InfoSummary of reviewsBay Lodging Resort enjoys an enviable location close to downtown Put-in-Bay, allowing guests easy access to local attractions, dining, and nightlife while providing a retreat with its peaceful surroundings. The resort is well-serviced with amenities such as a pool and golf cart rental, enhancing convenience for visitors. Although mixed reviews were given to the breakfast offerings, the resort shines in aspects like room cleanliness, which is frequently praised by guests. The well-maintained accommodations contribute to a comfortable stay, complemented by a helpful and friendly staff. Particularly noteworthy is Jackie at the front desk, whose warm approach leaves a memorable impression on guests.
The resort’s rooms are generally valued for their cleanliness and comfort, offering necessary amenities such as kitchens, despite their often smaller size. Some rooms have been updated, providing a cozy ambiance, though guests suggested improvements in aspects like furnishings, lighting, and room amenities, such as microwaves. The property is appreciated for its serene atmosphere paired with friendly service, both significant in creating a welcoming environment.
The pool area offers a relaxed atmosphere for families, enhanced by an outdoor bar that guests find enjoyable. While the pool is noted for being small and unheated, providing a colder experience, it generally adds to the overall resort ambiance. Golf cart rentals offer convenient access to explore the surroundings, proving popular with visitors looking for ease of transportation close to local attractions.
Guest experiences with bedding are variable, with many finding comfort in the beds provided, although preferences for mattress firmness affect satisfaction. Overall, Bay Lodging Resort balances convenience, cleanliness, and commendable staff service, making it an appealing choice for travelers to Put-in-Bay. Show more
InfoSummary of reviewsOverall, the Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel is a fantastic place to stay with an exceptional staff that goes above and beyond to make guests feel comfortable and welcome. The owners are lovely and the staff is well-organized, warm and welcoming, making it feel like family. Guests have given high praise to individual staff members, like Danti and Joey, who were exceptionally attentive and gracious. Despite some new staff members due to Covid-19, the staff's quality, friendliness and attentiveness ensured a positive and enjoyable experience. The hotel's location on the main strip of Put n Bay's restaurants and bars is also a plus. If you're looking for a memorable stay, the Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel is definitely worth considering. Show more
InfoSummary of reviewsCommodore Resort's cool pool is a standout feature, praised by many guests for its lively atmosphere, swim-up bar and friendly bartenders. Although there were some reports of rowdy crowds and early pool closures, most guests found the pool to be clean and enjoyable. While some mentioned the pool can become crowded at times, the majority agreed that it was one of the hotel's best features. Show more
InfoSummary of reviewsThe Islander Inn shines as a vibrant and inviting choice for visitors, highlighted by its exceptional location and friendly service. Situated in the heart of the action, the hotel offers guests convenient access to downtown attractions, dining, and entertainment, making it an ideal base for exploration. Guests frequently commend the hotel's central position and view it as fantastic and perfect for a lively getaway. Complementing the superb location are the clean facilities and the staff's friendliness and helpfulness, which significantly enhance the overall guest experience.
The rooms at Islander Inn receive praise for cleanliness and comfort, often deemed a pleasant retreat with modern updates that lend a fresh and inviting ambiance. Many appreciate the comfortable beds and the inclusion of amenities like mini-fridges, although some guests have noted that enhancements such as microwaves and coffee machines would further elevate the experience. Despite occasional issues, such as outdated decor or maintenance concerns, the rooms largely provide a solid and comfortable stay.
Cleanliness is a standout feature of Islander Inn, with its rooms and pools frequently receiving accolades for being pristine. The well-maintained exterior and convenient location add to the welcoming atmosphere, ensuring a pleasant environment for guests. The staff, known for their exceptional service, friendliness, and attentiveness, consistently leave a positive impression, contributing to memorable stays.
The pool area emerges as a central highlight, with its clean and beautiful facilities, including multiple pools, a lazy river, and a jacuzzi. The swim-up bar, when open, plus poolside entertainment creates a lively and engaging atmosphere that guests thoroughly enjoy. Proximity to the pools and local attractions further enhances the guest experience.
Despite mixed feedback on bed comfort, with some experiencing discomfort due to hard or lumpy mattresses, the overall attention to cleanliness and maintenance is acknowledged. The Islander Inn ultimately offers a vibrant and enjoyable stay, marked by its exceptional location, outstanding staff, and delightful pool experience. Show more
InfoSummary of reviewsPut-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center is a great option for those looking for a hotel conveniently located near all the main attractions. The location is consistently praised by guests with many describing it as great, perfect and central. The staff is exceptional and the rooms are comfortable, making for an overall good experience worth the trip. The pool area is a highlight for many guests with swim-up bars and pool parties providing plenty of entertainment. While the breakfast received mixed reviews, the breakfast location and quality were positively commented on. The hotel is family-friendly and offers a variety of accommodating room types. Despite some occasional challenges with parking and a few negative comments about rude staff members, most guests seem satisfied with the friendly and attentive staff at Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center. Overall, this resort offers a lovely, comfortable stay that is perfect for a relaxing vacation. Show more
