This five-star resort experienced a multi-million pound renovation program before its 2009 opening on its famous Ailsa golf course to become part of Starwood Hotels & Resorts.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Trump Turnberry is a five-star hotel that offers excellence and exceptional facilities and services to its guests. With a real 5-star experience, it is the best hotel some guests have ever stayed in. The hotel exudes luxury in a wonderful setting and provides a spoiling all-round experience with the assistance of amazing and helpful staff. Turnberry Magic is evident from the top-notch hotel, staff and bistro services. Although some staff may not be giving five-star service, guests generally enjoy their amazing stay and the fantastic food. The hotel is perfect for a relaxing and chilled time with family or a romantic break. Despite the dubious reputation of the owner, some guests would choose Trump Turnberry over other hotels. Guests expect everything to run smoothly at this hotel but some experienced noise in their rooms, which was not acceptable for a 5-star hotel.
This 5-star hotel is located in the heart of the city of Edinburgh and offers opulent and elegant accommodation, reminiscent of the golden age of travel.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG, is a truly exceptional five star hotel with a central location and fabulous decor. The friendly and adorable staff go above and beyond to provide superb customer service. It's no wonder that guests have described their stays as magnifique and amazing, making this hotel the best they have ever stayed in. Despite being sold as a five star hotel with rates to match, some guests have felt that the experience was more like a four star. However, overall, guests found it to be a wonderful place to stay and would highly recommend it, despite some minor disappointments such as issues with odors. Considering its good value for money compared to other five star hotels, the Kimpton - Charlotte Square is definitely worth considering for your next stay in Edinburgh.
A luxury hotel featuring one of the city's largest and most comprehensive spas, One Spa, complete with an indoor pool, hydrotherapy pool, sauna, and steam room. Offers stylish guest rooms, some with castle views.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The Sheraton Grand Hotel & Spa is a fantastic choice for a five star stay in Edinburgh. Exceptional service and facilities make it one of the best hotels around. Despite not being perfect with some guests feeling that the TV options and breakfast could be improved, the overall experience is enjoyable and superb. Previous visitors highly recommend the hotel and would stay again in the future. With an inviting breakfast room and bar, the hotel provides everything you need for a perfect break away.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Marine North Berwick is a lovely and comfortable five-star hotel that offers exceptional facilities and service. Guests loved the luxurious surroundings and attention to detail that made their stay special. The hotel is perfect for a weekend spa getaway, a romantic retreat or a stay with friends. The staff were exceptional and made guests feel welcome from the moment they arrived. The hotel features a beautiful building with well-decorated rooms and stunning views of the water to Fife from the lounge and bar. Guests loved the high standard of rooms and exceptional customer service. While some guests experienced noise issues in their rooms, overall, Marine North Berwick is a grand old lady of a hotel that offers a pleasant and comfortable stay in a beautiful location. It is highly recommended for anyone looking for exceptional accommodation.
Marine Troon is a grand 5-star hotel overlooking Royal Troon Golf Course, with views of the Firth of Clyde and Isle of Arran. The hotel offers luxurious accommodations and stunning views. It is known for its excellent service and prime location.
This 5-star hotel combines the elegance of a 19th-century Georgian townhouse with modern luxury. It features a spa, and destination restaurant. Its location offers private gardens and proximity to the city center.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The Kimpton Blythswood Square Hotel offers an exceptional experience and stay with beautiful and smart interiors, 1st class facilities and top-notch services. It is located in a great location for a short stay with many specific requests catered for. The fully staffed friendly reception and the friendly and very knowledgeable concierge are the biggest assets to this hotel. The quality comfortable bedding and complimentary mini bar add to the convenience of the guests. However, the hotel loses points for not being a true 5-star experience according to some guests, especially when it comes to closing the bar at 10:45 pm each night and the breakfast not being as good as one would expect. Yet, many still believe that the Kimpton Blythswood Square Hotel certainly lives up to its 5-star rating and is up there with the best hotels. Also, the beautiful food, great spa and friendly staff make the experience truly exceptional.
The Marcliffe Hotel is known for its elegance and tranquility. It is nestled in eight acres of nature near Royal Deeside. The hotel offers a spa, individually designed Castle Suites, and deluxe rooms.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Marcliffe is a luxury accommodation that offers exceptional facilities and services. Guests have described their stay as fabulous, wonderful and six-star experience in a five-star hotel. The hotel's location and comfort have received high praise with guests stating that it's a real five-star hotel that is worth every penny. The breakfast is described as excellent and all the food is cooked to order. The staff at The Marcliffe are excellent, polite and friendly, providing exceptional service to satisfy guests. The private and quiet location of the hotel provides a relaxed break for couples seeking a fabulous romantic getaway. Despite a few negative remarks from some guests, the overall consensus is that Marcliffe is a fantastic property that guests would come back to again and again for a cosy and comfortable getaway.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The JA Mar Hall Glasgow Scotland has received mixed reviews from its guests. Despite some negative comments about the hotel not living up to its 5-star rating, many guests still enjoyed their overall stay and praised the exceptional service, beautiful old property and nice facilities. However, some guests were disappointed with the basic breakfast, limited fitness center and high prices. Others felt that the hotel was not what they expected from a 5-star establishment and fell well below their expectations. While some guests highly recommend the hotel, others felt that it was not special enough to be considered a 5-star hotel.
Bringing the Gleneagles luxury experience to the city center, this hotel features a unique pre-war style with vintage furnishings. It is praised for its friendly staff, sophisticated atmosphere, and excellent dining at The Spence restaurant.
Located in the heart of St. Andrews, Kinnettles Hotel & Spa is a luxurious retreat offering elegant accommodations and spa facilities. Its central location makes it convenient for exploring the town and its attractions.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Kinnettles Hotel & Spa promises to be a luxurious five-star experience, however some guests were not quite convinced. Some were disappointed with the price and felt that the hotel did not quite meet their expectations of what a five-star hotel should be. Despite this, other guests praised the hotel and wrote exceptional and superb reviews with mentions of fantastic staff, great ambiance and an ideal location. Guests loved their stay and claimed it was a five-star hotel, however, a few mentioned concerns with the hotel's amenities such as fruit juice from concentrate. All in all, Kinnettles Hotel & Spa may not be everyone's idea of a five-star hotel but it still provides a great experience that many guests would return to.
This special hotel is part of the 5 star luxury hotel chain, Hotel du Vin.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Hotel Du Vin has received exceptional reviews from guests who have experienced supreme comfort and understated elegance during their stay. The facilities and staff have been described as magnificent, providing a superlative 5-star service. Guests have also raved about the hotel's beautiful surroundings and quality food and drink, as well as the friendly and fantastic staff. Many guests have had exceptional and memorable stays with some recalling their experience as magical. The location in the West End of Glasgow is also praised for its convenience for exploring the area. Overall, Hotel Du Vin is considered an excellent choice for a delightful stay and an unforgettable experience, making it the best hotel for some guests.
Adjacent to the Old Course, Rusacks St Andrews provides a boutique hotel experience steeped in golfing history. The hotel offers luxurious accommodations and breathtaking views of the Old Course Links and West Sands Beach.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Rusacks St Andrews is a stunning five-star hotel that provides an exceptional luxury experience. The hotel's facilities and services exceeded guests' expectations, from the lovely accommodations to the valet parking. Guests enjoyed friendly and helpful staff throughout their stay, whether it was having dinner in the incredible 18th rooftop restaurant or overlooking the old course's 18th hole from their new room. While some guests reported that the cooked breakfast was not up to par with a hotel of this class, others had a perfect stay and would highly recommend Rusacks St Andrews as the nicest hotel they stayed at during their trip.
The Principal is one of Edinburgh's most luxurious hotels. Offering 5-star facilities and accommodation, every guest that enters its doors will be met with nothing but luxurious treatment.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The InterContinental Edinburgh The George by IHG has been praised by guests for its exceptional facilities and services. As a luxury hotel, it's located in the best area of the city and is considered top class by guests. While some have noted that it lacks certain amenities such as a swimming pool, overall the hotel is very worthy of its 5-star rating. Exceptional and superb are just a few of the positive words used to describe the hotel, making it a first-class destination for travelers.
Dornoch Station, nestled in the charming town of Dornoch, has garnered significant praise for its excellent location, luxurious decor, and exceptional service. Positioned strategically with stunning views of the Royal Dornoch Golf Course and the beach, it proves to be an ideal base for both golfers and those looking to explore the quaint town center. The hotel beautifully complements its picturesque surroundings with recently refurbished, spotlessly clean rooms, and public areas that exude charm and warmth.
Guests have lauded Dornoch Station for its dog-friendly environment, the helpful and accommodating staff, and the remarkable food offerings. Breakfast at the hotel receives rave reviews for its variety and quality, with visitors frequently describing it as abundant, delicious, and a splendid start to the day. Dinner at the in-house restaurant is equally celebrated for its fabulous atmosphere and excellent culinary offerings, even if occasional service hiccups occur.
The rooms are highlighted for their comfort and elegant design, complemented by thoughtful amenities including fluffy towels, dressing gowns, and lovely toiletries. Although there are minor mentions of room size and lighting issues, the overall comfort and cleanliness overshadow these concerns.
The dedication to cleanliness is generally commendable, with the majority of guests praising the immaculate state of rooms despite some communal areas receiving mixed feedback. The exemplary staff consistently enhance the guest experience, noted for their professionalism and friendly demeanor, creating a welcoming and cozy atmosphere throughout the hotel.
Guests also appreciate the comfort of the beds, often describing them as exceptionally comfortable and contributing to a restful sleep. The hotel's luxurious ambiance is further highlighted by its stunning decor and fittings, making it a standout destination for those seeking a tranquil yet opulent retreat.
Overall, Dornoch Station delivers a delightful and memorable experience, characterized by its lovely location, comfortable accommodations, attentive staff, and excellent dining options, making it a highly recommended choice for visitors.
This luxury hotel combines a historic facade with modern design, featuring a stunning rooftop garden with city views. It offers contemporary luxury accommodation and is known for its unique architectural style.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Among the mixed reviews about The Glasshouse, Autograph Collection, certain themes emerge regarding its five-star status and the quality of its facilities and services. Several guests felt the hotel fell short of their five-star expectations, citing specifics such as a lack of ambience, poor facilities and subpar bar offerings as detracting factors. Additional complaints included noise levels from nearby food courts and an overall sense that the hotel did not deliver on its luxurious promise, more accurately aligning with a three-star experience.
On the upside, a proportion of guests praised the quality of the experience as truly deserving of a five-star rating, expressing satisfaction with certain elements of their stay. However, some key services expected from a five-star establishment, like room service and a stocked minibar, were noted to be absent, which seemed to influence the overall rating perceptions. Overall, the feedback suggests an inconsistency in the five-star experience with some areas falling significantly short while others achieving high satisfaction.
A luxury boutique hotel located in the charming West End, known for its elegant Victorian architecture and stylish interiors. It consistently receives high praise for its comfortable rooms and excellent service.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
The Bonham is an elegant boutique hotel in Edinburgh, praised for its stunning architecture and beautiful decor. Guests appreciate the ambiance and the traditional charm of the building with many original features. The staff are noted for providing professional service, which contributes to a generally high-class experience. Rooms are particularly highlighted for their five-star quality, suggesting a luxurious stay.
However, there are recurring sentiments that The Bonham doesn't fully meet the five-star standard expected, especially given its pricing. Some guests felt that the experience was more in line with a four-star hotel, citing certain service and detail-oriented aspects that fell short. Afternoon tea service, for instance, did not meet the five-star expectations for some.
Overall, while The Bonham impresses with its aesthetics and some aspects of service, there are mixed feelings about its alignment with the five-star rating, particularly concerning value for money and certain service standards.
This 5-star hotel is nestled on the leafy banks of the River Ness, offering a secluded atmosphere in the heart of the vibrant city center. It features a blend of a lovingly restored Grade B listed 19th-century house with modern design and architecture, providing luxurious accommodations and exceptional service. Each intricately designed room and grand suite offers a unique personality, ensuring a lavish and cared-for experience with warm Scottish hospitality.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Ness Walk stands out as a five-star hotel with guests frequently praising its luxurious ambiance, first-class service and meticulous attention to detail. Visitors describe their overall experience as superb with the hotel often cited as the best part of their trip to Scotland. The common areas are bright, airy, spacious and appealing, providing a welcoming atmosphere.
The hotel is recognized for its 5-star architecture and presentation, making it an ideal spot for a relaxing getaway. Guests appreciate the polite and attentive staff, contributing to a truly five-star experience. Luxurious touches are evident throughout, reflecting the hotel’s commitment to providing a five-star ambiance.
However, not all experiences align with the high expectations associated with a five-star rating. Some guests noted issues such as the absence of a pool/spa area, breakfast not meeting five-star standards and occasional lapses in room cleanliness. Furthermore, certain service standards, such as delays in breakfast service and subpar room amenities (e.g., using paper cups instead of glasses), were highlighted as areas needing improvement.
Despite a few hiccups, Ness Walk often impresses with its luxurious setting and attentive service, although it faces challenges in fully living up to the five-star benchmark.
A modern 5-star hotel located in India Buildings near Victoria Street. It is noted for its stylish design, comfortable chambers, and positive guest reviews, offering a vibrant luxury experience.
Summary of reviews related to the '5 Star' category
Virgin Hotels Edinburgh presents a blend of historic charm and modern luxury, consistently earning praise as a five-star establishment. Guests rave about the fantastic breakfast with some hailing the breakfast team for their exceptional service. The bar, library and terrace add to the allure, providing well-designed, opulent spaces that enhance the overall experience.
The hotel is situated in a historical building built into a cliff, beautifully integrating 400 years of culture and design with modern amenities. Rooms are described as quiet, cool, comfortable and luxurious, maintaining a high level of cleanliness. The luxurious feel extends to both the private and public areas of the hotel, providing a modern yet historic charm.
Service receives mixed reviews; while many guests commend the exceptional, friendly and professional staff, others feel the service falls short of five-star standards. Notably, the bar staff’s attitude and the lack of amenities such as coffee service in the bar and limited room service menus detract from the experience for some. There's a sense that the hotel sometimes struggles with understaffing, which impacts the service quality.
Guests also mention that certain aspects, like the basic room layouts or the inadequately soundproofed accommodation, do not align with five-star expectations, leading to some disappointment given the high price point per night.
Despite these inconsistencies, many guests still deem Virgin Hotels Edinburgh as one of the best hotels in the city with luxurious facilities and a high-quality experience, justifying the five-star rating for many. The overall experience seems to combine comfort, luxury and a rich historical ambiance, making it a notable choice for visitors to Edinburgh.