Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

4-Star Hotels in East Rutherford

200+ HOTELS IN AND AROUND EAST RUTHERFORDRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
Hotel Lucerne main photo
Hotel Lucerne
6.0 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.4
Very Good
From $323
$
+3
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Hotel Lucerne offers a notable mix of high standards and good value for money, located in a lively yet not overly busy area. Guests frequently highlight the efficient and helpful staff, adding to a pleasant stay experience. The friendly team enhances the overall satisfaction with the adjacent Nice Matin restaurant being a delightful addition for many visitors. The hotel is described as luxurious and upscale, maintaining a strong reputation.

However, several reviews suggest that some aspects of
Hotel Lucerne fall short of four-star expectations. Rooms are often mentioned as tiny and poorly insulated and the furnishings appear outdated to some guests. The elevator service is noted as slow and the availability of room amenities like blankets, bathrobes and slippers seems limited. While the value for money remains appreciated, more room features and amenities would align better with its four-star rating. Despite some service inconsistencies, the general impression remains positive due to the quality of staff and foundational service standards.
The Empire Hotel New York main photo
The Empire Hotel New York
6.2 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
6.7
Rated
From $214
$
+9
4 Star
AI-generatedLocated on the Upper West Side near Lincoln Center and Central Park, this iconic hotel mirrors the elegance and modernity of its surroundings. The stylish Art Deco rooms and vibrant rooftop bar provide an authentic Manhattan experience.
Yotel New York Times Square main photo
Yotel New York Times Square
6.2 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.4
Good
From $201
$
+6
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Yotel New York Times Square is a modern, well-located hotel offering functional and good value for money accommodations. Guests find the clean, modernized rooms and luxury suites with floor-to-ceiling windows particularly appealing, delivering lovely views and airy spaces. The hospitality and amenities cater to families, ensuring a pleasant stay at a reasonable price, making it a viable four-star hotel.

The hotel features an amazing restaurant and bar on the 4th floor, which adds to the overall positive experience. Guests appreciate the central location, even if it comes at a premium. Furthermore, the hotel's unique yobot luggage storage system is a plus, although some issues with it have been noted.

Despite its many merits, some aspects fall short of four-star standards, such as the smaller room sizes, occasional noise disturbances and issues with the WiFi not being strong enough for streaming services like Netflix. However, the hotel's comfortable beds and modern design still leave a strong impression on visitors. Overall,
Yotel New York Times Square offers great value for money and a central, comfortable stay in the heart of New York City.
DoubleTree by Hilton Fort Lee/George Washington Bridge main photo
DoubleTree by Hilton Fort Lee/George Washington Bridge
6.2 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in Fort Lee NJUS flag
7.8
Good
From $143
$
+2
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
DoubleTree by Hilton Fort Lee/George Washington Bridge has received mixed reviews regarding its four-star rating. While some guests expressed disappointment, suggesting the service and facilities do not align with a four-star standard, others found aspects of their stay more satisfactory. Positive feedback highlights friendly and helpful staff, clean and spacious rooms and an overall beautiful experience that meets basic needs. Some guests noted that it was better than other options and were generally satisfied with their stay. Nonetheless, the disparity in opinions suggests a gap between expectations of a four-star experience and the actual offerings of the hotel.
W Hoboken main photo
W Hoboken
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in Hoboken NJUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $435
$
+2
4 Star
AI-generatedThe W Hoboken is situated in the heart of Hoboken, offering access to dining and entertainment. It's close to the PATH and NY Waterway Ferry for easy access to New York City.
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
If you're looking for a four-star hotel with beautiful views and a great location, W Hoboken is the place for you. The rooms are attractive and clean with extremely comfortable beds. The staff are friendly and attentive, particularly Maxine at the front desk who is professional, courteous, knowledgeable and very helpful. Breakfast is excellent and the overall service is superb with great managers who work hard to ensure guests have an exceptional stay. While there may be some minor faults, the hotel is generally very good and definitely worth considering for your next trip to the area.
Comfort Suites Newark - Harrison main photo
Comfort Suites Newark - Harrison
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in Newark NJUS flag
7.5
Good
From $130
$
+3
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Comfort Suites Newark-Harrison receives generally favorable reviews, emphasizing its convenient location, clean and spacious rooms and welcoming staff. Positioned near Newark Penn Station and close to Newark Airport, the hotel offers excellent accessibility for those traveling to New York City or exploring New Jersey. Guests appreciate the large, well-equipped rooms with comfortable beds and the consistent quality of the standard American breakfast.

The breakfast is praised for its hearty and abundant options, particularly the waffles and muffins with the breakfast staff noted for their friendliness. However, some guests suggest improvements in variety and cleanliness, mentioning issues such as dry sausages or limited healthy options.

The rooms are described as very clean, spacious and comfortable with daily housekeeping maintaining high standards. Despite some mixed feedback regarding occasional odors or outdated facilities, the overall sentiment is positive, highlighting generous room size and comfort.

Cleanliness is a strong point for the hotel with guests frequently commending the spotless rooms and fresh bathrooms. Although there are occasional reports of issues like dirty carpets or bugs, the hotel maintains a solid reputation for cleanliness and comfort.

The staff receives consistent praise for their courteous and professional demeanor, contributing significantly to the positive guest experience. While there are isolated incidents of less friendly interactions, the general consensus is that the staff is a highlight of the stay, providing a welcoming and supportive environment.

Parking at the hotel is a mixed aspect with guests appreciating the convenience of free on-site parking. However, inconsistencies in communication about parking fees and security concerns, such as a reported car theft, suggest areas for improvement.

Overall, Comfort Suites Newark-Harrison offers a comfortable, clean and convenient stay with commendable staff service, though there is room for enhancement in breakfast variety and parking management.
Categories
4 Star
Honeymoon
Business
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Midtown West main photo
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Midtown West
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.7
Very Good
From $345
$
+5
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Midtown West offers a conventional four-star experience in the bustling Hudson Yards area. The hotel maintains a high standard with reasonable four-star amenities and appropriate facilities, standing out as a class above other places in its category. Consistency in quality and a considerable value per night make it a great choice for those seeking convenient luxury lodging.

The new hotel boasts nice, clean spots to relax outside, enhancing its appeal. Its use of eco-friendly bathroom products adds a touch of modern consciousness to the traditional four-star setting. While some guests felt the breakfast and certain services did not quite align with the four-star rating, the overall experience still meets and often exceeds typical expectations for this level of accommodation.

In summary,
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Midtown West provides a high-value stay with maintained four-star quality, making it a good choice for travelers looking for a dependable, upscale hotel experience in New York City.
Four Points by Sheraton Manhattan Midtown West main photo
Four Points by Sheraton Manhattan Midtown West
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.5
Very Good
From $309
$
+4
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Four Points by Sheraton Manhattan Midtown West has received mixed feedback regarding its four-star rating and facilities. Set in a great location and offering value for money, the hotel boasts clean, modern and spacious rooms that guests find comfortable and well-maintained. Many reviewers appreciated the fair prices and the friendly and helpful staff.

However, several details detract from the overall four-star experience. The absence of a minibar or fridge in the rooms is a notable concern and some guests expected daily room service, which was not provided. Despite its soundproofing, noise issues were still reported. Additionally, the hotel’s amenities, while decent, fell short of what one would expect from a four-star establishment with some visitors suggesting that it feels more like a two-star hotel.

While the hotel provides a calm atmosphere and good bar facilities, certain features that typically distinguish a four-star hotel are simply missing. This has led to disappointment among guests who found the overall experience to be quite standard for the high cost. Despite these issues, the location and cleanliness of the hotel are frequently praised.
Hotel Alameda, Highline main photo
Hotel Alameda, Highline
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
6.8
Rated
From $219
$
+9
Info
The hotel is located in the heart of the Chelsea Riviera between the High Line and the Hudson River. It offers three room types, all with the feel of an urban ryokan with wooden platform beds, warm lighting, and luxurious natural materials.
Categories
4 Star
Boutique-Style
Luxury
Lavish Columbus Circle Apartment by Central Park & Times Square main photo
Lavish Columbus Circle Apartment by Central Park & Times Square
6.3 mi from East Rutherford
Guest House in New York NYUS flag
10
Excellent
$
+4
Info
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Adult Only
Truss Hotel Times Square main photo
Truss Hotel Times Square
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $209
$
+10
Info
Categories
4 Star
Luxury
Honeymoon
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West main photo
Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.1
Good
From $226
$
+3
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
The Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West offers good value for the price, aligning closely with what one would expect from the Hilton brand. The hotel delivers a comfortable and clean environment with modern decor and a friendly atmosphere, making it a reasonable choice for travelers seeking a reliable stay in New York City. Though some guests felt the facilities were more basic than what is typically associated with a four-star hotel, the room sizes are appropriate for NYC standards.

While the hotel might not consistently meet the higher expectations often associated with a four-star rating or other Doubletree properties, it remains a standard and practical option. The general room quality and pricing are reasonable for its location with many guests noting comfort and recommending the hotel overall. However, be prepared for potential price increases over long weekends.
Romer Hell's Kitchen main photo
Romer Hell's Kitchen
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $285
$
+1
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Romer Hell's Kitchen in New York offers a unique blend of comfort and value, situated in a prime location near Times Square and the theater district. Guests appreciate the decor, which has been thoughtfully chosen, creating a calm and pleasing atmosphere. The hotel presents itself as a beautifully maintained boutique establishment, which adds a touch of charm to its overall appeal. Rooms are noted for their relative spaciousness, especially by New York standards, and provide a decent level of comfort with new mattresses that ensure a restful sleep.

Despite these positives,
Romer Hell's Kitchen raises mixed feelings about its four-star rating. Some guests believe the hotel aligns more with a three-star standard, noting the absence of certain expected amenities such as classic hotel kits and in-room facilities like kettles or coffee machines. Others suggest that although billed as a four-star property, certain aspects like towel quality and breakfast offerings fall short of expectations.

The hotel's pricing has also been a subject of discussion, as it can appear a bit steep, particularly during peak seasons like Christmas. While some guests felt they received good value for their money, others remarked on the high costs, comparing them unfavorably to what one might expect from luxury hotels in other parts of the world.

Service at the hotel is friendly but could benefit from more personalization and efficiency, with improvements suggested for check-in processes and general amenities. While there is no restaurant on-site, the hotel's location means that guests can easily explore a variety of local dining options, making it unnecessary to opt for the breakfast package offered by the hotel.

Overall,
Romer Hell's Kitchen stands out for its location and thoughtful design, offering a decent stay at a reasonable price for the area, yet it may leave some guests yearning for the full four-star experience.
CIVILIAN Hotel main photo
CIVILIAN Hotel
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $270
$
+4
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
CIVILIAN Hotel in New York garners mixed feedback, though it generally leans positive. Guests frequently applaud its beautiful, sophisticated and modern design, noting the high standard of decor and the charming, elegant blend reminiscent of the 60s. The hotel is described as a "super cute" and "nice design hotel," and it's considered a true four-star experience due to its luxurious ambiance and friendly, helpful staff.

From a logistical perspective, the hotel's value proposition stands out. Many reviewers highlight the great value for money, especially given its perfect location. It's noted as more affordable than other similarly rated hotels in the area. Despite some dissatisfaction regarding room size with some finding them very small and the "big" double beds only standard size, guests still consider it a worthwhile stay.

However, some aspects fall short of expectations for a four-star hotel. The absence of daily cleaning services, which surprised some guests, is highlighted as an issue that does not align with the four-star standard. While the basic service is included, some express disappointment in this regard.

Despite these critiques, the overall sentiment remains positive. Guests appreciate the decision to stay at a hotel with a great atmosphere, superb decor and competitive pricing for the area. Ultimately, while there are varied experiences, many reviewers would choose to stay again, underlining a generally favorable impression of
CIVILIAN Hotel.
Hyatt Place New York City - Times Square main photo
Hyatt Place New York City - Times Square
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
7.8
Good
From $265
$
+1
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Hyatt Place New York City/Times Square offers an impressive combination of value and location. Many guests highlighted its excellent value for money, commending the reasonable prices and the high quality of service and facilities provided. The hotel is described as well-maintained with excellent customer service, ensuring a comfortable stay that some likened to Gatsbyesque comfort. The strategic location is perfect for sightseeing, adding to its appeal for tourists.

While the hotel generally meets the standards of a four-star establishment, some aspects fall short. The breakfast, though generally good, did not meet the expectations of a four-star rating for many guests with limited variety and quality closer to a three-star experience. The hotel operations, such as the busy mornings and occasional unfriendly staff interactions, detracted from an otherwise positive experience.

The hotel’s four elevators, connected for guest convenience, were noted, though the morning rush created some chaos. Despite these minor issues, guests overall found Hyatt Place to be a great value for the price, particularly appreciating the balance it strikes between quality and cost.
Arlo Midtown main photo
Arlo Midtown
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $274
$
+2
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Arlo Midtown stands out as a modern, stylish retreat with contemporary accommodations that make it a superb choice for travelers seeking a four-star experience in the heart of New York City. The hotel’s sleek design and cozy furnishings immediately create a welcoming atmosphere that guests find both comfortable and aesthetically appealing. Its central location between Hudson Yards and Times Square is another big plus, providing easy access to the vibrant city life.

The rooftop bar is a true highlight, offering sensational views that enhance the overall stay. The hotel’s great bar area and delicious breakfast also receive frequent praise, adding to the excellent service provided by friendly and helpful staff. Fitness enthusiasts will appreciate the well-equipped gym.

Despite some comments about the rooms feeling somewhat cramped, the accommodations are consistently noted for being clean, modern and functional, meeting the four-star category criteria. The beds are described as comfy and the bathrooms pristine. Some guests felt that the space might not fully meet their expectations for a four-star level, yet overall, the hotel offers exceptional value for money, making it a perfect choice for short trips, solo travelers and business stays alike.

The hotel’s sophisticated atmosphere is complemented by a beautiful bar area and thoughtful staff, ensuring a pleasant and superb experience. The combination of modern design, cleanliness standards and excellent location make
Arlo Midtown a highly recommended option for those looking for a comfortable and luxurious stay without compromising on value.
Riu Plaza New York Times Square main photo
Riu Plaza New York Times Square
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $307
$
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Visitors to the Riu Plaza New York Times Square have shared a mix of opinions regarding its four-star rating, facilities and services. Guests generally agree that the hotel shines with its great location and excellent service, making it a fantastic choice for both individuals and families visiting New York. The modern and fresh decor, alongside the beautiful interior and exterior, enhances the overall appeal. Many found the breakfast experience superb with a quality buffet that offers many choices. The view from the rooms and the comfort of the accommodations were also highly praised with particular mentions of the amazing showers.

Despite these positives, some guests felt that the hotel falls short of true four-star standards in certain areas. Criticisms were aimed at the lack of room service, limited facilities and in some cases, the quality of food provided. Nevertheless, the overall sentiment leans towards a favorable four-star rating with the hotel generally being described as worth its rating and a great value for money.

In summary,
Riu Plaza New York Times Square meets many four-star expectations with its excellent location, great service and modern accommodations, although some areas may require improvement to fully live up to its four-star status.
Market Rentals NYC main photo
Market Rentals NYC
6.4 mi from East Rutherford
Aparthotel in New York NYUS flag
0.0
From $278
$
+2
Info
Categories
4 Star
Free Wi-Fi
Delta Hotels by Marriott New York Times Square main photo
Delta Hotels by Marriott New York Times Square
6.5 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
From $242
$
+4
Info
Summary of reviews
Summarized by AI
Delta Hotels by Marriott New York Times Square is celebrated for its exceptional central location, offering easy access to iconic NYC landmarks like Times Square, Broadway and Central Park, as well as numerous subway stations. This strategic positioning makes it an ideal base for both tourists and business travelers, providing convenient connectivity throughout the city, including major transport hubs like the Port Authority Bus Terminal and Penn Station.

Guests consistently praise the comfortable beds and cleanliness of the rooms, which are spacious by New York standards. Modern amenities such as large TVs, coffee makers and fridges add to the convenience, while the overall room environment is often noted as cozy and welcoming. Despite some maintenance lapses and occasional noise complaints, the emphasis on comfort and cleanliness remains a strong positive aspect.

The breakfast experience at the hotel receives mixed reviews. While some guests enjoy the excellent and delicious à la carte options and commend the good coffee, the high cost and lack of variety, especially in vegetarian choices, are noted drawbacks. Still, the breakfast offering is generally appreciated by those who opt for it.

The dining experience at the hotel's restaurant also has its highs and lows. Positive remarks about the cozy ambiance and friendly staff contrast with criticisms regarding limited menu choices, particularly for vegan options and inconsistent quality. Nearby restaurants present an attractive alternative for many guests.

The hotel staff are often described as friendly, helpful and courteous, contributing to a generally positive guest experience. However, there are reports of inconsistent service and occasional language barriers, which suggest a need for improved training and professionalism.

Free WiFi is a well-received feature, providing fast and reliable internet access for guests throughout the hotel. This is especially important for business travelers and those needing to stay connected.

For fitness enthusiasts, the gym is well-equipped and appreciated by guests, although its availability can be inconsistent, which might be a minor inconvenience.

The hotel caters well to families with spacious and clean rooms that are suitable for larger groups. Nevertheless, practical concerns, such as bathroom privacy issues and safety of the surrounding area for children, are noted.

Overall,
Delta Hotels by Marriott New York Times Square offers a strong three-star experience with its central location, cleanliness and comfort being major highlights. While there are areas needing improvement, particularly in dining consistency and staff training, the hotel remains a solid choice for budget-conscious travelers seeking a convenient and comfortable stay in Manhattan.
Categories
4 Star
Family
Dog Friendly
Pestana CR7 Times Square main photo
Pestana CR7 Times Square
6.5 mi from East Rutherford
Hotel in New York NYUS flag
8.6
Very Good
From $251
$
+4
4 Star
Summary of reviews related to the '4 Star' category
Summarized by AI
Pestana CR7 Times Square hotel enjoys a central location, making it a convenient choice for travelers wanting to be near Times Square. The hotel boasts modern interiors and a neat design, providing a pleasant and comfortable stay with clean and spacious rooms. Many guests appreciate the excellent service, calling it fabulous and mint and find the staff to be friendly and accommodating.

The amenities are generally well-received and the hotel offers a good quality/price ratio, making it a recommendable option for many. With breakfast deemed decent and the hotel's overall modernity, guests often find their stay enjoyable and exceeding expectations, maintaining the four-star standard.

However, some guests noted that the hotel does not quite meet the four-star standard they anticipated with some likening it more to an upmarket hostel. Additionally, expectations about available parking were not met, as the hotel does not provide onsite parking but has an arrangement with a nearby lot. Despite these critiques, the hotel's fantastic location and overall pleasant environment contribute to a generally positive guest experience.
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 21-40 out of 200+ hotels in and around East Rutherford
  • «
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • »
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities