Travelmyth Logo
7,258,491 hotelsin 60 categories
Sign In

Hotels in Sister Bay

200+ HOTELS IN AND AROUND SISTER BAYRanking can be influenced by the commissions we receive.
Country House Resort main photo
Country House Resort
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.4
Excellent
From $131
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Overall, Country House Resort is a luxurious and indulgent stay in a beautiful location. Reviewers highly recommend the outdoor hot tub and love the clean pool and hot tub with stunning views. The spa bath and outside Jacuzzi are also appreciated features for relaxation. Many guests upgraded to a room with a hot tub and even those who visited during off-season were pleased with the hot tub in their room. Some may find the hot tub in the living room strange, but it is a bonus feature that many appreciate. The new showers are fabulous and the location close to Sister Bay enhances the experience. If you're looking for a luxurious stay with the added bonus of a hot tub, Country House Resort is a perfect choice.
Categories
Honeymoon
Dog Friendly
Pool
Open Hearth Lodge main photo
Open Hearth Lodge
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.4
Excellent
From $125
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, Door County, is highly praised for its outstanding location and peaceful atmosphere. Its proximity to popular destinations like Sister Bay, Ephraim, and Fish Creek, combined with a serene setting away from bustling crowds, makes it a preferred choice for exploring the peninsula. The lodge’s charming outdoor amenities, such as fire pits and a fenced-in dog area, enhance the cozy and inviting environment, complemented by friendly and accommodating staff.

Guests appreciate the complimentary breakfast for its variety and quality, including fresh pastries, homemade donuts, and locally sourced produce. The breakfast setting, highlighted by a glass pavilion and inviting fireplace, adds to the delightful morning experience. The rooms are celebrated for their cleanliness and spaciousness, offering modern amenities like electric fireplaces and jacuzzi tubs, which contribute to a homely retreat. Families find the accommodations especially inviting, with dog-friendly rooms and kitchen facilities that cater to all members, including pets.

Immaculate cleanliness across the lodge is a standout feature, with the property described as one of the cleanest experiences by many visitors. Attention to detail in room amenities, such as soft towels and toiletries, enhances the welcoming atmosphere. The staff receives consistent praise for their warm, helpful, and accommodating service, exemplifying hospitality at its finest. The gym, pool, and hot tub facilities are also well-maintained, providing guests with opportunities for exercise and relaxation.

The lodge's family-friendly atmosphere is enriched by numerous activities and thoughtful touches, creating an ideal setting for a memorable getaway. The beds receive positive feedback for their comfort and quality, although occasional remarks about firmness suggest personal preference may vary. Overall, Open Hearth Lodge offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for leisure travelers, with strong recommendations for local attractions and dining options enhancing the visitor experience.

For dog owners, Open Hearth Lodge is a premier destination, offering exceptional pet-friendly amenities and services. The fenced-in dog play area and dedicated pet-friendly rooms ensure a comfortable stay for both pets and their owners. Staff attentiveness further enhances the experience, making Open Hearth Lodge an ideal choice for those seeking a welcoming and well-equipped accommodation option in Door County.
Categories
Golf
Family
Dog Friendly
The Dorr Hotel main photo
The Dorr Hotel
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
The Inn at Little Sister Hill main photo
The Inn at Little Sister Hill
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
8.9
Excellent
From $223
$
Info
Categories
Honeymoon
Parking
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Sister Bay Inn main photo
Sister Bay Inn
Inn in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.2
Excellent
From $187
$
Info
Summary of reviews
Sister Bay Inn in Door County, Wisconsin, is celebrated for its prime location, allowing guests easy access to the scenic attractions of the area while offering a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of downtown Sister Bay. Visitors appreciate the beautifully maintained grounds and the convenience of nearby amenities, contributing to an enjoyable and tranquil stay. The inn's continental breakfast earns positive reviews for its variety, freshness, and cleanliness, providing a pleasant start to the day. Guests find the rooms comfortable and spacious, with modern updates enhancing their overall experience. The accommodations are complemented by inviting outdoor amenities like a heated pool, hot tub, and fire pit, providing numerous options for relaxation.

The inn consistently sets a high standard for cleanliness, with both the rooms and common areas being impeccably maintained. This commitment to cleanliness is accompanied by the exceptional customer service of the friendly and attentive staff, who go out of their way to ensure guests feel welcomed and valued. Their proactive assistance in providing local insights further enhances the stay. Sister Bay Inn’s emphasis on hospitality is reflected through its well-crafted outdoor facilities, enhancing the serene atmosphere and adding to the overall charm of the property.

Although the beds receive mixed feedback regarding firmness, with some guests finding them harder than preferred, the majority highlight comfort as a key feature. Even with minor concerns, Sister Bay Inn offers a delightful, clean, and comfortable getaway experience, leaving a lasting impression on visitors with its blend of accessibility, tranquility, and outstanding service.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Outdoor Pool
Parking
Gym
Pheasant Park Resort main photo
Pheasant Park Resort
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.0
Excellent
From $181
$
Info
Categories
Family
Accessible
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
Outdoor Pool
Coachlite Inn main photo
Coachlite Inn
Inn in Sister Bay WIUS flag
8.3
Very Good
From $116
$
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
3 Star
The Nordic Lodge main photo
The Nordic Lodge
Lodge in Sister Bay WIUS flag
7.5
Good
From $215
$
Info
Summary of reviews
The Nordic Lodge is highly regarded for its serene and prime location, offering guests the perfect balance between tranquility and accessibility. Nestled conveniently near Sister Bay and Ephraim, it provides easy access to the charming locales, shops, restaurants, and parks of Door County. The lodge's peaceful, country-like setting is complemented by spacious rooms featuring beautiful grounds and balconies, making it an appealing retreat. Guests appreciate the friendly staff, clean accommodations, and delightful amenities, including a pool, hot tub, and breakfast options, ensuring comfort and convenience throughout their stay.

Room cleanliness is a consistent highlight, with accommodations often described as spotless and comfortable, despite some minor wear and outdated elements. The well-maintained hot tub and pool facilities are inviting and contribute to the peaceful ambiance of the property. The management's pride in upkeep is evident, leading to a generally well-preserved appearance.

The Nordic Lodge also stands out for its exceptional staff, who are consistently praised for their friendliness and helpfulness, greatly enhancing the guest experience. The team is noted for its accommodating nature, ensuring guest satisfaction and providing excellent service.

The pool and hot tub offer a pleasant experience, with guests appreciating the cleanliness and spaciousness, supporting leisure and exercise. Comfortable lounge chairs and additional features around the pool area contribute to a leisurely and relaxing atmosphere.

Beds at the lodge are frequently praised for their comfort, contributing to a restful sleep experience. While there are some mixed reviews about older mattresses and bed height, the overarching sentiment is one of satisfaction regarding bed comfort.

In summary, The Nordic Lodge offers a charming and quiet environment featuring clean and comfortable accommodations, friendly staff, and relaxing amenities, making it a desirable choice for those visiting Door County despite occasional areas for improvement.
Categories
Pool
Heated Pool
Indoor Pool
Parking
Dog Friendly
Updated Home with Deck 2 Mi to Sister Bay Beach! main photo
Updated Home with Deck 2 Mi to Sister Bay Beach!
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.4
Excellent
$
Info
Sister Bay Home with Yard - Walk to Beach main photo
Sister Bay Home with Yard - Walk to Beach
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Contemporary Retreat with Patio about 1 Mi to Beach main photo
Contemporary Retreat with Patio about 1 Mi to Beach
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.2
Excellent
$
Info
Goose & Twigs main photo
Goose & Twigs
Hotel in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
From $261
$
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Small
Modern Sister Bay Condo Less Than 1 Mile to Beach! main photo
Modern Sister Bay Condo Less Than 1 Mile to Beach!
Apartment in Sister Bay WIUS flag
9.0
Excellent
$
Info
Scandinavian Lodge main photo
Scandinavian Lodge
Accommodation in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Honeymoon
Pool
Indoor Pool
Children's Pool
Outdoor Pool
Free Wi-Fi
Three Sister's Cottage Barn main photo
Three Sister's Cottage Barn
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Parking
Three Sisters main photo
Three Sisters
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Parking
Three Sister's Cottage Barn Guesthouse main photo
Three Sister's Cottage Barn Guesthouse
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
0.0
$
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Parking
Door County Retreat about 3 Mi to Sister Bay Beach main photo
Door County Retreat about 3 Mi to Sister Bay Beach
Apartments in Sister Bay WIUS flag
8.0
Very Good
$
Info
Perfect Retreat for 2 Studio Above Bakery, Dogs! main photo
Perfect Retreat for 2 Studio Above Bakery, Dogs!
Apartment in Sister Bay WIUS flag
7.5
Good
$
Info
Categories
Dog Friendly
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Birch Haven by Simple Life Rentals main photo
Birch Haven by Simple Life Rentals
Vacation Home in Sister Bay WIUS flag
7.0
Good
$
Info
Categories
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
*Additional taxes or fees may apply. Please check the final price before completing your booking.Showing 1-20 out of 200+ hotels in and around Sister Bay
Save more on the App
7,258,491
Hotels
60
Categories
49,804
Regions
208,995
Cities