Info
Summary of reviewsMelville Castle Hotel is a stunning retreat that offers a harmonious blend of historical charm and modern comforts, set in picturesque parklands close to Edinburgh. Guests are consistently impressed by the tranquil and beautiful grounds, complete with well-maintained gardens and scenic footpaths perfect for leisurely strolls. The hotel’s convenient proximity to Edinburgh and its transport links make it an ideal location for both relaxation and exploration of the Scottish capital, combining rural serenity with urban accessibility.
The hotel’s breakfast receives generally positive feedback with many guests praising the delicious, fresh and varied options available via both buffet and à la carte menus. The charming breakfast setting adds to the enjoyable start of the day for many guests, despite occasional issues with service organization and wait times. Dinner at the hotel's restaurant is similarly well-regarded for its exceptional food quality, elegant atmosphere and attentive service from staff members like Gill and Michelle, though some diners find the prices steep and service inconsistent at times.
Accommodations at Melville Castle are spacious, clean and elegantly decorated to maintain the historical ambiance of the property. Many rooms feature period-appropriate furniture, oversized beds and powerful showers, all contributing to a comfortable stay. Guests often appreciate the impressive views and unique features such as four-poster beds. While minor maintenance issues and occasional inconsistencies in cleanliness are noted, the overall room experience is overwhelmingly positive.
Staff at Melville Castle Hotel are frequently commended for their friendliness, professionalism and dedication to guest satisfaction. The team is described as welcoming and attentive with several staff members receiving specific praise for their exceptional service. While there are some instances of less efficient service, particularly at reception and during breakfast, the general consensus is that the staff significantly enhance the overall guest experience.
Regarding Wi-Fi, the connectivity is generally reliable and strong throughout the hotel, including public areas and some courtyard spots. The parking facilities are highly rated for their ample space, convenience and secure environment, adding to the stress-free experience for those traveling by car. The hotel is also noted for its family-friendly atmosphere, offering spacious accommodations and an enchanting environment that delights both children and adults. Outdoor enthusiasts and golf lovers will appreciate the expansive grounds for jogging and the nearby golf courses.
In summary, Melville Castle Hotel provides a luxurious, comfortable and fairy-tale-like stay that combines the best of Scotland’s natural beauty with the convenience of city proximity, backed by a welcoming staff and high-quality amenities.
Show moreRead review summaries for all categories
Categories
