4-Star Hotels, Guesthouses, Hostels, B&Bs in Stirling

Macdonald Forest Hills Hotel & Spa

7.5

Good

From $137

4-Star ResortSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryMacdonald Forest Hills Hotel & Spa sounds like a high-end resort with beautiful and stunning scenery. Despite its lovely appearance, some guests believed that the hotel is quite tired and has a lot of maintenance issues. Some customers were disappointed because they got stuck in the steam room and the shower delivered scalding water when cold water was selected. Additionally, there were complaints about the lack of customer service for a four-star hotel, overpriced rates and lack of atmosphere inside which felt freezing. Some guests felt that the hotel is not up to four-star standards, as the executive accommodation was not really executive standard. Many guests felt that the Macdonald Forest Hills Hotel & Spa fell short of their expectations and needed to improve to be classified as a four-star hotel.
Show more

Stirling Highland Hotel- Part of the Cairn Collection

Hotel in Stirling

7.9

Good

From $115

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel with Spa

Dog Friendly Hotel

Macdonald Forest Hills Resort

Resort in Aberfoyle

7.4

Good

From $137

Info Categories

4-Star Resort

Resort with Spa

Family Friendly Resort

Hotel Colessio

Hotel in Stirling

7.2

Good

From $127

4-Star HotelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryHotel Colessio presents a mix of appealing characteristics alongside several noticeable shortfalls, especially when considering its four-star rating. Positively, guests appreciate the hotel's luxurious ambiance and see it as providing good value for money, particularly noting the boutique feel and pristine décor suitable for business stays. The building and rooms receive commendations for their quality, offering a decent overnight experience for many visitors.

However, the consensus among reviews is that the hotel doesn't fully live up to a four-star standard. Common concerns include subpar management and service quality, such as disappointing breakfast options and slow service times. Rooms, while generally good, sometimes suffer from poor lighting and cleanliness issues that detract from the overall experience. The facilities seem to lack the expected four-star amenities and many guests were dissatisfied with the WiFi quality.

Despite being marketed as a four-star establishment, it appears that Hotel Colessio falls short of consistent guest expectations. To align with its advertised status, improvements in service, amenities and overall management are necessary.
Show more

Kirkhouse Inn

Hotel in Strathblane

7.7

Good

From $99

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Hotel near Golf Courses

Hotel for Honeymoon

The Courie Inn

Hotel in Killin

9.0

Excellent

From $141

Info Categories

4-Star Hotel

Boutique-style Hotel

Hotel for Honeymoon

Roman Camp Country House Hotel

Country House in Callander

8.7

Very Good

From $225

Info Categories

4-Star Country House

Luxury Country House

Dog Friendly Country House

Dogs Stay Free

La Fortuna Lodges

Chalet in Stirling

9.0

Excellent

From $369

Info Categories

4-Star Chalet

Chalet with Rooms With Jacuzzi / Hot-tub

Luxury Chalet

Garrison Of Inversnaid Farm with Hot Tub

Bed & Breakfast in Inversnaid

9.2

Excellent

From $177

Info Categories

4-Star Bed & Breakfast

Historic Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Wellsfield Farm Holiday Lodges

Lodge in Stirling

8.9

Excellent

From $200

Info Categories

4-Star Lodge

Luxury Lodge

Lodge with Free Wi-Fi

Westcot

Guest House in Callander

9.8

Excellent

From $166

Info Categories

4-Star Guest House

Guest House Taking Steps Towards Sustainability

Guest House where Extra Health & Safety Measures Have Been Taken

Stirling Youth Hostel

Hostel in Stirling

7.8

Good

From $31

4-Star HostelSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryStirling Youth Hostel offers excellent value for money with many guests highlighting it as great or even better value. The facilities, especially the kitchen, are frequently praised for being well-equipped and accessible to all. The combined kitchen and lounge areas are noted for their high standards. The location of the hostel is another strong point, often described as fantastic and set within a beautiful building.

The hostel maintains a high level of cleanliness and the staff routinely receive compliments for their kindness and fabulous service. Guests looking for a good price-performance ratio will be pleased with the single rooms that come with a bathroom and toilet. While some reviews express confusion about the hostel’s four-star rating, the overall feedback suggests that it meets strong expectations in terms of facilities and service. The dining experience, particularly during breakfast, is also positively mentioned. Overall, the hostel seems to deliver a solid experience that many find satisfying and worthwhile.
Show more

Crianlarich Youth Hostel

Hostel in Crianlarich

8.2

Very Good

From $32

Info Categories

4-Star Hostel

Dog Friendly Hostel

Hostel with Parking

Garden Studio for Two

Chalet in Doune

9.7

Excellent

From $172

Info Categories

4-Star Chalet

Chalet with Free Wi-Fi

Chalet with Parking

Rowardennan Youth Hostel

Hostel in Rowardennan

7.9

Good

From $39

Info Categories

4-Star Hostel

Dog Friendly Hostel

Hostel with Parking

The Abbotsford

Guest House in Callander

9.0

Excellent

From $143

4-Star Guest HouseSummary of reviews related to the '4 Star' categoryThe Abbotsford receives high praise for its charming and welcoming atmosphere. Guests repeatedly highlight how beautifully furnished and simply stunning the hotel is. Descriptions such as lovely and cozy paint a picture of a warm and inviting space. Visitors often remark that The Abbotsford is a delightful and memorable stay, not to be missed. While it generally upholds a high standard, some comments suggest that certain amenities, such as door hangers for tidying requests, could improve to align with its 4-star rating. Nonetheless, for those seeking an enchanting and comfortable experience, The Abbotsford stands out as a top choice.
Show more