordinaries ambiente, immersing yourself in the elegant surroundings of this great four-star property. Guests consistently rave about the hotel's struttura a quattro stelle, appreciating the attention to detail and the overall ambiance of this nice hotel. While there were no mentions of specific facilities, it's clear that the hotel lives up to its reputation as a truly posto meraviglioso and a must-visit destination.
Show more

Palazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa

Hotel in Radda in Chianti

8.6

Very Good

From $134

4-Star Hotel

Located in the heart of Chianti, this historic residence offers a luxurious spa and beautifully appointed rooms. Its central location allows easy access to the region's vineyards and cultural attractions.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryPalazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa is a hotel that many guests deemed disappointing in terms of its 4-star rating, as some felt that not all the staff were up to par and that some of the services were not up to standard. While some guests appreciated the location and the spa, others felt that the hotel was overpriced for the facilities and services provided. The breakfast was viewed as decent but lacking in variety and the rooms were described as small and pricey for the type available compared to what one would expect from a 4-star hotel. Therefore, one may want to consider other options before booking Palazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa.
Show more

Hotel Villa San Lucchese

Hotel in Poggibonsi

9.2

Excellent

From $127

4-Star Hotel

This 4-star hotel, a renovated 15th-century villa nestled in the Chianti hills, features a swimming pool, tennis court, and a Tuscan restaurant with a terrace offering panoramic views. It offers a blend of historical charm and modern amenities, making it suitable for a comfortable and memorable stay.

Hotel Athena

Hotel in Siena

8.8

Excellent

From $95

4-Star Hotel

Located within Siena's historic walls, this hotel provides free parking and a furnished terrace with city views. It also features an elegant Italian restaurant and is conveniently located near major attractions like the Duomo di Siena Cathedral and Piazza del Campo.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Athena receives mixed reviews regarding its four-star rating. Some feel the hotel does not live up to its advertised standard, citing issues with cleanliness, inadequate breakfast offerings and a cost that does not align with the perceived quality. Others, however, find it consistent with four-star standards found in Italy, praising its amenities, location and overall quality. The hotel features comfortable rooms, superb facilities and efficient service that some find worthy of a four-star category. While there are commendable aspects, including services performed correctly and an elegant establishment, there are also noted areas for improvement to fully meet the expectations of a four-star rating.
Show more

Hotel Palazzo San Niccolò & Spa

Hotel in Radda in Chianti

8.5

Very Good

From $119

4-Star Hotel

Situated in Radda in Chianti, this hotel offers a relaxing spa and beautifully appointed rooms. Its location in the heart of the Chianti region makes it ideal for wine lovers and those seeking a tranquil escape.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Palazzo San Niccolò & Spa, while boasting a charming historic facade, faces mixed reviews regarding its four-star status. Guests point out that the facilities and services fall short of what one anticipates from a hotel of this rating, with outdated furniture and devices contributing to the disappointment. The absence of expected amenities such as luggage service further detracts from the experience. The breakfast, consisting mainly of industrial products and canned fruits, is commonly noted as underwhelming for a four-star establishment, failing to offer variety or freshness. Despite these critiques, some guests acknowledge a top-level service, hinting at the potential for a more positive experience if other areas were improved.
Show more

Hotel Villa Casalecchi

Hotel in Castellina in Chianti

8.3

Very Good

From $186

4-Star Hotel

This 19th-century property features a pool, free Wi-Fi, and a sun terrace overlooking vineyards and olive groves. The accommodations are en suite, and guests appreciate the tranquility, beautiful scenery, and friendly service. Some rooms have high ceilings.

Villa Scacciapensieri Boutique Hotel

Hotel in Siena

8.1

Very Good

From $179

4-Star Hotel

Surrounded by a large park just outside Siena, this boutique hotel offers beautiful views of the Chianti Hills. The hotel provides comfortable and elegant accommodations, beautiful gardens, and attentive staff.

Hotel Palazzo San Lorenzo & Spa

Hotel in Colle Val D'Elsa

9.0

Excellent

From $124

4-Star Hotel

Located in the Chianti region, this hotel offers a spa and wellness center, providing guests with relaxation and rejuvenation opportunities. It combines historic charm with modern amenities, making it a comfortable and high-quality option.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Palazzo San Lorenzo & Spa has elicited a mixed but largely positive response from its guests, particularly in the context of its four-star rating. The hotel is often described as being worthy of its four-star designation with several guests highlighting its quality and top-notch facilities. Refined common spaces and modern amenities are often mentioned, reflecting the high standards expected from a hotel in this category.

Guests appreciated the comfort and upkeep of the rooms, which are detailed as large, quiet and delicately furnished. The hotel’s breakfast offerings have also garnered positive feedback, noted for their luscious variety and being satisfactory overall. Additionally, the ease of communication with the staff and their attentive service has been praised, contributing to a generally great experience.

Despite these positives, there are a few who felt the hotel does not fully live up to the four-star standard, expressing disappointment in some aspects like the lack of access to a pool. On the cost front, opinions are split; some see the higher prices as expected for a hotel of this caliber, while others are more critical of the value for money. Nonetheless, the majority of guests recognize its charm, cleanliness and the fair value provided.

In conclusion, Hotel Palazzo San Lorenzo & Spa appears to deliver a quality four-star experience overall with refined facilities and attentive service being key highlights, though it may fall short of expectations for some.
Show more

Castello di Leonina Relais - Adults Only

Hotel in Casetta

8.6

Very Good

From $237

4-Star Hotel

This 13th-century castle offers stunning views of the hills around Asciano. It features a wellness corner, a Finnish sauna, and a swimming pool with hydromassage, providing a relaxing and luxurious experience. The hotel is known for its quiet and peaceful atmosphere, making it ideal for a romantic getaway.

Four Points by Sheraton Siena

Hotel in Siena

8.5

Very Good

From $128

4-Star Hotel

This hotel offers reliable comfort and a range of amenities expected from the Sheraton brand. It provides a convenient location with comfortable rooms and good service, suitable for both leisure and business travelers.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryFour Points by Sheraton Siena offers a range of four-star amenities and superior service that many guests find appealing. The hotel boasts a clean, spa-like atmosphere that aligns well with its high standards and meticulous maintenance. The rooms and services are consistently praised for their quality and comfort, reflecting true four-star accommodations. Reviews often highlight the hotel's appropriate and high-level offerings, describing the experience as excellent and superb.

Guests appreciate the quality service and well-kept rooms, suggesting the establishment meets expectations for a four-star hotel. There is also a notable mention of a well-organized and rich breakfast, although some guests felt it didn't quite match their four-star experiences in other Italian hotels. Despite some critiques, like the expectation that pool access should be included in the room price, the overall impression remains positive with a strong focus on the hotel's adherence to its four-star classification.

With a good price-performance ratio and suitable structure for its category, many travelers definitely recommend Four Points by Sheraton Siena as a high-quality establishment that provides a satisfying stay.
Show more

Hotel Executive

Hotel in Siena

8.4

Very Good

From $84

4-Star Hotel

Located in the center of Siena, this hotel provides comfortable rooms and is within a reasonable distance of Piazza del Campo. Wi-Fi is available throughout the venue as well as a free private car park, allergy-free rooms and a garden are available on site.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Executive, a four-star establishment, has garnered a mix of praise and criticisms from guests. Many commend its value for the price, highlighting the friendly and professional staff, which aligns with the expectations for a four-star hotel. The hospitality is often noted as excellent and it remains a popular choice among tourists.

However, several reviews suggest that the hotel falls short of its four-star rating. Guest experiences reveal issues such as deficient air conditioning, broken tiles in bathrooms, signs of mold and poor room heating, which detract from the overall comfort. Additionally, some facilities, like air conditioning and television, were non-functional for certain stays and the walls were described as being thin, potentially disrupting peace and quiet.

The breakfast received significant criticism for not meeting the standards of a four-star hotel. Guests reported limited options, poor product quality, dry cakes and diluted fruit juices. The service at breakfast was also described as subpar with some staff prioritizing closing over guest satisfaction.

Overall, while the hotel delivers in terms of value and welcoming service, it struggles to meet the full expectations of a four-star rating, especially in terms of maintenance and breakfast quality.
Show more

NH Siena

Hotel in Siena

7.9

Good

From $102

4-Star Hotel

NH Siena is well-situated near the historic district, offering modern accommodations and excellent service. Its central location makes it convenient for exploring Siena's attractions, while providing a comfortable and well-equipped base.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryNH Siena offers affordable accommodation with excellent facilities and services. Despite a few negative reviews, guests generally have high expectations of the hotel's four-star rating, which is met for the most part. The hotel is fantastic and the rooms are generally clean, although some may need renovations due to wear and tear. Unfortunately, the hotel does not offer parking and guests must find paid parking elsewhere.
Show more

Villa del Sole Siena

Bed & Breakfast in Siena

9.5

Excellent

From $141

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Boutique-style Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Precise House Montaperti Siena

Hotel in Siena

8.1

Very Good

From $87

4-Star Hotel

Precise House Montaperti Siena offers comfortable accommodations with a range of amenities. It is well-regarded for its service and overall quality, providing a pleasant stay for guests.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe reviews of Precise House Montaperti Siena present a mixed picture, with many guests questioning its four-star rating. Several reviews suggest that the hotel's condition and services do not meet the expectations one might have of a hotel in this category, hinting at a need for renovation and improved maintenance of rooms and facilities. The location is noted to be rather remote, adding to the sense that it does not quite match its advertised luxury status.

Guests highlighted specific areas where the hotel falls short of the four-star standard. These include a breakfast offering that lacks variety, particularly for a hotel in this category, and other breakfast aspects like the absence of freshly squeezed orange juice. The pool experience is underwhelming for some, described as unheated and cold, affecting its suitability for families.

The hotel structure and style have been compared more to a motel than an upscale establishment, with criticisms about the lack of soundproofing and inadequate amenities in the bathroom. Furthermore, some reviewers felt that charging additional fees for family accommodations was inappropriate for a hotel claiming four-star status.

Despite these critiques, there are positive notes regarding the hotel's cleanliness, overall value for money, and a few experiences exceeding guests' expectations. However, recurring feedback suggests it aligns more closely with a three-star hotel experience. Overall, it seems that Precise House Montaperti Siena offers a satisfactory but not exceptional stay, ultimately falling short of what many expect from a four-star hotel.
Show more

Hotel Belvedere Di San Leonino

Hotel in Castellina in Chianti

9.4

Excellent

From $174

4-Star Hotel

Located in a historic country house from the 1400s, this hotel is surrounded by vineyards and offers rooms decorated in a characteristic Tuscan style. It includes an outdoor pool, a restaurant, and a winery. Reviews emphasize the beautiful location, charming ambiance, and excellent food and wine.

Hotel Palazzo Squarcialupi

Hotel in Castellina in Chianti

9.2

Excellent

From $200

4-Star Hotel

This 15th-century building offers a blend of historical charm and modern amenities, including a garden with an outdoor swimming pool, and a spa. Guest reviews highlight the beautiful location, excellent food, and helpful staff, as well as the very good breakfast and well-maintained property.

Hotel Le Pozze Di Lecchi

Hotel in Gaiole in Chianti

8.7

Very Good

From $125

4-Star Hotel

This hotel is perfectly located for excursions to the Chianti area, Siena, and Florence. It features a lovely pool area with a bar, and the staff is always smiling and helpful with information about the sights and restaurants in the area. Great food is served in the restaurant.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Le Pozze Di Lecchi is nestled in a picturesque location, promising guests a tranquil and serene environment. This lovely gem offers a peaceful retreat, despite the slightly challenging road access. While its beauty and convenience are often praised, some aspects appear to fall short of the expectations typically aligned with a four-star rating. Several reviews highlight discrepancies, such as the need for improved cleanliness in rooms and a breakfast selection that lacks regular updates. Furthermore, the shower facilities and certain service features have been pointed out as not meeting the four-star standard. Despite these noted shortcomings, there are instances where the service has pleasantly surpassed expectations, showcasing moments of excellence that contribute to the overall experience.
Show more

Relais Della Rovere

Hotel in Colle Val D'Elsa

8.9

Excellent

From $147

4-Star Hotel

This hotel offers a golf course, an outdoor pool, and bicycle rentals for recreation. The hotel features Tuscan-style design and provides concierge services.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryRelais Della Rovere is often praised as a gorgeous four-star retreat, truly encapsulating Italian four-star hospitality. With accommodations that are on the level of a 4-star hotel, it is appreciated for offering good prices for such a category. Although considered a great 4-star hotel, some reviews note that the service and cleanliness do not consistently meet four-star standards, particularly mentioning the limited and poorly organized breakfast. While it generally presents itself as worthy of its rating, some aspects could be improved to ensure it fully aligns with the expectations of a four-star hotel experience.
Show more

Hotel Ristorante Alcide

Hotel in Poggibonsi

7.8

Good

From $49

4-Star Hotel

Set in the Tuscan hills, this hotel is ideally located for exploring the Valdelsa Valley and the Chianti wine region. It features a traditional 160-year-old Tuscan restaurant, offering an authentic culinary experience.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Ristorante Alcide has received a consistent theme of feedback regarding its four-star rating with many guests expressing that the hotel falls short of these expectations. The primary criticisms focus on the need for extensive renovations and modernization, particularly in the rooms and bathrooms. Many visitors noted that the hotel structure, furnishings and overall ambiance appear quite dated and not reflective of a contemporary four-star establishment.

Soundproofing issues were highlighted as a significant area for improvement with many guests pointing out insufficient noise insulation, which disrupted their stay. Additionally, there were comments about the quality of amenities provided, stating they did not match what one would expect from a hotel of this star rating.

Despite these drawbacks, some reviews acknowledged the hotel's potential, describing it as good value for a four-star accommodation. Certain aspects of the service and quality did meet the four-star standards for some guests.

Overall, while the hotel maintains a four-star classification, the prevailing sentiment among reviewers suggests that it does not fully meet the standards typically associated with this rating, due to its outdated facilities and need for refurbishment.
Show more

Toscana Ambassador

Hotel in Poggibonsi

8.0

Very Good

From $72

4-Star Hotel

Located a short walk from Poggibonsi's historic center and train station, this 4-star hotel offers modern rooms equipped with free Wi-Fi. It provides convenient access to local attractions and features on-site dining with delicious Tuscan cuisine.

Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe reviews for the Toscana Ambassador reveal a recurring sentiment that the hotel falls short of its 4-star rating. Guests frequently mention that the amenities and room quality don't meet expectations, with many citing outdated interiors and a need for renovation. The decor and furnishings are compared to those of a 2-star establishment, suggesting a failure to justify the premium pricing typically associated with a 4-star hotel. Despite these criticisms, the hotel does have some redeeming features. Guests appreciate the strategic location, which offers convenient access to various destinations. Additionally, the breakfast receives positive remarks for its variety and excellence. The staff is noted for being customer-oriented, with thoughtful touches like a pleasant farewell. However, there's a clear consensus that the overall experience, while positive in some aspects, doesn't align with the standards associated with a 4-star rating.
Show more

*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.

SHOWING 1-20 OUT OF 200+ HOTELS IN SIENA