Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In
Come As You Are Inn LLC main photo
Come As You Are Inn LLC
Bed & Breakfast in Sayville NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
$
+3
Info
Categories
Adult Only
Parking
Small
Long Island Vacation Rental 4 Mi to Beach main photo
Long Island Vacation Rental 4 Mi to Beach
Vacation Home in Sayville NYUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Glamorous Pines Home - Fire Island Pines, NY main photo
Glamorous Pines Home - Fire Island Pines, NY
Vacation Home in Sayville NYUS flag
0.0
$
+4
Info
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Luxury 3-bedroom Pines house with 360-degree views main photo
$
+3
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Free Wi-Fi
16 more hotels nearby!
The Pines Men-Only Stay main photo
The Pines Men-Only Stay
3.8 mi from Sayville
Homestay in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.5
Excellent
$
+6
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Heated Pool
Private Pool
Outdoor Pool
Adult Only
Casablanca a Pristine 7Br house 500 ft to beach main photo
Casablanca a Pristine 7Br house 500 ft to beach
3.8 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
0.0
$
+3
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Pristine 7Br house 500 ft to beach main photo
Pristine 7Br house 500 ft to beach
3.8 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
0.0
$
+2
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
The Madison Fire Island Pines main photo
The Madison Fire Island Pines
3.9 mi from Sayville
Guest House in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
9.3
Excellent
$
+6
Info
Categories
Adult Only
Honeymoon
Dog Friendly
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport main photo
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
4.2 mi from Sayville
Hotel in Bohemia NYUS flag
6.4
Rated
From $119
$
+6
Info
Summary of reviews
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport receives commendations primarily for its exceptional location and friendly staff, making it a favored choice for travelers, particularly those requiring easy access to the nearby airport. The hotel's central positioning not only facilitates convenient travel but also provides a safe, accessible environment suitable for various purposes, including attending family events and accessing local attractions. Guests appreciate amenities like 24-hour coffee and tea, which enhance the experience.

Reviews of the breakfast offerings are mixed with many guests finding the area clean and noting the availability of daily newspapers. However, the lack of variety and absence of hot items have left some guests wanting more from their morning meal. The feedback suggests the need for broader and better-maintained breakfast options.

Rooms at the hotel receive mixed feedback. While many guests appreciate their spaciousness, initial cleanliness and the comfort of the beds and pillows, others have pointed out the need for significant updates. Reports of outdated decor, dirty carpets, musty smells and maintenance issues such as worn-out bathtubs and malfunctioning air conditioners suggest that improvements are needed to meet guests' expectations consistently.

Cleanliness is another area with varied reviews. Although the hotel staff is praised for their friendliness and diligence, some guests have experienced cleanliness issues in individual rooms and common areas, indicating a need for better upkeep. Persistent problems such as musty odors, dirty carpets and poorly maintained outdoor areas have been noted repeatedly.

The staff at
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport receive high praise for their welcoming, accommodating and professional demeanor. Specific employees, like Pam and Miguel, have been frequently mentioned for their exceptional service. Despite occasional reports of less attentive service, the overall sentiment emphasizes the staff's positive impact on the guest experience.

While the hotel offers free WiFi, the reliability of the internet connection varies with some guests reporting satisfactory speeds and others encountering slow or sporadic connectivity. Similarly, the comfort of the beds has people divided; some find them clean and cozy, while others encounter issues with outdated mattresses and broken frames.

As a three-star establishment,
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport is recognized for its good value, clean environment and friendly service. However, the dated nature of its facilities and specific maintenance problems suggest that it falls short of fully meeting the expected standards of its rating.

The hotel's pet-friendly policies are a notable highlight with guests appreciating the dedicated pet walking area and the accommodation of dogs in rooms. This feature, along with the convenient location and friendly staff, makes it an appealing option for travelers with pets seeking both comfort and pet-friendly amenities.
Categories
Dog Friendly
3 Star
Honeymoon
Bayfront Home in Patchogue with Deck and Fishing Dock main photo
Bayfront Home in Patchogue with Deck and Fishing Dock
4.2 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Brookhaven NYUS flag
0.0
$
+2
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
El Compound main photo
El Compound
4.3 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Cherry Grove NYUS flag
0.0
$
+1
Info
Categories
Adult Only
67 Lake House main photo
67 Lake House
4.3 mi from Sayville
Hostel in Brookhaven NYUS flag
8.3
Very Good
$
+3
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Small
Grove Hotel main photo
Grove Hotel
4.3 mi from Sayville
Hotel in Cherry Grove NYUS flag
8.8
Excellent
From $170
$
+5
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Adult Only
Cherry Grove Enchantment main photo
Cherry Grove Enchantment
4.4 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Cherry Grove NYUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Rdhaven main photo
Rdhaven
4.5 mi from Sayville
Apartment in Brookhaven NYUS flag
0.0
$
+5
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Stylish Entire Home w/ Pool & Relaxing Patio main photo
Stylish Entire Home w/ Pool & Relaxing Patio
4.5 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Brookhaven NYUS flag
0.0
$
+4
Info
Categories
Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat main photo
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat
4.6 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
0.0
$
+2
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Beautiful 3 BR Near Town & Beach w King Bed main photo
Beautiful 3 BR Near Town & Beach w King Bed
4.8 mi from Sayville
Vacation Home in Brookhaven NYUS flag
0.0
$
+2
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
LoveFINS main photo
LoveFINS
4.8 mi from Sayville
Luxury Tent in Fire Island Pines NYUS flag
4.5
Rated
$
+1
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center main photo
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
4.8 mi from Sayville
Hotel in Ronkonkoma NYUS flag
4.6
Rated
From $126
$
+4
Info
Categories
Business
3 Star
Parking
EV charging stations
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 200+ hotels in and around Sayville
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities